Appeal court dismisses District of North Vancouver's bid to avoid paying woman $900K
B.C.'s highest court has rejected the District of North Vancouver's attempt to avoid paying $900,000 in compensation to a woman whose home it expropriated for highway construction in 2019.
The district paid Juanna Patricia Hanlon $2 million in November 2018 for her home on Forsman Avenue in the Lynnmour neighbourhood.
The advance payment was intended to capture the fair market value of the home and allow the municipality to complete construction on improvements to the Upper Levels Highway.
Hanlon and the district were unable to agree on a final sale price for the property, however, and ended up in court.
In May 2019, the district won an injunction requiring Hanlon to vacate the property by May 31 of that year to allow construction to proceed.
Hanlon left the property, but took the district to B.C. Supreme Court, seeking additional compensation under the Expropriation Act.
Last year, a judge ruled in Hanlon's favour, finding that the appropriate value for the property in November 2018 was $2.9 million, and ordering the district to pay Hanlon $900,000 to make up the difference between that value and its initial payment.
On Thursday, a three-judge panel of the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld the lower court's ruling, dismissing the district's appeal in the case.
According to the appeal decision, the municipality argued that the Supreme Court judge had erred in three ways:
First, he had failed to appropriately consider the fact that the property was listed for sale in 2016 and 2017 for $1.9 million and received no offers at that price.
Second, the judge placed too much weight on sales across the street from Hanlon's home, which were a land assembly and shouldn't have been considered comparable.
Third, he compounded his second error by using these other sales in calculating the rate at which property values in the district were increasing, generally.
Writing for the three-judge panel, B.C. Court of Appeal Chief Justice Robert James Bauman rejected each of the district's arguments.
He found that none of the objections the municipality raised to the lower court's decision dealt with errors the judge had made in interpreting the law.
Rather, each alleged error amounted, in Bauman's estimation, to a difference of opinion between the district and the trial judge.
"In my view, the judge’s careful review of the evidence and his acceptance, in large part, of the expert opinions tendered by Ms. Hanlon leave the district in the position of endeavouring to retry the case in this court," Bauman wrote. "Absent reviewable error, that is for naught."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Poilievre kicked out of Commons after calling Prime Minister Justin Trudeau 'wacko'
Testy exchanges between the prime minister and his chief opponent ended with the Opposition leader and one of his MPs being ejected from the House of Commons on Tuesday -- and the rest of Conservative caucus walking out of the chamber in protest.
Baby, grandparents among 4 people killed in wrong-way police chase on Ontario's Hwy. 401
A police chase which started with a liquor store robbery in Bowmanville Monday night ended in tragedy some 20 minutes later when a suspect fleeing police entered Highway 401 in the wrong direction and caused a pileup which killed an infant and the child's grandparents, as well as the suspect, investigators say.
Man dies after suffering cardiac arrest while waiting in ER, widow wants investigation
When an ambulance took David Lippert to the hospital in March of 2023, the 68-year-old Kitchener, Ont., executive was hoping to find out why he was feeling weak and unable to walk. Some 24 hours later, he was found unresponsive in the ER.
Sword-wielding man attacks passersby in London, killing a 14-year-old boy and injuring 4 others
A man wielding a sword attacked members of the public and police officers in a northeast London suburb Tuesday, killing a 14-year-old boy and injuring four other people, British authorities said.
Conservatives push motion calling for Carney to testify, say it's about 'accountability'
The federal Conservatives made good on their promise to push for former Bank of Canada governor Mark Carney to testify before MPs, resulting in a heated political debate in Ottawa on Tuesday.
Freeland previews omnibus budget bill, proposed capital gains tax change left out
Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland will be tabling yet another omnibus bill to pass a sweeping range of measures promised in her April 16 federal budget, though left out of the legislation will be the government's proposed capital gains tax change.
London Drugs stores remain closed, 'cybersecurity incident' may have breached personal data
London Drugs says it is working with third-party security experts as the company tries to reopen dozens of stores across Western Canada that were shuttered by a cybersecurity incident Sunday.
McGill requests 'police assistance' over pro-Palestinian encampment
McGill University says it has 'requested police assistance' about the pro-Palestinian encampment on its lower field.
WATCH Arnold Schwarzenegger spotted filming in Elora, Ont.
The name of the project has not been officially released although it’s widely believed to be the Netflix series FUBAR.