Majority of Canadians willing to pay to fix housing crisis, health-care system: poll
New data shows a majority of Canadians — regardless of income, political beliefs, or area code — support the idea of putting a surtax on properties priced north of $1 million if it would help alleviate the crises in health care and housing.
According to a poll by B.C.-based Research Co. and Generation Squeeze, 68 per cent of Canadians support “implementing a modest surtax paid by the 10 per cent who own the most expensive homes.”
The wealth of that demographic is currently protected by Canada’s 50-year-old homeownership tax shelter, which Generation Squeeze’s founder refers to as “HOTS.”
“We’re hot for HOTS!” Dr. Paul Kershaw, who is also a policy professor in the UBC School of Population Health, joked before turning serious.
“It’s a harmful policy that incentivizes us to want home prices to rise,” Kershaw said. “Do we want housing a place to call home, or do we want it to be an investment strategy where many, like me, get rich?”
Kershaw is among the 10 per cent of Canadians who benefit from the homeownership tax shelter--the country’s largest housing subsidy. Each year, the policy costs Canadians $10 billion on the federal level, while costing provinces another $5 billion, Finance Canada reports.
SURPRISING SUPPORT FOR SURTAX
One of the most surprising findings from the poll, according to Kershaw, is that 57 per cent of high-value property owners showed support for “modest price on housing inequity.” However, their support dropped to 15 per cent when it is described as a “surtax.”
“We have to frame the issue really carefully from a surtax into the idea they could be contributing slightly more,” said Kershaw.
The polling shows Canadians are more likely to support adding a surtax if the revenue goes towards improving housing affordability or the health-care system, especially if it would benefit long-term care.
Kershaw believes that’s because high-value homeowners are more likely to be older people who got into the housing market when prices were low and have since benefited from them skyrocketing.
“While they’re willing to invest in themselves, they’d also be investing in their children and grandchildren by making the housing market easier to enter,” said Kershaw.
TAX SHELTER EXPOSES REGIONAL FRUSTRATIONS
Data by Generation Squeeze shows Ontario has earned more housing wealth than any other province since the half-century-old tax shelter was brought in, with B.C. close behind. Kershaw uses the example of two different retirees--one in Fredericton, N.B., the other in Vancouver--to highlight the amount of wealth that’s sheltered regionally.
“That retiree in Fredericton has every reason to be frustrated that Canada shelters high-value homes from taxation,” said Kershaw. “Both retirees may have entered the housing market at the same time, but the Vancouver home is now worth more than $1 million, while the Fredericton one is worth $360,000.”
In Canada’s two most-expensive housing markets, Ontario and British Columbia, one in two people polled shows support for implementing a modest surtax on high-value properties.
PUBLIC POLL PAVES PATH FOR POLITICIANS
The poll also found 55 per cent of Canadians who vote Conservative in federal elections support a modest surtax, as do 63 per cent of Liberal voters and 64 per cent of people who vote NDP.
Kershaw hopes those findings will encourage policy makers to implement Generation Squeeze’s surtax recommendation, which was first made in a report published in January.
“Politicians will rarely be able to lead where the public isn’t going,” said Kershaw, explaining the purpose of the poll was to gauge Canadian attitudes and encourage political action. “We aren’t proposing to get rid of the tax shelter, this is literally just taking the sharpest edges off.”
The surtax recommendation also includes a deferral option for people with modest incomes and high-value homes.
“We’re not going to push retirees out of their homes. We can adapt while acknowledging the difference between income wealth and property wealth.”
Fixing the housing system through a surtax is a faster solution than adding new homes to the supply, as Vancouver saw in 2017 when the city brought in an empty homes tax.
Generation Squeeze is the same think-tank that helped the City of Vancouver develop that tax, which is now priced at three per cent tax on a home’s assessed value.
“People are recognizing we’ve done many of the easy things,” Kershaw said. “We tried to stop other people ruining our housing market –foreign buyers, developers, mean-spirited NIMBYers--It hasn’t been enough,” Kershaw said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW Who should lead the Liberals? 'None of the above,' poll finds
As questions loom over Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s leadership, a new Nanos Research poll commissioned for CTV News says a quarter of Canadians say none of the potential candidates appeal to them.
Canada's response to Trump deportation plan a key focus of revived cabinet committee
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump's promise to launch a mass deportation of millions of undocumented people has the Canadian government looking at its own border.
Canada rent report: What landlords are asking tenants to pay
Average asking rents declined nationally on a year-over-year basis for the first time in more than three years in October, said a report out Thursday.
U.S. election maps: How did 2024 compare to 2020 and 2016?
Though two states have yet to be officially called, the U.S. election map has mostly been settled. How does it compare with the previous two elections?
N.S. school 'deeply sorry' for asking service members not to wear uniforms at Remembrance Day ceremony
An elementary school in the Halifax area has backed away from a request that service members not wear uniforms to the school's Remembrance Day ceremony.
Remembrance Day: What's open and closed in Canada?
While banks and post offices will be closed nationwide on Remembrance Day, shops and businesses could be open depending on where you live in Canada.
BREAKING Judicial recount for Surrey-Guildford confirms B.C. NDP's majority
The B.C. New Democrats have a majority government of 47 seats after a judicial recount in the riding of Surrey-Guildford gave the party's candidate 22 more votes than the provincial Conservatives.
48,584 space heaters recalled in Canada after burn injury in U.S.
Health Canada has announced a recall for electric space heaters over potential fire and burn risks, a notice published Thursday reads.
Israeli soccer fans were attacked in Amsterdam. The violence was condemned as antisemitic
Israeli fans were assaulted after a soccer game in Amsterdam by hordes of young people apparently riled up by calls on social media to target Jewish people, Dutch authorities said Friday. Five people were treated at hospitals and dozens were arrested after the attacks, which were condemned as antisemitic by authorities in Amsterdam, Israel and across Europe.