B.C. naturopathic physician's attempt to sue province over non-existent vaccination requirement dismissed
A B.C. woman's attempt to sue the provincial government over a COVID-19 vaccination requirement that doesn't currently exist has been dismissed.
Jennie Weisenburger brought her lawsuit against the College of Naturopathic Physicians of British Columbia and the provincial government, in the form of provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry and Health Minister Adrian Dix.
Weisenburger alleged that the college – on the direction of provincial officials – had restricted her freedom of expression, and that she anticipates that Henry will require naturopathic physicians to be vaccinated against COVID-19 at some point in the future.
"Throughout the height of the pandemic and to date, (Henry) has never issued an order that would require the plaintiff, who is not employed in the public health-care system, to be vaccinated in order to provide her services," reads B.C. Supreme Court Justice David A. Crerar's decision on the case, which was issued Tuesday and published online Wednesday.
"Nor has the defendant college ever imposed such a requirement."
The province's remaining vaccination requirements – which were largely upheld in court last month – apply only to people who work in the publicly funded health-care system.
The defendants asked Crerar to dismiss the case, arguing that Weisenburger's claims were "unnecessary, frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of process."
Crerar agreed. He dismissed Weisenburger's claim and declined to allow her to amend it, describing her proposed amended notice of civil claim as "more a polemic than a pleading."
'Collateral attack'
The judge cited a variety of grounds for dismissing the case, including that it was brought as a civil lawsuit rather than a petition for judicial review.
Weisenburger argued that her case was "a comprehensive claim dealing centrally with the constitutional validity of emergency powers under the (Public Health Act)," according to the decision.
The defendants argued that the case was actually, "in essence, an impermissible collateral attack on the decisions and actions of the provincial defendants and the college, which are properly the subject of a judicial review brought by way of petition, not by way of action."
Crerar agreed with the defendants.
"The essence of the plaintiff’s claim is a challenge to and an attempt to avoid the legal force and effect of the decisions and actions of the defendants in the exercise of their statutorily bestowed powers and responsibilities," the judge's decision reads.
He also rejected Weisenburger's assertion that a petition for judicial review would have been insufficient to secure the remedies she desired – such as monetary damages and orders overturning parts of the Public Health Act.
Crerar noted that the court would have the power to strike down parts of the act in a judicial review case, and that – while monetary damages could not be awarded in such a proceeding – past court precedent has held that merely seeking damages does not make a claim "bulletproof" if it should have been brought as a judicial review petition in the first place.
'Double hypothetical'
Beyond being filed as the wrong type of case, the lawsuit made "no reasonable claim," Crerar ruled.
"The bulk of the plaintiff’s claim is based upon a hypothetical future event that will likely never happen," the judge's decision reads, before quoting multiple paragraphs from Weisenburger's filing that say she "anticipates" the provincial health officer will impose restrictions on her.
"The plaintiff’s claim is based upon a double hypothetical: that the defendants will issue a mandatory vaccination order, and that the mandatory vaccination order will provide no exemptions," the decision reads.
"The potential for exemptions to such a hypothetical order, or the wording of the hypothetical order itself, piles further hypotheticals on further hypotheticals."
The court cannot assume that a vaccine mandate will be imposed, or that it will lack exemptions that will run afoul of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Crerar concluded. Likewise, even assuming the pleaded facts were true, there would be no reasonable cause for legal action, because the mandate has not yet been imposed.
Crerar also listed several other reasons why Weisenburger's claim was bound to fail, and found that the plaintiff had "provided no basis to conclude that the claim is salvageable."
He therefore granted the defendants' application to dismiss the case, without leave to amend and resubmit it.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
EXCLUSIVE Canadian lawyers play key role in money laundering, says financial intelligence report
A report by Canada's financial watchdog obtained by the Investigative Journalism Foundation working in collaboration with CTV News looked at Canadian lawyers' potential role in money laundering schemes, including those by organized crime groups like biker gangs and drug cartels.
Biden, Trump square off tonight in first U.S. presidential debate
Joe Biden and Donald Trump are preparing to square off in their first presidential debate of the campaign tonight as the tight race for leadership of the United States begins to ramp up.
How to watch the Trump-Biden CNN Presidential Debate
U.S. President Joe Biden and presumptive Republican nominee Donald Trump will go head-to-head on Thursday, June 27 in the first-ever debate between a sitting and former U.S. president. Here's how to watch the CNN Presidential Debate, follow along in a live chat with expert analysis on CTVNews.ca, and CTV News Channel's pre- and post-debate specials.
Evacuation planning for Canadians in volatile Lebanon underway: National Defence
As tensions in Lebanon between Hezbollah and Israel increase, Canada’s Department of National Defence confirmed plans to extract Canadians from the volatile country.
21 children are set to exit Gaza in first medical evacuation since early May
Twenty-one critically ill children were set to exit Gaza on Thursday in the first medical evacuation since the territory's sole travel crossing was shut down in early May, Palestinian officials said.
'Godfather' of AI pledges $1 million to fix Ontario Science Centre
A world-renowned Toronto academic known as the 'Godfather' of artificial intelligence has pledged $1 million to repair the roof of the Ontario Science Centre – as long as it stays on its current site.
Original 'Harry Potter' cover art sells for $2.6 million, setting auction record
The original illustration for the first edition of J.K. Rowling’s 1997 novel “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” has sold for a record-breaking C$2.6 million.
'Inhumane': Residents of Toronto condo report stifling temperatures after weeks without air conditioning
Entering their fourth week without air conditioning in their downtown Toronto condo, residents say stifling indoor temperatures have become 'unbearable.'
Bill Cobbs, 'Air Bud' and 'The Sopranos' actor, dies at 90
Bill Cobbs, the veteran character actor who became a ubiquitous and sage screen presence as an older man, has died. He was 90.