Dog's pool damage leads to neighbour being ordered to pay $620: B.C. tribunal
A West Kelowna woman is being ordered by B.C.'s small claims tribunal to pay more than $600 after her son's dog damaged the neighbour's pool.
The Civil Resolution Tribunal decision was posted online Wednesday morning, with tribunal member Sarah Orr explaining the incident unfolded nearly two years ago.
The tribunal heard that, on April 30, 2022, Jill Thompson was looking after her son's dog when the pup got out of her yard and into the neighbour's through a gap in the fence. Susan Greig told the tribunal the dog fell into her pool and damaged it, leading her to claim nearly $4,000 to pay for her insurance deductible, increased insurance premiums and loss of the use of her pool.
"Before the incident, Ms. Greig's pool was partially filled with water and covered by a tarp that was secured with bricks around the pool's perimeter," Orr wrote in her decision. "The tarp had some water pooled on top of it. When the dog fell in the pool it pulled some of the bricks in with it, which Ms. Greig says damaged the pool liner and cover."
While Thompson denied the damage was the dog's fault, Orr said Greig submitted video evidence with her claim, which she says was "persuasive." Orr explained the video showed the dog was in her yard for "at least five minutes" and in the pool for more than three minutes before Thompson entered the yard to get it.
Greig made an insurance claim for the damage and was paid about $7,000, less a $1,000 deductible to replace the pool liner and cover.
Who's responsible?
In her decision, Orr said there are multiple ways a dog owner could he held liable for their pet's actions. In this case, the matter of negligence applies, she said. Orr explained that while Thompson doesn't own the dog, "it was indisputably in her custody and care at the time of the incident." Orr also wrote that Thompson knew – or should have known – about the gap in the fence.
"I find that by allowing (her son's) dog in her backyard, which Mrs. Thompson knew or should have known was enclosed by an insufficient fence, and by allowing the dog to get far enough away from her that she could not see what it was doing for several minutes, Mrs. Thompson failed to maintain reasonable control of the dog," Orr's decision said. "I find she breached the dog bylaw and breached the required standard of care, and so I find she was negligent."
Even so, the tribunal heard a West Kelowna bylaw requires pool owners to have a fence or barrier in place before the pool is filled with water. Greig acknowledged she knew about the gap in the fence for at least two weeks before the incident. Orr concluded Greig breached the building bylaw by "failing to repair the gap in the fence or install a sufficient gate around the gap."
"I have found that both Ms. Greig and Mrs. Thompson were negligent," Orr wrote. "I find there is insufficient evidence to determine whose property the fence is on, but both parties' negligence is founded on the fence's insufficiency."
Entitled to damages?
As part of her claim – which totalled nearly $4,000 – Greig sought a $1,000 reimbursement for her insurance deductible. As she found both women equally responsible for the incident, Orr awarded Greig half that amount.
Greig also claimed a little over $2,300 for increased insurance premiums. Orr said, however, Greig failed to provide evidence to back that amount up, so she was denied that payout.
Another $600 was sought "for the loss of the use of her pool for three months."
"However, she did not explain or provide evidence to show which months of the year she normally uses her pool, or when her pool was repaired after the incident," Orr wrote. "Without more, I find Ms. Greig has failed to prove this aspect of her claim."
In addition to the $500, Thompson was also ordered to pay about $120 to cover post-judgement interest and CRT fees.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Trump fined US$1,000 for gag order violation in hush money case as judge warns of possible jail time
The judge presiding over Donald Trump's hush money trial has fined him US$1,000 for violating his gag order and sternly warned the former president that additional violation could result in jail time.
The story of how a B.C. man found his birth mother
After his adopted parents died, Dave Rogers set out to learn more about his birth mother. DNA results and a little help from friendly strangers would put him on a path to a small town in England.
When grief and AI collide: These people are communicating with the dead
AI tools can offer recommendations, answer questions and 'talk' with users. But some users are using them to recreate the likeness of the dead.
Spike in 'violent rhetoric' since Oct. 7 attack from 'extremist actors,' CSIS warns
The Israel-Hamas war has led to a spike in 'violent rhetoric' from 'extremist actors' that could prompt some in Canada to turn to violence, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service warns.
Italy's white-collar mafia is making a business killing
Italy's mafia rarely dirties its hands with blood these days. Extortion rackets have gone out of fashion and murders are largely frowned upon by the godfathers.
WestJet, mechanics union agree to tentative deal to avoid strike
A potential strike between WestJet and its mechanics union appears to have been avoided.
Russia announces nuclear weapon drills after angry exchange with senior Western officials
Russia plans to hold drills simulating the use of battlefield nuclear weapons, the Defense Ministry announced Monday, days after the Kremlin reacted angrily to comments by senior Western officials about the war in Ukraine and Moscow warned that tensions with the West are deepening.
Summer forecast: What to expect as El Nino weakens
As Canadians brace themselves for summer temperatures, forecasters say a weakening El Nino cycle doesn’t mean relief from the heat.
Actor Bernard Hill, of 'Titanic' and 'Lord of the Rings,' has died at 79
Actor Bernard Hill, who delivered a rousing cry before leading his people into battle in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King' and went down with the ship as the captain in 'Titanic,' has died.