B.C. landlord ordered to pay $5,400 for tenant's spitting, garbage-tossing, vandalism
A B.C. landlord has been ordered to pay $5,400 in strata fines racked up by a former tenant who was accused of breaching the building's bylaws 75 times.
Those breaches included threatening the building manager, doxing strata council members, vandalizing common property, throwing garbage on the lobby floor, spitting on a wall, and "wiping discharge from the tenant's dog's eye and smearing it on the elevator wall," according to a recent decision from the province's small claims tribunal.
The building’s strata took condo owner Amrit Paal Burmy to the Civil Resolution Tribunal seeking $9,400 in unpaid fines for his former tenant’s alleged behaviour, and was awarded more than half that total – though tribunal member Eric Regehr also sided with the landlord and dismissed $4,000 in fines on technicalities.
Between the strata and Burmy, there was no disagreement on whether the breaches took place.
“The tenant disputed some of the allegations at the time, but in this dispute, the owner does not specifically contest any of the allegations,” Regehr noted in his decision. “Most of the allegations are undeniable anyway because they are either written communications or conduct captured on surveillance video.”
But for some of the most serious allegations, Burmy argued the strata failed to properly apply its own bylaws, and Regehr agreed.
The strata issued $3,200 in fines for harassing emails, texts and social media posts from the tenant, including posts that doxed council members by sharing their “personal contact information and places of employment alongside allegations that they are all racists,” according to the decision.
For those incidents, the strata accused Burmy’s tenant of violating the building’s bylaw 8.1, which, among other things, bars the “use of a strata lot or common property” in ways that cause a nuisance or hazard to others.
Burmy successfully argued emails, texts and social media posts couldn’t violate that bylaw because they do not involve “use” of the building.
“I have no doubt that the tenant’s conduct interfered with the strata council members’ ability to manage the strata and feel safe in their homes,” Regehr wrote.
“However, I do not consider sending emails and posting to social media to be part of the ‘use’ of a strata lot, even if the tenant was home when they composed them. Digital communication is inherently mobile and unconnected to any specific location.”
The tribunal member noted he would have upheld those fines if they had been applied under the building’s bylaw 45, which warns that “disrespectful behaviour towards owners, residents, visitors, and contractors” won’t be tolerated.
Burmy also managed to get another $800 in fines tossed because the tenant had not been properly notified.
Under B.C.’s Strata Property Act, stratas must notify both the landlord and tenant about alleged bylaw breaches, give them an opportunity to respond, then notify them in writing about whether the strata council has approved a fine.
For four approved fines of $200, the tribunal found the strata had only completed half of that final step by notifying the landlord in writing, but not the tenant.
“These procedural requirements are strict, with no leeway,” Regehr wrote. “If the strata does not perfectly comply with (the SPA), any resulting fines are invalid.”
Burmy was also ordered to pay his strata $296.11 in pre-judgment interest and $112.50 in tribunal fees, for a total of $5,808.61 – though the landlord might be able to recover most of that money from his former tenant.
According to a B.C. government guide on renting in strata properties, while stratas can pursue a tenant’s fines from the landlord, the tenant “will then owe this sum to the owner.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Laws that could get Canadians in trouble in tourism hotspots
There are some laws in popular tourist destinations around the world that could land Canadian travellers in mild-to-serious trouble if they're not careful. Don't let these local laws land you in hot water during your next vacation abroad.
Jasper evacuees forced into B.C. to flee fires told to make U-turn to Alberta for aid
Thousands of wildfire evacuees forced from Jasper National Park into British Columbia along smoke-choked mountain roads Monday night were directed Tuesday to make a wide U-turn and head home if they needed a place to stay.
Polar bear at Calgary Zoo died by drowning following 'crushing' injury
The Wilder Institute/Calgary Zoo has revealed the cause of death for polar bear Baffin last week.
Clip resurfaces of Vance criticizing Harris for being 'childless,' testing Trump's new running mate
Comments Donald Trump’s running mate JD Vance made in 2021 questioning Vice President Kamala Harris’ leadership because she did not have biological children have resurfaced, testing the young conservative senator in his early days campaigning as part of the Republicans' presidential ticket.
Pennsylvania state police commissioner reveals stunning details about Trump shooting
A local law enforcement commissioner revealed during a House Homeland Security hearing on Tuesday stunning new details about the security failures that led to the near assassination of Donald Trump, raising more questions for the embattled U.S. Secret Service.
Trudeau hand-picking candidate in Montreal byelection riles aspiring contenders
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's decision to hand-pick a candidate for a riding in an upcoming Montreal byelection isn't being well-received by three aspiring contenders who spent months campaigning only to be shunted aside.
Edmonton gas station employee found guilty of terrorism charges in the U.K.
An Edmonton man has been convicted of multiple charges under the Terrorism Act in the United Kingdom.
Celine Dion lands in Paris amid reports of performance at the Olympics
Speculation is mounting that Celine Dion will make an appearance at the Paris Olympics after landing in the French capital days before the opening ceremony.
Quebec mom devastated after man who killed her daughter in hit-and-run gets out after 5 months
A Montreal-area mother is furious with Quebec's justice system because the man who killed her 25-year-old daughter in a 2022 hit-and-run was released from jail after only serving one-sixth of his sentence behind bars.