Protracted dispute over B.C. strata noise settled by tribunal
A B.C. tribunal has ruled on a protracted dispute in which a condo owner described the noise from her upstairs neighbours as "torture" and "violence."
The Civil Resolution Tribunal's decision was posted online Tuesday, describing the conflict, the harms the woman said she suffered as a result, and the strata council's response to the complaints.
Eun Kyung Ahn was claiming a total of $20,125 in damages for the harms she said the noise caused her, which included negative health effects and the loss of her job.
The tribunal did not find she had proven the noise was "intolerable," but did rule that her complaints had not been investigated adequately when they were first made.
"I find that if the strata had more thoroughly and promptly investigated, it may have revealed objectively intolerable noise and sparked the strata to take further action. I find the strata’s half-measures and delays in investigating allowed the noise dispute to linger and bad feelings between Ms. Ahn and the tenants to fester," tribunal member Micah Carmody wrote.
"I find that a fair and prompt investigation would have, at least, prevented Ms. Ahn from several months of frustration with her living situation."
THE NOISE
The dispute began shortly after a family of four with two children moved into the unit above Ahn's in May of 2021, according to the decision. The initial written complaint to the strata council described the noise and the impact Ahn said it was having on her.
"The tenants had been making noise that included children running and yelling, adults stomping, and people throwing, dropping, rolling and moving heavy things on the hard-surface floor. She said she could hear 'each and every step' and had trouble studying, working, and falling asleep," a summary included in the decision said.
"She complained of extreme stress, heart palpitations, anxiety, headache, indigestion, sleep deprivation, tiredness and poor concentration."
In all, Ahn would submit four complaints over a period of roughly six weeks before receiving a response. When a representative from the company managing the strata did respond, Ahn was told that her complaints had been investigated but that the noise did not rise to the level of a bylaw infraction. Although that response included an offer to visit Ahn's unit and assess the noise, the tribunal noted that no one ever followed through.
ESCALATING CONFLICT
A period of relative calm followed Ahn's fifth complaint, after the strata said a visit to the upstairs neighbours showed that foam tiles had been put down and covered by area rugs.
"Ms. Ahn said that since the tenants were making efforts to reduce noise, she would make efforts to put up with the noise," Carmody wrote in his decision.
But a month later a sixth complaint was submitted and the conflict apparently escalated. In December of 2021, roughly five months after the first complaint, Ahn "began posting noise recording videos publicly on YouTube," the tribunal's decision says.
In January of 2022, the upstairs neighbour submitted a noise complaint to the strata alleging that Ahn had "connected a speaker to the ceiling and played a variety of 'zombie music [and] bad annoying sounds like someone banging,'" it said, also alleging Ahn had "spoken profanities through the speaker."
The next day, Ahn was notified that she had been fined $400: $200 for breaching the noise bylaw and $200 for "harassment," the tribunal decision says.
Testing was conducted later that year – 15 months after the initial complaint – and the strata concluded its investigation by finding that the tenants had not violated the noise bylaw. Ahn filed her claim with the tribunal the following month, saying the noise persisted.
THE DECISION
The tribunal awarded Ahn $1,000 in damages as compensation for the way the strata responded to the complaints.
"I find the strata took too long to investigate Ms. Ahn’s complaints, did not take sufficient investigative steps, had no rational basis for concluding that the bylaws were not contravened, and did not consider each complaint on its merits," Carmody wrote.
"I find the strata violated Ms. Ahn’s reasonably-held expectation that it would fairly and reasonably investigate her noise complaints, which was burdensome and unjust. I find the strata was significantly unfair to Ms. Ahn."
The fines the strata imposed on Ahn for violating the noise bylaw were also reversed.
The tribunal did not find there was sufficient evidence to support Ahn's claim that the noise, which she described as "vivid," "unbearable," "torture," and "violence" was objectively intolerable.
Her claim for $20,125 worth of damages was dismissed for that reason and because she had not provided evidence of the negative impacts the noise had on her health or her career.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Here's how much more Canadian landlords are asking for now, according to a just-released report
A new report says the average asking rent for a home in Canada in April was up 9.3 per cent compared with a year ago, while a slight month-over-month increase was also recorded for the first time since January.
What is basic income, and how would it impact me?
Parliamentarians are considering a pair of bills aiming to lift people out of poverty through a basic income program, but some fear these types of systems could result in more taxes for Canadians who are already financially struggling.
Canada abstains from Palestinian UN membership vote but supports two-state solution
Canada was one of 25 countries that abstained from a United Nations vote on Palestinian membership that passed with overwhelming support on Friday.
More than half the Canadians once detained in Syrian camps for suspected ISIS family members have returned home
A total of 29 Canadians have been freed from detention camps in northeast Syria and brought back to Canada since human rights advocates began lobbying for their release years ago.
'I may have some nightmares:' Man survives being bitten by 2 sharks in Bahamas
A man who was bitten by two sharks in the Bahamas said Thursday he's 'thankful that I'm here' while sharing his story of survival.
Rare severe solar storm Friday could bring spectacular aurora light show across Canada
A rare and severe solar storm is expected to bring spectacular displays of the northern lights, also known as aurora borealis, across much of Canada and parts of the United States on Friday night.
Out-of-control wildfire burning near Fort McMurray
As of 9 a.m. on Friday, the wildfire burning 28 kilometres southwest of the northeastern Alberta city was 25 hectares in size.
Mexico's president accuses press and volunteer searchers for missing people of 'necrophilia'
The administration of Mexico's president has accused the press and volunteer searchers who look for the bodies of missing people of 'necrophilia,' comments that drew criticism this week.
Magnitude 4.2 earthquake reported off Vancouver Island's west coast
A 4.2-magnitude earthquake was recorded west of Vancouver Island early Friday morning.