Former Vancouver mayor Kennedy Stewart wins $100K court costs in NPA defamation case
Former Vancouver mayor Kennedy Stewart wins $100K court costs in NPA defamation case
Kennedy Stewart carries his civic election ballot after marking it as he votes at an advance poll in Vancouver, B.C. on Thursday, Oct. 13, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Former Vancouver mayor Kennedy Stewart can recover more than $100,000 in legal costs related to a failed defamation case launched by his political rivals in the Non-Partisan Association, a British Columbia Supreme Court judge has ruled.
Justice Wendy Baker ruled March 20 that the defamation case against Stewart by current and former members of the NPA's board of directors lies “closer to (strategic lawsuits against public participation) than it does to a legitimate contest between reputation and public expression.”
Board members of the once-dominant Vancouver civic party sued Stewart after he issued a news release in January 2021 denouncing “hate and extremism” in the NPA in response to media reports on the party's internal turmoil over an ideological shift to the right.
Baker found the defamation claims had “substantial merit,” but said Stewart's statements were not malicious and were fair game because the issues were in the public interest and had been widely reported.
After the case was dismissed in July 2022, Stewart sought damages, arguing the lawsuit was filed in bad faith for an improper purpose, but Baker ruled that awarding Stewart costs addressed any harm the case may have caused.
The plaintiffs in the case, including businessman Federico Fuoco and lawyer Wesley Mussio, said the news release falsely implied “that the board of the NPA contains extremists, who openly support hate groups, and are spreading hate within their party.”
Baker found the NPA board members' claims had merit because the statements in the news release tended “to lower the reputation of the NPA board within the eyes of a reasonable person.”
Stewart defended the release, saying the “NPA board had not done enough to deny the public imputations of extremism, hate, intolerance, racism, homophobia, misogyny or antisemitism among the NPA board members, as published in the news media.”
Stewart said there were plenty of public news articles written prior to the news release that raised similar allegations, including quotes from “members of the NPA itself.”
“I find that a person reading those media articles could honestly express an opinion that some members of the NPA board appeared to hold such views, and that the NPA board ought to take steps to distance itself from members maintaining them,” Baker's July 2022 ruling says.
Baker's latest ruling on costs says the parties were clearly in “political competition” when the NPA board members filed the lawsuit, and doing so served to limit the former mayor's political expression until it was dismissed.
She found that it gave rise to “a state of affairs which could easily be seen as politically advantageous to the plaintiffs and the NPA.”
The judge also found the NPA board members improperly attempted to disqualify three different lawyers retained by Stewart over conflict-of-interest concerns.
Baker found the squabbles over Stewart's counsel increased his costs and caused him anxiety, ruling that the plaintiffs challenged his choice of lawyers for “strategic reasons, in an inappropriate attempt to limit and thwart Mr. Stewart's defence.”
The judge decided against awarding damages to Stewart under the Protection of Public Participation Act, finding “that the full indemnity costs I have ordered fully addresses any harm to Mr. Stewart arising from this action.”
Lawyers for neither Stewart nor the NPA board members were immediately available for comment.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 22, 2023.
With the latest hike bringing Canada's key interest rates to levels not seen since 2001, one mortgage broker is warning that it may be 'the last straw' for some homeowners with variable mortgages.
It's been a busy, tumultuous few days for Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex as he took his place on the witness stand in his trial against the Mirror Group Newspapers. Here are royal commentator Afua Hagan's top takeaways from his two-day grilling.
Poor air quality is forecast to persist into the weekend across parts of Ontario, as plumes of wildfire smoke blanket the province and prompt school boards to limit outdoor activities.
The Bank of Canada's latest decision to raise its key interest rate comes at a time when many are struggling to afford their homes. CTVNews.ca wants to hear from people in Canada who are going to great lengths to find affordable housing.
One of the architects of the law that governs Canada's prison system says it's understandable people want revenge on killer and serial rapist Paul Bernardo, but that's not what the prison system is designed for.
With social media ever-present in modern life, figuring out when and how to introduce it to children is something every parent will have to deal with eventually. CTV's Your Morning spoke to a child-life specialist about how parents can have that conversation and be positive role models too.
A large wildfire burning on Vancouver Island Wednesday continues to impact traffic on Highway 4, the only highway leading to the west coast communities of Port Alberni, Tofino and Ucluelet.
The man who was found not criminally responsible in the stabbing deaths of five people at a house party in Brentwood more than nine years ago is seeking more freedoms.
The man who was found not criminally responsible in the stabbing deaths of five people at a house party in Brentwood more than nine years ago is seeking more freedoms.
The air quality in Toronto has become so polluted due to forest fires in Quebec and Ontario that strenuous outdoor activities could leave you coughing and with an itchy throat.
A regulatory body has revoked the licence of a Mississauga homebuilder after it says that the company demanded that a buyer pay an additional $518,000 for a property that they already had a contract to purchase.
Further evacuations are necessary in Abitibi and Nord-du-Québec due to forest fires. Although the situation has improved on the North Shore due to rain, no precipitation is expected further west until Monday.
In an interview on CJAD 800 Radio, Quebec Conservative Party leader Eric Duhaime said the new measures in place related to Quebec's ammendments to the French Language Charter have made Quebec a 'laughingstock' and that phone and website messages are 'offensive.'
On Wednesday, the Montreal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) filed a writ of intervention with the housing tribunal (TAL) to plead in favour of two tenants opposing the clause in their lease prohibiting them from owning animals in their dwelling.
Family and friends gathered at the spot Haven Dubois's mother pulled his body from the water eight years ago, ready to embark on a cross Canada journey in his honour.
The chief of the Shelburne Volunteer Fire Department says the blaze near Barrington Lake, which is now classified as “held,” is unlike anything he’s ever seen.
Halifax media outlets were given a tour of the neighbourhoods hardest hit by the Tantallon wildfire Tuesday afternoon and saw firsthand the damage and destruction left behind.
Irving Oil says it’s undertaking a “strategic review” with an eye to its future. In a release Wednesday, the company says it’s looking at a number of options, including the sale of its assets.
A lifejacket and a swift response by the community are credited with saving the life of a swimmer who had drifted from shore near Grand Bend last weekend.
Smoke from wildfires in Quebec and Northern Ontario is finding its way into the region. While the London, Ont. area has escaped the extreme haze seen over parts of Eastern Ontario, a special air quality advisory is in effect — anyone looking up Tuesday evening could see why.
Construction has started on Dundas Street between Quebec and Egerton streets. The work is for the East London Link and is expected to take about two months to complete.
A northern Ontario forest fire that started west of Sudbury on Sunday morning has grown to more than 1,000 hectares and has prompted officials to issue an evacuation order for the immediate area as the number of active fires in the region grows.
Poor air quality is forecast to persist into the weekend across parts of Ontario, as plumes of wildfire smoke blanket the province and prompt school boards to limit outdoor activities.
High levels of air pollution have developed in Waterloo region and Wellington County as smoke plumes from wildfires burning in Quebec and northeastern Ontario continue to blow into the region, Environment Canada says.
Kennedy Stewart carries his civic election ballot after marking it as he votes at an advance poll in Vancouver, B.C. on Thursday, Oct. 13, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
