B.C. woman convicted of coughing on grocery worker during pandemic acquitted
A British Columbia Supreme Court judge has acquitted a woman who was sentenced last year to 18 months of probation for intentionally coughing in the face of a grocery worker and assaulting another worker with a grocery cart during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Justice Douglas Thompson on Thursday threw out the convictions for two counts of assault and one count of causing a disturbance, finding the lower court judge erred by not allowing the accused to call a character witness during her trial.
Kimberly Brenda Woolman was found guilty of the charges last April and was sentenced to 18 months of probation in July.
The altercation occurred three years prior, on April 24, 2020, when provincial health orders required stores to limit the number of customers allowed inside and required shoppers to stay at least two metres apart.
Grocery employees testify
Judge Barbara Flewelling presided over the three-day trial, which heard from five employees of the Campbell River store who testified that Woolman refused to follow the store's COVID-19 mitigation measures, refused to leave the store when asked, and shouted "loud invective that COVID-19 was fake," the trial judge wrote in her decision.
Employee Jacqueline Poulton told the court she was following Woolman down a store aisle and asking her to leave when Woolman stopped abruptly, turned to face her from about a metre away and then leaned in to forcibly cough twice in her face.
After staff convinced Woolman to vacate the store, employee Gordon Dawson instructed her to leave her shopping cart behind because it had unpaid items in it. Woolman refused, saying she needed the cart to walk to her car. Employees offered her an empty cart, which she declined, before shoving her cart into Dawson.
"Those were the very early days of the COVID 19 pandemic when scientists and medical professionals were struggling to understand how the virus was transmitted between people," Flewelling wrote.
"It was recognized that it was a respiratory virus. In those early days, there was no medication or vaccine available to cure or to reduce the severity of the infection," she added.
The judge noted that while most British Columbians at that time were able to remain at home, front-line workers who provided essential services did not have that luxury.
"Those front-line workers included the people who went to work every day at Save-On-Foods so that people could buy groceries," she wrote. "Those front-line workers were the people that Ms. Woolman derided and assaulted."
The trial judge also noted that Woolman was similarly aggressive and rude to witnesses and to the court during her trial.
'Error was not harmless or minor'
After sentencing, Woolman appealed her conviction on "myriad grounds… many of which are manifestly without merit," Thompson wrote in his decision to overturn the trial judge's ruling Thursday.
During her trial, Woolman discharged her lawyer and opted to represent herself. Shortly after, she advised the court that she wished to call a character witness, but the Crown prosecution objected, saying such evidence would be irrelevant to the case.
The trial judge sided with the Crown and ruled against hearing from the character witness, "holding that character evidence can be helpful in sentencing proceedings, but character evidence is not admissible on a trial proper whether led by the Crown or an accused," Thompson wrote.
"After this erroneous ruling, the court heard evidence from the last two Crown witnesses," Thompson wrote. "The accused elected not to call evidence. After hearing submissions and reserving judgment, the trial judge delivered her reasons for convicting the appellant on all three counts."
No new trial ordered
The B.C. Supreme Court judge found that the excluded evidence could have provided insight about whether Woolman is a "peaceable person" and whether she was indeed shouting at employees as some witnesses for the prosecution testified.
"The weight of the evidence heard by the judge supported her finding that the appellant shouted," Thompson wrote. "However, the impressions of the Crown witnesses on this issue were not uniform."
"I am not satisfied that the character evidence ruling was harmless in that it related to a minor aspect of the case that could not have had any effect on the outcome," Thompson concluded.
Typically, a successful appeal would merit a new trial in such a case because it is reasonable to believe the accused would be convicted again, even with the character evidence allowed, the judge found.
However, given that Woolman has already served approximately one-third of her 18-month sentence, Thompson ordered a full acquittal of the charges.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Asking rent prices up 9.3% across Canada, Ontario sees only decline: report
A new report says the average asking rent for a home in Canada in April was up 9.3 per cent compared with a year ago, while a slight month-over-month increase was also recorded for the first time since January.
What is basic income, and how would it impact me?
Parliamentarians are considering a pair of bills aiming to lift people out of poverty through a basic income program, but some fear these types of systems could result in more taxes for Canadians who are already financially struggling.
'I may have some nightmares:' Man survives being bitten by 2 sharks in Bahamas
A man who was bitten by two sharks in the Bahamas said Thursday he's 'thankful that I'm here' while sharing his story of survival.
Magnitude 4.2 earthquake reported off Vancouver Island's west coast
A 4.2-magnitude earthquake was recorded west of Vancouver Island early Friday morning.
Mexico's president accuses press and volunteer searchers for missing people of 'necrophilia'
The administration of Mexico's president has accused the press and volunteer searchers who look for the bodies of missing people of 'necrophilia,' comments that drew criticism this week.
WATCH Expecting an interest rate cut in June? Don't bet on it after new jobs data
Canada's labour market rebounded in April, adding more than 90,000 jobs, a staggering number of new positions after four consecutive months of little change.
Out-of-control wildfire burning near Fort McMurray
As of 9 a.m. on Friday, the wildfire burning 28 kilometres southwest of the northeastern Alberta city was 25 hectares in size.
Prince William says wife Kate is 'doing well'
Prince William said on Friday his wife Kate was 'doing well' in a rare public comment about the Princess of Wales as she undergoes preventative chemotherapy for cancer.
'Irate male' assaulted Newfoundland officers with block of cheese, police say
Police in Newfoundland say patrol officers were assaulted Thursday by a "very irate male" wielding a block of cheese.