Former friends try to sue each other after alcohol-fuelled fight involving 'use of a cleaver,' small log
Two former friends got in an alcohol-fuelled fight, seriously injured each other, then tried to sue each other in separate proceedings, British Columbia Supreme Court documents show.
What happened, based to a recent ruling on the civil cases and a sentencing decision from an associated criminal case, started as a fight at a house party in 2018.
One friend invited the other to attend and the pair drank beer and whisky. Then, after everyone left, they got in an argument that turned physical, according to an agreed statement of facts.
It's unclear who started the argument, or what they were fighting about. A judge said that "both their recollections have been impaired by the consumption of alcohol and the injuries they have sustained."
One used a "cleaver," and the other used a "blunt object believed to be a small wooden log," the court heard during the criminal trial of one of the men.
Both were seriously hurt, but only one man was criminally charged at the time.
The one holding the cleaver pleaded guilty to assault causing bodily harm, and was given a six-month conditional sentence order to be followed by probation.
Following the plea, the party host tried to sue the guest, who'd admitted in court that the level of force he used was greater than could be justified as self-defence.
The guest said that his guilty plea didn't mean he was liable for civil assault and damages for the host's injuries.
Then the guest filed his own lawsuit, claiming he was overserved by the defendant named in his suit, and that the host assaulted him, "resulting in personal injuries, loss, and damage to him."
And so the case came before a judge in Vancouver earlier this month, who was asked to decide not on who is or isn't liable, but whether the matter was worth three trials – two civil, following the criminal trial.
In a decision made June 3 and published online Friday, Justice Jasmin Ahmad decided two would be enough.
"Having both actions heard together will result in a reduction of combined trial days as the Court will not have to hear duplicate and overlapping witness testimony and argument with respect to liability. Witnesses fees will also be reduced," she said in part.
"Use of the pre-trial fact-finding at trial will allow for efficiencies in time and expense in proving the facts that will be required at both trials."
She dismissed an application for a summary judgment, and decided there will be one trial, and that the man who was criminally convicted will have costs on both applications.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Prince William and Kate release photo of daughter Charlotte to mark ninth birthday
Prince William and his wife Kate released a picture of their daughter Charlotte to mark the princess's ninth birthday on Thursday.
Ontario man loses $1,500 applying for Nexus cards on social media
The trusted traveller program between Canada and the United States is extremely popular and almost two million Canadians have a Nexus card.
NEW Facial reconstruction reveals what a 40-something Neanderthal woman may have looked like
Scientists studying a Neanderthal woman's remains have painstakingly pieced together her skull from 200 bone fragments to understand what she may have looked like.
Campus protests: Israeli academics say their universities are 'best chance' for peace
One of the demands of pro-Palestinian activists who have set up protest encampments on university campuses in Canada and the United States is a severing of ties with Israeli universities.
Concerns about Plexiglas prompt inspections at some Loblaws locations in Ottawa
Inspections are underway at more than one Loblaws location in Ottawa after complaints were filed about tall Plexiglas barriers.
Weight-loss drug Wegovy available in Canada starting May 6
The makers of Ozempic say their weight-loss drug Wegovy will be available to patients in Canada starting Monday.
Five human skeletons, missing hands and feet, found outside house of Nazi leader Hermann Goring
Archeologists have unearthed the skeletons of five people, missing their hands and feet, at a former Nazi military base in Poland.
This Canadian restaurant just lowered its prices. Here's how it did it
A Canadian restaurant lowered its prices this week, and though news of price tags dropping rather than climbing sounds unusual, the business strategy in this case is not, according to experts in the field.
NEW Companies letting customers opt out of Mother's Day ads
In an effort to balance the profitability of Mother's Day with the pain it causes some people, some brands are offering customers the choice to opt out of Mother's Day email advertising.