B.C. homebuyer awarded more than $5K after seller failed to evict basement suite tenant
The corporate seller of a B.C. home has been ordered to pay the buyer more than $5,000 for failing to evict a tenant who refused to leave.
Buyer Ahmed Ali took seller SL Trading Ltd. to the province's Civil Resolution Tribunal, alleging that the company had failed to meet its obligations under the contract of purchase and sale (CPS).
In a decision issued Monday, CRT member Peter Mennie found that Ali had proven his allegations on the balance of probabilities, ordering SL Trading to pay him a total of $5,448.14 in damages, interest and CRT fees.
BASEMENT TENANT REFUSED TO LEAVE
Mennie's decision does not specify where in B.C. the property is located. It does, however, indicate that Ali and SL Trading entered the CPS on April 13, 2021, and amended it on April 30 of that year to reflect a $5,000 reduction in the purchase price and SL Trading's agreement to "repair the property’s deck, boiler, and fireplace." The total purchase price is not specified in the decision.
Relevant sections of the CPS reproduced in Mennie's decision included that Ali would receive "vacant possession" of the home on Aug. 31, 2021, that SL Trading would ensure all appliances – including four stoves, four fridges, two washers and two dryers – would be in working order on that date, that SL Trading would remove all garbage from inside and outside the property, and that it would give eviction notices to the property's tenants.
SL Trading told the CRT that it served the tenants with notice on May 23, 2021, advising them to vacate the property by Aug. 15. The company said it did not receive any dispute notice from the basement tenant – who is unnamed in the decision – and believed that person would move out.
Undisputedly, the basement tenant did not move out. The day after he took possession, Ali began the process of evicting the tenant through the provincial Residential Tenancy Branch, a process that concluded on Nov. 30, 2021, according to the decision.
While SL Trading argued that Ali had assumed the tenancy when he purchased the home, Mennie disagreed.
"The emails in evidence make it clear that Mr. Ali and his realtor asked SL Trading multiple times to confirm that the basement tenant would leave before the possession date," Mennie's decision reads.
"When this did not happen, Mr. Ali’s lawyer informed SL Trading that Mr. Ali would complete the purchase under protest and without prejudice to his ability to sue for damages. Mr. Ali did not agree to assume the tenancy or waive his right under the CPS to vacant possession of the property."
Ali claimed $2,229.59 in costs associated with hiring a lawyer and going through the RTB process. Mennie found these costs had been proven and awarded them to Ali as compensation.
The tribunal member declined to award Ali the $4,225 he claimed for his own time associated with the RTB application – a figure calculated as $100 per hour for 42.25 hours.
"Mr. Ali has provided a breakdown of his time but has not explained why $100 is an appropriate hourly rate," the decision reads. "While I accept that the RTB matter was inconvenient to Mr. Ali, time spent dealing with such inconveniences is not compensable."
GARBAGE AND APPLIANCE ISSUES
Once he had successfully ejected the basement tenant from the property, Ali discovered that the washing machine and refrigerator used by the tenant were not working, and the stove was missing, according to the CRT decision.
SL Trading argued that these issues were the responsibility of the evicted tenant, but Mennie again disagreed, noting that there was a specific clause in the CPS that required the company to provide working appliances at the time Ali took possession.
Ali provided the tribunal with an invoice showing he paid $1,750 to purchase "a used stove, fridge, and washing machine" for the unit, and Mennie awarded him this amount in damages.
Similarly, Ali claimed $1,380 for the cost of removing "a large amount of garbage left behind the house, under the deck, and in the basement suite."
While SL Trading argued that Ali had viewed the property before entering the purchase agreement and agreed to purchase it "as is," Mennie found that photographs provided by Ali clearly showed the company had not adhered to the clause in the CPS requiring it to remove all garbage before Ali took possession.
The tribunal member awarded Ali the $1,380 he claimed, bringing the total amount of damages he had proven to $5,539.59. Because the CRT's small claims jurisdiction limits awards to $5,000 or less, Mennie reduced the amount to $5,000.
That limit doesn't apply to interest or reimbursement of CRT application fees, however. With $273.14 in interest and $175 in fees, the total amount SL Trading must pay Ali within 30 days of the decision is $5,448.14.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW Is there a cost to convenience? Canada approves new cancer immunotherapy treatment
A new cancer treatment recently approved in Canada promises to cut treatment time down to just minutes, but experts have differing opinions on whether it's what's best for patients.
Air Canada walks back new seat selection policy change after backlash
Air Canada has paused a new seat selection fee for travellers booked on the lowest fares just days after implementing it.
Canada's new dental program offering hope of free care to millions but many dentists aren't signed up
A new Canadian dental care program is offering the hope of free care to millions, but while 1.7 million people have signed up for the plan, only about 5,000 dentists have done the same.
Province boots mayor and council in small northern Ont. town out of office
An ongoing municipal strike, court battles and revolt by half of council has prompted the province to oust the mayor and council in Black River-Matheson.
King Charles III returns to public duties with a trip to a cancer charity
King Charles III will return to public duties on Tuesday when he visits a cancer treatment charity, beginning his carefully managed comeback after the monarch’s own cancer diagnosis sidelined him for three months.
NDP says Ottawa's new grocery task force isn't living up to government promises
The federal government says the task force it created to monitor and investigate grocery retailers' practices has not conducted any probes and doesn't have a mandate to take enforcement action.
A group of Toronto tenants have been on a rent strike for a year and say there's no resolution in sight
Dozens of tenants in Toronto's Thorncliffe Park area have now been withholding their rent for one year, and it’s unclear when the dispute will end.
U.K. police arrest man wielding a sword in east London, 5 people are taken to the hospital
A man wielding a sword attacked members of the public and two police officers on Tuesday in the east London community of Hainault before being arrested, police said.
Archeologists search for remnants of Halifax's 250-year-old wall that surrounded the city
Archeologist Jonathan Fowler is using ground-penetrating radar to search for historic evidence of the massive wall that surrounded Halifax more than 250 years ago.