$275K in fines for real estate agents who allowed fraudsters to sell B.C. home that wasn't theirs
Four real estate agents and an associated brokerage have agreed to pay a combined $275,000 in fines to the BC Financial Services Authority for their roles in facilitating a fraudulent transaction.
Five consent agreements involving Pacific Evergreen Realty were posted on the BCFSA website Wednesday. All of them relate to a real estate transaction that took place in November and December 2019 involving a fraudulent power of attorney document and an absentee "owner" who did not actually own the property being sold.
While some of the consent agreements contain more detail than others, all of them are clearly referring to the same transaction.
DETAILS ABOUT THE HOME
The most detailed account of what happened can be found in the consent agreement between the BCFSA and Lok Chi Annie Fong, who was a managing broker for Pacific Evergreen at the time of the transaction.
All of the agreements have been redacted to remove identifying information about the property, its true owner, the alleged fraudsters and various other parties not subject to BCFSA discipline proceedings.
Fong's is the only consent agreement that identifies the property's location, describing it as having a civic address in Richmond, B.C., and an assessed value of $2,278,000 as of July 1, 2019.
The true owner, referred to as "Owner 1" in the documents, was a woman born in October 1983 in Chengdu, China, who had been registered on the title to the property since April 2004, when she would have been just 20 years old.
"At all material times, Owner 1 had sole legal and beneficial ownership of the property and sole authority to dispose of it in any way," the consent agreement reads.
On Nov. 15, 2019, a man referred to in the documents as "Seller 1" contacted Tracy Xiaomei Li, another real estate agent working as a licensed representative of Pacific Evergreen.
The following day, Li met Seller 1 at the property. The man introduced himself as the executive assistant of the property's purported owner, a man referred to in the documents as "Fake Owner 1."
Seller 1 told Li that Fake Owner 1 was in Toronto, but had given Seller 1 power of attorney to represent him in conducting the sale.
A power of attorney document did exist, though Seller 1 did not share it with Li at that first meeting, according to the consent agreements. The document had been signed and notarized in Vancouver the day before the meeting, and Fake Owner 1 had provided a fake B.C. driver's license to the notary.
Seller 1 gave Li and her assistant – referred to as Assistant 1 – a tour of the property, saying that Fake Owner 1 had never lived there and had rented it out. He claimed the owner had had "very bad experiences" with the last tenant, saying the tenant stopped paying rent and stole appliances.
"The property was vacant and appeared to have been broken into," the Fong consent agreement reads.
"It was missing all removable appliances including the fridge, washer, dryer, and dishwasher. Some copper piping had been taken from the mechanical room in the garage and a bathroom cabinet was missing legs."
THE TRANSACTION
At the meeting, Seller 1 told Li and her assistant that Fake Owner 1 had no intention of fixing the property and was willing to sell it for $1.8 million.
"Seller 1 refused to have the property listed on the MLS system because he wanted to 'keep it quiet' and 'do (a) quick transaction,'" the Fong consent agreement reads.
Shortly after the meeting with Seller 1, Li went to Pacific Evergreen's Richmond office and told other licensees there about the situation. Another real estate agent, David Chian Wei Yang, was present at the time and said he might have a buyer, according to the agreement.
Yang called a representative of his client, who was interested and agreed to send Li an offer.
Over the ensuing two weeks, Li, Yang, Fong and Pacific Evergreen managing broker Lo-Ming Lee each were told at least once that the circumstances of the transaction – on the seller's side – seemed suspicious.
Li made efforts to get identification documents from Seller 1 and Fake Owner 1, but only ever received photos of the latter's ID, according to the consent agreements.
Despite the red flags associated with the sellers and the various conversations within Pacific Evergreen expressing suspicion about them, the sale completed on Nov. 29, 2019, for a price of $1,725,000.
Both Li and Yang received commissions from the sale on Dec. 6, 2019.
On April 2, 2020, the actual owner of the property filed a lawsuit in B.C. Supreme Court against Li, Yang, Pacific Evergreen, Seller 1 and several other entities, including the notary, Seller 1's lawyer, and the two companies that bought the property.
The Pacific Evergreen defendants, including Li and Yang, have since been removed from that lawsuit, which remains before the courts, according to the Fong consent agreement.
MISCONDUCT AND FINES
Li, Yang, Fong, Lee and Pacific Evergreen all admitted to misconduct related to the transaction in consent agreements with the BCFSA.
Li and her Personal Real Estate Corporation received the stiffest penalty, agreeing to pay the BCFSA a $100,000 penalty, plus $7,000 in "enforcement expenses."
She also agreed to complete the Real Estate Trading Services Remedial Education Course at UBC's Sauder School of Business and to be subject to "enhanced supervision" by a managing broker for six months.
In her consent agreement, Li admitted to nine instances in which she violated the "duty to act honestly and with reasonable care and skill" set out in the provincial Real Estate Services Act and its associated rules.
Some of these instances included failing to take "reasonable measures to confirm that Seller 1 was duly authorized to deal with the property in relation to its sale" and failing "to take reasonable measures to alert other persons acting in relation to the sale of the Property of the suspicious circumstances."
Li also falsely stated on a document that she had ascertained Seller 1 and Fake Owner 1's identities by viewing their driver's licences on Nov. 16, 2019, when in fact she saw Seller 1's for the first time three days later and never saw the original of Fake Owner 1's ID.
Similarly, she provided a document to Seller 1 that indicated both she and Yang were "designated agents for the buyer," when, in fact, only Yang was.
For his part, Yang and his PREC agreed to pay a $50,000 penalty and $5,000 in enforcement expenses to the BCFSA. He also agreed to take the UBC remedial education course.
His consent agreement lists two instances of misconduct: First, he failed to properly disclose to the buyer whether he would be representing them or not. And second, he "failed to take reasonable steps to alert other persons acting in relation to the sale of the property of the suspicious circumstances surrounding the sale and Seller 1’s conduct."
Fong's consent agreement calls for her to pay a $50,000 penalty and $5,000 in enforcement fees. She must also take the UBC course and is banned from being a managing broker for six months.
According to the document, Fong admitted to failing to provide adequate supervision to both Li and Yang, and failing to take adequate steps to address each of her subordinates' misconduct when she became aware of it.
Lee's consent agreement also includes a $50,000 penalty and a $5,000 enforcement fee. He must take the UBC course and is banned from being the sole managing broker of any brokerage for one year.
His misconduct was the same as Fong's: Failing to provide adequate supervision and failing to adequately address Li and Yang's misconduct when he became aware of it.
Both managers' agreements specifically mention their failure to ensure that Li and Yang ceased providing real estate services for Seller 1 until they had taken sufficient steps to ensure his power of attorney was valid.
Finally, the brokerage itself admitted to one instance of misconduct in its own consent agreement with the BCFSA.
According to that agreement, Pacific Evergreen committed misconduct by failing to ensure that "before providing trading services to or on behalf of a party to a trade in real estate, licensees engaged by the brokerage, including T Li and D Yang, disclose(d) to the party accurate copies of the Disclosure of Representation in Trade documentation."
The brokerage agreed to pay a $25,000 penalty, plus $5,000 in enforcement expenses. It also agreed to submit a "compliance plan" to the BCFSA within 30 days of the consent agreement taking effect.
The plan must "address the identification of, reporting of, and both the brokerage’s and individual related licensee’s response to suspicious transactions, including but not limited to possibly fraudulent transactions," according to the agreement.
In all, the fines imposed on the four individuals and the brokerage add up to $275,000, plus another $27,000 in enforcement expenses. This means the total amount owed to the BCFSA under the agreements is $302,000.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
What is a 'halal mortgage'? Does it make housing more accessible?
The 2024 federal budget announced on April 16 included plans to introduce “halal mortgages” as a way to increase access to home ownership.
Here's where Canadians are living abroad: report
A recent report sheds light on Canadians living abroad--estimated at around four million people in 2016—and the public policies that impact them.
Deadly six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 sparked by road rage incident
One person was killed in a six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 in Innisfil Friday evening.
Chants of 'shame on you' greet guests arriving for the annual White House correspondents' dinner
An election-year roast of U.S. President Joe Biden before journalists, celebrities and politicians at the annual White House correspondents' dinner Saturday.
Opinion I just don't get Taylor Swift
It's one thing to say you like Taylor Swift and her music, but don't blame CNN's AJ Willingham's when she says she just 'doesn't get' the global phenomenon.
Invasive and toxic hammerhead worms make themselves at home in Ontario
Ontario is now home to an invasive and toxic worm species that can grow up to three feet long and can be dangerous to small animals and pets.
Harvey Weinstein hospitalized after return to New York from upstate prison
Harvey Weinstein’s lawyer said Saturday that the onetime movie mogul has been hospitalized for a battery of tests after his return to New York City following an appeals court ruling nullifying his 2020 rape conviction.
'We are declaring our readiness': No decision made yet as Poland declares it's ready to host nuclear weapons
Polish President Andrzej Duda says while no decision has been made around whether Poland will host nuclear weapons as part of an expansion of the NATO alliance’s nuclear sharing program, his country is willing and prepared to do so.
Central Alberta queer groups react to request from Red Deer-South to reinstate Jennifer Johnson to UCP caucus
A number of LGBQT+2s groups in Central Alberta are pushing back against a request from the Red Deer South UCP constituency to reinstate MLA Jennifer Johnson into the UCP caucus.