Parole board ignored trauma of Indigenous man convicted of murder, court rules
An Indigenous man convicted of murder and attempted murder could get parole after the Federal Court ruled the parole board failed to consider his traumatic past when it denied his release.
Jeffrey George Ewert, 61, was convicted in 1984 after he sexually assaulted and strangled two women in British Columbia in two separate incidents while highly intoxicated, killing one and leaving the other severely disabled.
The Parole Board of Canada denied his application for day parole in 2022, concluding he still posed an undue risk to society. But a Federal Court judge in Montreal last week overturned that decision, ruling the board failed to consider what are known as Gladue factors — Ewert's traumatic childhood and the Indigenous healing process he has undertaken.
Ewert's lawyer, Nora Demnati, says the parole board has been slow to embrace Gladue principles, which require the criminal justice system to consider the unique circumstances of Indigenous people when decisions are made about bail, sentencing and parole. She hopes this latest decision will force the board to "give proper consideration" to Indigenous offenders' background and efforts at rehabilitation.
The case will now return to the parole board's appeal division for a new assessment. Demnati said she's "very hopeful" Ewert, who has been behind bars for 40 years, will be granted day parole. "He should definitely get parole," she said. "He should have gotten parole years ago, to be honest."
Ewert was in his early twenties when he committed his crimes, and is serving two concurrent life sentences. He became eligible for day parole in 1996, but didn't apply until 2022. In a previous court case, he said he believed he was unlikely to be paroled because he was deemed too high-risk.
Ewert, whose mother was of Métis descent and whose father was British, was adopted as a baby by a non-Indigenous family in Surrey, B.C. His adoptive father was alcoholic and his adoptive mother had psychiatric problems. She abused him physically, psychologically and sexually from the ages of about six to 12, according to the court decision. He began abusing substances in his early adolescence.
Since his sentencing, Ewert has engaged in a healing process and practised traditional Indigenous teachings that have helped him deal with his anger, triggers and substance abuse, wrote Justice Jocelyne Gagné. He has had a minimum-security classification since 2019 and has had several escorted temporary absences. He is currently being held at the minimum-security Federal Training Centre in Laval, Que. He asked for day parole at the Salvation Army halfway house in Saskatoon.
Correctional Service Canada (CSC) deems Ewert's risk of violence as "moderate to high in the short term," according to the decision. His correctional file, reviewed by the parole board, finds that he "exhibits the need to dominate and control women, emotional management issues, an explosive temperament, and distrust towards others."
The parole board denied Ewert's release in December 2022, but Gagné found the board didn't give enough weight to Ewert's history or the treatment he's received. "The evidence demonstrates that (Ewert) has gained extensive awareness about how his background and childhood trauma led to his heavy substance abuse, anger triggers, and his relationships with women," she wrote.
Demnati said the parole board does pay attention to Indigenous offenders' background and trauma, but only superficially. "The risk for the public is so paramount to their analysis that it sometimes tends to trump other considerations," she said. She believes that steps Indigenous offenders have taken to heal from their trauma, like embracing their identity and culture, are often disregarded.
"No one gets released on parole being perfect or having a zero risk of reoffending," she said. "It's always a question of is the risk manageable for society, given the release plan that we are offering to the parole board and given the work that has been done?"
A 2016 Federal Court decision found that Gladue principles do apply to parole decisions. But Jonathan Rudin, special projects director at Toronto-based Aboriginal Legal Services, said the parole board still has a hard time assessing Indigenous offenders.
For one thing, he said, most of the board's information comes from the CSC, which he said tends to classify Indigenous offenders as higher-risk. Another issue is that Gladue reports, which are used in pre-sentencing and bail hearings to lay out the unique circumstances of Indigenous offenders, rarely exist for parole hearings.
Ewert has a long history of litigation, and was referred to in a previous decision as "a bit of a jailhouse lawyer." In 2018, a case involving Ewert ended up at the Supreme Court of Canada, which found that the CSC failed to ensure that its risk assessment tests are accurate for Indigenous offenders.
Rubin said both that decision and the latest one are significant. "I think every time the ... court makes it clear that you have to do more than say, 'I've considered Gladue,' I think that's important."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 1, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Air Canada begins preparations for shutdown as union talks near impasse
Air Canada is finalizing contingency plans to suspend most of its operations as talks with the pilot union are near an impasse, the country's largest airline said on Monday.
Justin Trudeau may be in for an earful as he meets with caucus in B.C.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau may be bracing for an earful from his caucus when Liberal MPs gather in Nanaimo, B.C. today to plot their strategy for the coming election year.
Former fashion tycoon Peter Nygard's long-delayed sentencing expected today
Former fashion mogul Peter Nygard is expected to be sentenced for his sexual assault convictions today, after multiple delays in the case that have stretched for months.
Apple's upcoming iPhone will catapult the tech trendsetter into the age of AI
Apple's ubiquitous iPhone is about to break new ground with a shift into artificial intelligence that will do everything from smartening up its frequently dim-witted assistant Siri to creating customized emojis on the fly.
Trial begins over Texas 'Trump Train' highway confrontation
A federal trial is set to begin Monday over claims that supporters of former U.S. president Donald Trump threatened and harassed a Biden-Harris campaign bus in Texas four years ago, disrupting the campaign on the last day of early voting.
'Shogun' wins record-breaking 14 Emmys at Creative Arts ceremony as Jamie Lee Curtis gets her first
'Shogun' won the most Emmys ever for a single season of a television series with 14 at the Creative Arts Emmy Awards on Sunday night, while 'The Bear' won seven including best guest actress in a comedy series for Jamie Lee Curtis.
Couche-Tard says it's committed to purchase of 7-Eleven owner, outlines its case
Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. says it is 'disappointed' in a refusal of its takeover offer by the Japanese owner of 7-Eleven and remains focused on reaching a deal.
Authorities vow relentless search as manhunt for interstate shooter enters third day in Kentucky
As a gruelling manhunt stretched into a third day Monday for a suspect in an interstate shooting that struck 12 vehicles and wounded five people, authorities vowed to keep up a relentless search as the stress level remained high for a rural area where some schools cancelled classes.
China announces joint naval, air drills with Russia
China's Defence Ministry on Monday announced joint naval and air drills with Russia starting this month, underscoring the closeness between their militaries as Russia presses its grinding invasion of Ukraine.