Do rental deposits need to be returned? B.C. tribunal rules in favour of would-be tenant who changed his mind
![Room for rent sign A "room available" sign is seen in this undated image. (Shutterstock)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2022/6/9/room-for-rent-sign-1-5940185-1654798116944.jpg)
A would-be tenant will get his rental deposit back even though he backed out of his agreement before moving in, B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled.
The decision, posted Wednesday, outlined a dispute between a potential tenant and a person renting out a room in their home. The potential roommate paid a $250 deposit in August 2021, but when he cancelled his plans, that deposit wasn't returned to him.
The tribunal heard the would-be renter was told he didn't get a refund because the two allegedly agreed that would only happen if a new roommate was found by the end of the month.
In his decision, Richard McAndrew wrote the two did not have a formal rental agreement signed. The person looking to rent the room paid his deposit on Aug. 1, but sent a text message the next day saying he'd changed his mind.
In applying to get his refund back, the potential tenant denied agreeing that he should only get his deposit back if a replacement roommate was found.
McAndrew's decision said the man instead "demanded an immediate, full deposit refund."
"The issue of whether the applicant is entitled to a deposit refund depends on the parties’ original rental agreement," McAndrew wrote.
McAndrew said in his decision both individuals "intended to be bound by the deposit to secure the room rental," since it was paid one month before the room rental was supposed to start.
"So, when the applicant withdrew, he breached the parties' contract. This does not mean, however, that the respondent is entitled to keep the deposit," McAndrew wrote.
"I find that the respondent is only entitled to keep any portion of the applicant’s deposit necessary to offset the damages suffered from his breach of contract. The respondent has the burden of proving that they suffered any such loss or damage."
While the person renting out the room claimed they had a hard time finding a replacement, the initial would-be tenant said the rental listing was taken offline.
"The applicant texted the respondent on Aug. 5, 2021 asking if they found a new roommate because the listing was gone," McAndrew wrote.
"Further, the applicant says that he also checked the classified listing service on Aug. 9, 2021, Sept. 7, 2021 and Oct. 28, 2021 and he says that the respondent's roommate listing was not displayed on any of those dates, which the respondent did not dispute."
McAndrew determined the individual looking for a tenant "voluntarily stopped posting their advertisement" and "likely did so because they had found a new roommate by then" or because they'd decided they didn't want to rent the room out anymore.
As a result, McAndrew said the person renting out the room didn't prove they suffered in any way from the cancelled tenancy and ordered the deposit be returned. In addition, the would-be tenant was awarded just over $125 to cover CRT fees and some interest.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7029443.1725744633!/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.png)
Police release video of Toronto plaza shooting that killed university student
A university student from Brampton was killed when two shooters fired indiscriminately into a crowded plaza in Toronto last month in what police say was a 'cowardly act.'
'Hopeless and helpless': Regina mother seeks help to treat rare spinal disease
Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.
The iPhone is getting a 'glow' up. What to expect from Apple's Monday event
Apple excited fans with its vision for its 'Apple Intelligence' artificial intelligence system earlier this year. Now, it's time for the company to prove it really works.
No more porta-potties at B.C. construction sites starting Oct. 1
What some B.C. construction workers describe as the worst aspect of their jobs will be coming to an end next month, the province announced.
'Extremely vigorous' wildfire activity in central B.C. prompts crews to back off for safety
The wildfire fight in central B.C. intensified Friday, according to officials.
Aryna Sabalenka beats Jessica Pegula to win the U.S. Open for her third Grand Slam title
Aryna Sabalenka got past Jessica Pegula 7-5, 7-5 in a rollicking U.S. Open women’s final Saturday to win her first championship at Flushing Meadows and third Grand Slam title of her career.
They were due to leave for their dream cruise in May. Three months on they’re still stuck at the departure port
It was the years-long cruise that was supposed to set sail, but saw its departure postponed… postponed… and postponed again.
Trudeau insists he's staying on as Liberal leader. But what if he changes his mind?
The Liberal caucus is set to meet in Nanaimo, B.C., next week for a retreat ahead of the fall parliamentary sitting. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau insists he will lead his party into the next election despite polls citing his unpopularity among Canadians. Here's a look at what would happen if he decided to call it quits.