Unusual property assessment appeal seeks to increase, not lower, Surrey home's value
![Surrey Surrey is seen in this file image. (Murray Titus / CTV Vancouver)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2019/3/21/surrey-1-4347045-1627383331331.jpg)
A Surrey homeowner recently won an appeal of their property assessment, but unlike most people who appeal their homes' value, they weren't trying to get it reduced.
Surinder P. Gulati went to B.C.'s Property Assessment Appeal Board to challenge the assessed value of their house on 140 Street near 88 Avenue in Surrey.
Gulati argued that the 1,195-square-foot, one-storey home with a finished basement, six bedrooms and three bathrooms should be valued at $1,440,000, rather than the $1,270,000 value BC Assessment assigned it for 2024.
In support of this position, Gulati made a variety of arguments that PAAB panel chair John Bridal rejected as inappropriate in a decision posted on the board's website earlier this month.
Gulati told the appeal board the home, which was built in 1981, had recently been extensively renovated. They claimed that the amount of the assessed value allocated to the structure itself was insufficient because of these renovations, and that the building's replacement cost for insurance purposes was now $692,000.
Gulati claimed the renovation itself cost more than $135,000, which was the portion of the assessed value attributed to buildings, rather than land value, according to the decision.
Bridal noted that insurance values are not the same as market value, and the assessment process generally considers total value of land and buildings together, despite separating that value into the categories of "land" and "improvements."
The panel chair similarly dismissed Gulati's claims that the property generated $53,400 in net rental income.
"I find the income approach is not typically valid for single-family residential properties in Greater Vancouver, as there tends to be a tenuous relationship between rental income and sale prices," Bridal's decision reads.
"Buyers and sellers of these residential properties do not commonly focus on income-earning characteristics when establishing prices. However, even if this was a valid appraisal approach here, there is insufficient evidence presented to make any reasonable finding."
Likewise, Gulati argued that the assessor had inappropriately considered traffic noise from the property's location at the intersection of two busy streets as a negative factor, reducing the overall value.
The appellant argued the location on two busy streets should add to the value "as it strengthens the subject’s commercial redevelopment potential."
"The appellant notes there is a commercial complex across the street," the decision reads.
"However, the assessor provides evidence to show this suggested highest and best use is not supported by the zoning, Official Community Plan, or conformity with the neighbourhood. I find the Assessor’s evidence is convincing that the subject’s current use is its highest and best use. As such, I agree the traffic influence is more likely to be a negative factor."
Despite rejecting most of Gulati's arguments, the panel chair did increase the value of the property after comparing it to recent sales in the area.
Bridal set the home's value at $1,369,000, with all of the increase attributed to improvements, rather than land value.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7029792.1725811934!/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.png)
Over 200 firearms seized in Waterloo weapons investigation
According to police, during a traffic stop officers noticed firearms and ammunition inside the vehicle.
Bloc Quebecois ready to extract gains for Quebec in exchange for supporting Liberals
The Bloc Québécois says its ready to wheel and deal with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's party for support during confidence votes now that the Liberal government's confidence and supply agreement with the NDP has ended.
'It's morally wrong': A rural Alberta town reacts to homeless shelter closure
At the end of a side street in Slave Lake, Alta., Lynn Bowes looks at a grey job-site trailer with boarded-up windows and doors that once operated as her town's only homeless shelter.
'Beetlejuice Beetlejuice' jolts box office with US$110 million opening weekend
After 36 years of waiting, the juice is finally loose again in 'Beetlejuice Beetlejuice,' this time racking up US$110 million in its premiere weekend.
Military surplus store in Calgary, destination of celebrity shoppers, closing doors
Cher, Anthony Hopkins, Heath Ledger, Alec Baldwin and Tom Hardy are just a few of the celebrities John Cumming met while growing up in his family's military surplus store.
The controversial plan to turn a desert green
Ties van der Hoeven's ambitions are nothing if not grand. The Dutch engineer wants to transform a huge stretch of inhospitable desert into green, fertile land teeming with wildlife.
Timeline: The rise and fall of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's political fortunes
In the wake of the NDP withdrawing its automatic support of the minority Liberal government, here is a timeline of key events charting the arc of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's fortunes in federal politics.
Dallas Cowboys Dak Prescott signs four-year, US$240-million contract, becomes highest-paid player in NFL history
The Dallas Cowboys and quarterback Dak Prescott agreed to a record four-year, US$240 million contract extension.
They were due to leave for their dream cruise in May. Three months on they’re still stuck at the departure port
It was the years-long cruise that was supposed to set sail, but saw its departure postponed… postponed… and postponed again.