Lewd gestures, 'malicious lies' and a bag of dog feces in a car among allegations in B.C. neighbours' dispute
A dispute among neighbours that devolved into daily drive-by insults and accusations that a bag of dog feces was deliberately left in one person's car was adjudicated by B.C.'s small claims tribunal this week.
The conflict among residents of a mobile home park in Kelowna dates back to June of last year, according to the decision posted online Tuesday.
Shelly Stefanishion filed a claim seeking $5,000 in damages. Her neighbours, Bradley Baldwin and Donna Lee Power, filed a claim for the same amount – the maximum allowed by B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal. Both sides were alleging nuisance.
"A nuisance occurs when one person substantially and unreasonably interferes with another person’s quiet use and enjoyment of their land," the decision said.
The origin of the antipathy, it noted, may have been related to a dispute over a dog. But tribunal member Eric Regehr declined to weigh in on the initial confrontation, instead turning his attention to what happened after the relationship soured.
DOG FECES AND DAILY INSULTS
First, the tribunal addressed the matter of the bag of dog feces. In support of her claim that her neighbours had placed it in her car the day after an altercation, she submitted a photo. Baldwin and Power countered by saying that this was not proof they were to blame, saying someone else had left it.
Regehr agreed this was possible.
"There is no direct evidence that it was the respondents who put the dog feces in her car," he wrote. "I find that she has not proven that the respondents put the dog feces in her car."
Stefanishion also said the couple began yelling at her every time they passed her house, which the tribunal pointed out the pair would have done every time they entered or exited the complex. In support of that claim, Stefanishion produced a log she'd kept of each interaction.
"The log indicates that the respondents usually called her a liar, but there are also entries describing lewd insults and gestures," the decision says.
Additionally, a Telus worker who was at Stephanishion's home during one of the instances of these interactions provided a statement in which he described the couple's yelling as "very intimidating."
In response, Bradley and Power admitted to calling Stephansion a liar in order to "shame her," but also said that this was OK because it was true.
The tribunal was not persuaded.
"Given that the respondents admitted to wanting to shame Ms. Stefanishion and given the log’s likely accuracy, I find that the respondents likely also directed offensive gestures and lewd insults at Ms. Stefanishion. Again, they do not directly dispute this. Ultimately, it does not matter exactly how many times the respondents insulted Ms. Stefanishion. I find that the respondents persistently insulted Ms. Stefanishion while she was at home."
Because of this, Regehr said Stefanishion's allegation of nuisance was founded, on a balance of probabilities, and awarded her $500.
"I find that a reasonable person would consider the respondents’ persistent insults and lewd gestures over many weeks to substantially interfere with their use and enjoyment their home," the decision said.
'PERSISTENT CAMPAIGN' OF 'MALICIOUS LIES'
In their claim, Bradley and Powers said their neighbour was actively trying to recruit other people in the park to side with her in the ongoing dispute in a "persistent campaign" of "malicious lies" that alienated them from other residents. They also said Stephanishion would call them "losers" and make "lewd gestures" when they passed her home.
"It is undisputed that none of these alleged incidents occurred on the respondents’ property, although the respondents say that her conduct led them to feel 'trapped in their home,'" Regehr said.
However, he did not find that any of this impacted the couple's "quiet use" or "enjoyment" of their home. He also found that Stephanishion's yelling was likely a response to the pair's insults.
Their claim was dismissed.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
B.C. seeks ban on using drugs in 'all public spaces,' shifting approach to decriminalization
The B.C. government is moving to have drug use banned in 'all public spaces,' marking a major shift in the province's approach to decriminalization.
Orca calf that was trapped in B.C. lagoon for weeks swims free
An orca whale calf that has been stranded in a B.C. lagoon for weeks after her pregnant mother died swam out on her own early Friday morning.
Trump's lawyers try to discredit testimony of prosecution's first witness in hush money trial
Donald Trump's defence team attacked the credibility Friday of the prosecution's first witness in his hush money case, seeking to discredit testimony detailing a scheme between Trump and a tabloid to bury negative stories to protect the Republican's 2016 presidential campaign.
Sophie Gregoire Trudeau on navigating post-political life, co-parenting and freedom
Sophie Gregoire Trudeau says there is 'still so much love' between her and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, as they navigate their post-separation relationship co-parenting their three children.
Air traveller complaints to Canadian Transportation Agency hit new high
The Canadian Transportation Agency has hit a record high of more than 71,000 complaints in a backlog. The quasi-judicial regulator and tribunal tasked with settling disputes between customers and the airlines says the backlog is growing because the number of incoming complaints keeps increasing.
More than 115 cases of eye damage reported in Ontario after solar eclipse
More than 115 people who viewed the solar eclipse in Ontario earlier this month experienced eye damage after the event, according to eye doctors in the province.
'I was scared': Ontario man's car repossessed after missing two repair loan payments
An Ontario man who took out a loan to pay for auto repairs said his car was repossessed after he missed two payments.
76ers All-Star centre Joel Embiid says he has Bell's palsy
Philadelphia 76ers All-Star centre Joel Embiid has been diagnosed with Bell’s palsy, a form of facial paralysis he says has affected him since before the play-in tournament.
U.S. flight attendant indicted in attempt to record teen girl in airplane bathroom
An American Airlines flight attendant was indicted Thursday after authorities said he tried to secretly record video of a 14-year-old girl using an airplane bathroom last September.