Manslaughter conviction upheld after B.C. man cites claustrophobia in fatal Costco altercation
British Columbia's highest court has upheld a manslaughter conviction against a Vancouver man who shoved a senior outside a busy Costco store, rejecting his argument that the trial judge failed to consider how his claustrophobia and fear of crowds led to the fatal altercation.
Thomas Stephen Toth was sentenced to 18 months in jail and two years of probation for the death of 86-year-old Orlando Ocampo after an altercation outside the downtown Vancouver Costco on Dec. 20, 2017.
At trial, the jury heard that the two men bumped into each other while leaving the crowded store that morning. A brief verbal argument ensued before Toth, then 57 years old, walked to the curb to wait for a taxi with his 16-year-old daughter.
Upset by the encounter, Ocampo went to speak with a security guard and the two approached Toth about the altercation. Another argument erupted and Ocampo sprayed Toth and his daughter with pepper spray.
Ocampo had turned to walk back towards the store when Toth pushed the senior from behind, causing him to fall, strike his head on the ground and lose consciousness. He died in hospital three weeks later.
Claustrophobia and self-defence
Toth appealed his conviction on the manslaughter charge, arguing the trial judge did not properly instruct the jury to consider how his claustrophobia disoriented his senses and provoked a self-defence response.
He also argued the Costco security guard's testimony, which suggested the fatal shove was neither "justified" nor "necessary" for self-defence since Ocampo was already walking away, was a prejudicial opinion and should not have been allowed as evidence.
Delivering the Appeal Court panel's decision Monday, Justice Barbara Fisher found the lack of jury instruction on claustrophobia and the admission of the security guard's evidence did not constitute significant errors of the lower court.
The judge noted that while Toth's claustrophobia was highlighted by his lawyer during her opening statement at trial, its relevance to the defence's case seemed to diminish as the trial wore on.
That aside, Fisher found the jury was fully aware of Toth's condition, which was exacerbated by the crowds at the store that morning.
"Toth’s claustrophobia was one element of the factual milieu that the jury would not have forgotten, as it was linked to the evidence of his emotional state and his ability to observe and perceive," Fisher said.
Regarding the admissibility of the security guard's evidence, the panel was unanimous in finding the jury had a sufficient understanding of the law of self-defence and was not relying on the guard's testimony as expert opinion on the matter.
"While [the security guard] was a key witness, there were numerous other witnesses who observed the incident, and in the context of all that evidence, [the security guard's] opinion formed but a small part," Fisher said.
The court dismissed the appeal and upheld Toth's conviction in the manslaughter case.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW Is there a cost to convenience? Canada approves new cancer immunotherapy treatment
A new cancer treatment recently approved in Canada promises to cut treatment time down to just minutes, but experts have differing opinions on whether it's what's best for patients.
Air Canada walks back new seat selection policy change after backlash
Air Canada has paused a new seat selection fee for travellers booked on the lowest fares just days after implementing it.
Canada's new dental program offering hope of free care to millions but many dentists aren't signed up
A new Canadian dental care program is offering the hope of free care to millions, but while 1.7 million people have signed up for the plan, only about 5,000 dentists have done the same.
Province boots mayor and council in small northern Ont. town out of office
An ongoing municipal strike, court battles and revolt by half of council has prompted the province to oust the mayor and council in Black River-Matheson.
King Charles III returns to public duties with a trip to a cancer charity
King Charles III returned to public duties on Tuesday, visiting a cancer treatment charity and beginning his carefully managed comeback after the monarch's own cancer diagnosis sidelined him for three months.
NDP says Ottawa's new grocery task force isn't living up to government promises
The federal government says the task force it created to monitor and investigate grocery retailers' practices has not conducted any probes and doesn't have a mandate to take enforcement action.
A group of Toronto tenants have been on a rent strike for a year and say there's no resolution in sight
Dozens of tenants in Toronto's Thorncliffe Park area have now been withholding their rent for one year, and it’s unclear when the dispute will end.
U.K. police arrest man wielding a sword in east London, 5 people are taken to the hospital
A man wielding a sword attacked members of the public and two police officers on Tuesday in the east London community of Hainault before being arrested, police said.
Archeologists search for remnants of Halifax's 250-year-old wall that surrounded the city
Archeologist Jonathan Fowler is using ground-penetrating radar to search for historic evidence of the massive wall that surrounded Halifax more than 250 years ago.