City of Abbotsford not liable for damage caused by tree falling on resident's trampoline: CRT
If a tree falls on your trampoline and you didn't complain to the City of Abbotsford about it beforehand, is the city still liable?
It's not an abstract question of philosophy, but the central question asked and answered in a case recently decided before B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal.
The answer, according to tribunal vice chair Eric Regehr, is no. The city is not liable.
Homeowner John Camarda took the city to the CRT seeking the maximum of $5,000 in compensation for the cost of repairing a fence and replacing a trampoline that were damaged when a tree fell on his property in November 2022.
According to Regehr's decision, which was posted online Tuesday, there was no dispute that the tree fell, nor that it was owned by the city.
Camarda did not specify the legal basis for his claim in his CRT application, but the city submitted – and Regehr agreed – that the two possible grounds for Camarda's claim were negligence and nuisance.
In response to the negligence allegation, Abbotsford invoked a legal concept known as the "policy defence."
"The policy defence essentially says that governments cannot be held liable in negligence for 'core policy decisions' because they do not owe a duty of care to citizens for policy decisions," Regehr's decision reads.
"The reason this principle exists is that governments must make difficult public policy choices, and it is not the court’s (or the CRT’s) job to judge those choices. Instead, voters judge government policy choices through elections."
The city told the tribunal it has a primarily "reactive" tree management policy, which it was applying when it failed to proactively remove the tree that ultimately fell on Camarda's property.
Abbotsford has hundreds of thousands of trees, and it only actively monitors about 13,000 of them, generally because of past incidents or identified risks, neither of which were present in the case of the tree that fell on Camarda's property, according to the decision.
Regehr accepted that the city's decision not to monitor every tree it owns was a core policy decision.
"The policy is based on budgetary constraints, and high-level employees set the budget through a deliberative process," the decision reads.
"This means Abbotsford owed the applicant no duty of care. Abbotsford can only be liable for a policy decision if the policy itself was irrational or made in bad faith. There is no evidence that any of this is the case. There is also no evidence that Abbotsford failed to properly implement the policy in its handling of the tree. I therefore find that Abbotsford is not liable in negligence for the fallen tree."
Similarly, though a party does not have to owe a duty of care in order to be held liable for nuisance, Regehr found there was no basis for the nuisance allegation either.
To prove nuisance, Camarda would have had to show that the city either knew or ought to have known that the tree was likely to fall, according to the decision.
"There is no evidence here that anyone had complained about the tree or that there had been previous trees falling in the area," the decision reads. "So, Abbotsford did not know and had no reason to know that the tree might fall. This means Abbotsford is not liable in nuisance."
Accordingly, the tribunal member dismissed Camarda's claim. Regehr made note, however, that there was nothing stopping Camarda from bringing a new claim against Abbotsford regarding any damage caused by a second tree that fell in November 2023.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Here's how much more Canadian landlords are asking for now, according to a just-released report
A new report says the average asking rent for a home in Canada in April was up 9.3 per cent compared with a year ago, while a slight month-over-month increase was also recorded for the first time since January.
What is basic income, and how would it impact me?
Parliamentarians are considering a pair of bills aiming to lift people out of poverty through a basic income program, but some fear these types of systems could result in more taxes for Canadians who are already financially struggling.
Canada abstains from Palestinian UN membership vote but supports two-state solution
Canada was one of 25 countries that abstained from a United Nations vote on Palestinian membership that passed with overwhelming support on Friday.
'I may have some nightmares:' Man survives being bitten by 2 sharks in Bahamas
A man who was bitten by two sharks in the Bahamas said Thursday he's 'thankful that I'm here' while sharing his story of survival.
Mexico's president accuses press and volunteer searchers for missing people of 'necrophilia'
The administration of Mexico's president has accused the press and volunteer searchers who look for the bodies of missing people of 'necrophilia,' comments that drew criticism this week.
Rare severe solar storm Friday could bring spectacular aurora light show across Canada
A rare and severe solar storm is expected to bring spectacular displays of the northern lights, also known as aurora borealis, across much of Canada and parts of the United States on Friday night.
Out-of-control wildfire burning near Fort McMurray
As of 9 a.m. on Friday, the wildfire burning 28 kilometres southwest of the northeastern Alberta city was 25 hectares in size.
Magnitude 4.2 earthquake reported off Vancouver Island's west coast
A 4.2-magnitude earthquake was recorded west of Vancouver Island early Friday morning.
WATCH Expecting an interest rate cut in June? Don't bet on it after new jobs data
Canada's labour market rebounded in April, adding more than 90,000 jobs, a staggering number of new positions after four consecutive months of little change.