Lawsuit challenges Vancouver's decision to remove 160K trees from Stanley Park
![Stanley Park trees Downed trees, felled due to a looper moth infestation, are seen in Stanley Park in March 2024. (CTV News)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/3/21/stanley-park-trees-1-6817648-1721172627146.png)
Four Vancouver residents are suing the city over the planned removal of some 160,000 trees from Stanley Park, claiming the massive logging operation is unnecessary.
The Vancouver Board of Parks and Recreation contracted B.A. Blackwell and Associates to begin the felling work last fall, citing concerns that the trees were either dead or dying as a result of an ongoing Western hemlock looper moth infestation – and could eventually pose a risk of toppling onto visitors.
Officials also suggested the affected trees, which make up approximately one-third of the Stanley Park forest, would exacerbate wildfire risks.
But in a lawsuit filed last week in B.C. Supreme Court, a group of residents challenged the science behind the city's justifications.
Michael Caditz, Katherine Caditz, Anita Hansen and Jillian Maguire argued that while the looper moths have damaged hemlocks by feasting on their needles, many of the trees could still recover from the defoliation.
Those that don't are "unlikely to crash down," according to the claim, but could instead be expected to decompose from the top down while standing.
"There is no elevated risk from standing defoliated coastal hemlocks, dead or alive," reads the lawsuit, which was filed on July 11.
The plaintiffs also argued that wildfires are "more likely and more severe" in forests that have been thinned, in part because of larger wind tunnels created by the removal of tree trunks and higher temperatures caused by the decrease in shade coverage from branches and leaves.
The lawsuit identifies Michael Caditz as a software developer, Katherine Caditz as a homemaker, Hansen as a holistic health educator and Maguire as a schoolteacher.
Neither the city nor park board has filed a response to the civil claim, and each declined to comment while it is before the courts.
Logging paused for spring and summer
The logging operation was paused earlier this year to avoid disturbing birds' nests during the spring and summer. Officials expect the work to take five years to complete.
Back in March, the park board toured the tree-clearing progress after several months of felling from B.A. Blackwell – with Commissioner Tom Digby describing the sight as "absolutely devastating."
Digby also noted that the city is planting tens of thousands of new seedlings in a reforestation effort, replacing the moth-prone hemlocks with Douglas fir, cedar and other species.
"The hemlock were doomed species in this space, the hemlock looper always gets them," he said at the time.
In their lawsuit, the Caditzes, Hansen and Maguire each said they visit Stanley Park multiple times per week, and that the logging has already had a number of negative impacts – including a reduction in the sound barrier provided by the trees, increasing noise from vehicles on Stanley Park Drive.
Their claim lists "solitude," "stress relief," "spiritual connection with undisturbed nature" and "rejuvenation" among uses of the park that are being "impeded and degraded" as a result of the tree-clearing.
The plaintiffs also accused officials of failing to properly debate the proposal or consider feedback from the public.
"There was never a motion at a public park board meeting to direct staff to undertake a logging or tree removal operation in Stanley Park with respect to looper moth mitigation," their claim reads.
The group is seeking an injunction prohibiting the further removal of any trees from the park, plus legal costs and any additional relief that "may seem appropriate" to the court.
Michael Caditz also launched a petition opposing the city's plans back in February. As of Tuesday, it had collected more than 18,700 signatures.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7028417.1725654228!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
BREAKING Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs Grand Chief Cathy Merrick dies after collapsing outside Winnipeg courthouse
The Grand Chief of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs has died after collapsing outside of the Manitoba courthouse Friday afternoon, according to multiple sources.
Woman who was denied a liver transplant, after review highlighted alcohol use, has died
Questions are being raised about the case of a 36-year-old Ontario woman who died of liver failure after she was rejected for a life-saving liver transplant after a medical review highlighted her prior alcohol use.
Teen girl charged with attempted murder after student set on fire at Saskatoon high school
A 14-year-old girl faces an attempted murder charge after a 15-year-old girl was doused in a flammable substance and set on fire at a Saskatoon high school Thursday.
Montreal man given $664 fine for tying dog to parking meter while grabbing a croissant
A Montreal man who tied his dog to a parking meter while he entered a bakery is now facing a hefty fine for breaking a law he had no idea existed.
Molson Coors ends diversity, equity and inclusion policies, moves to 'broader view'
Brewing company Molson Coors says it is dropping its diversity, equity and inclusion policies and taking a 'broader view' in which all employees know they are welcome.
Selena Gomez is a billionaire
Selena Gomez can now add becoming a billionaire to her long list of achievements.
An American woman accused of killing 2 of her children fights extradition in a London court
An American woman accused of killing her two youngest children in Colorado last December told her 11-year-old daughter who survived the attack that God made her do it, a prosecutor said in a London court.
Canadian tied to alleged Russian influencer op received thousands in fees: U.S.
YouTube says the channels of a far-right Canadian influencer have been removed after U.S. officials alleged the company she co-founded received US$760,000 in fees and commissions as part of an alleged Russian ploy to dupe right-wing influencers into sowing division among Americans.
California man charged with killing 81 animals, including miniature horses, goats, ducks, parakeets
A man suspected of going on a three-hour shooting rampage in Northern California and killing 81 animals, including miniature horses, goats and chickens, pleaded not guilty to animal cruelty and other charges.