Director of B.C. massage school must pay $12K after asking client to 'certify' he's not Muslim
The director of a B.C. massage school has been ordered to pay thousands of dollars for discriminatory comments she made to a Muslim man who wanted to book a treatment.
In a B.C. Human Rights Tribunal decision posted online last week, tribunal member Devyn Cousineau determined Joyce Middleton discriminated against Majid Shahadat in 2019. That discrimination continued, Cousineau said, throughout the tribunal's resolution process.
The tribunal heard Shahadat is a Muslim man who was born in Bahrain and is of mixed Arab and Indian descent.
"He has lived in Canada for 25 years and describes himself as a 'proud Canadian,'" Cousineau wrote.
Shahadat reached out to Northern School of Spa Therapies, located in Fort St. John, in 2019 to book a lymphatic drainage massage. The response he got, Cousineau said, left him "understandably shocked and hurt."
Hours after booking his appointment online, Shahadat got an email from Middleton, asking him for his "credentials."
"We rarely accept new clients outside the area of Fort St. John for our own protection. I am asking you to certify you are not of the Islamic faith, which as you know has earned a bad reputation for raping and killing of infidels in Canada and elsewhere," the email sent to Shahadat said. "I apologize, this is not meant to be offensive, but I have to be watchful over my students as I am sure you will be able to understand."
Three days later, Middleton sent a follow-up email, saying the school wouldn't accept "new male clients that (they) do not know," adding they "have to protect (their), students, who happen to be all girls at this time."
Middleton then referred Shahadat to a male massage therapist, Cousineau wrote.
Cousineau said the emails showed Shahadat was denied service, at least in part, because he was perceived to be a Muslim man based on his name.
"Ms. Middleton directly invoked the harmful and pervasive stereotype that Muslim men are threatening to women, girls, and non-Muslim 'infidels', and that the Islamic religion is itself a threat," Cousineau's decision said. "These are classic features of Islamophobia."
'Deepened the extent of the harm'
After Shahadat filed his complaint with the Human Rights Tribunal, Cousineau said, Middleton reportedly launched a "defence" to "prove that her fears are rational and based on tenets of Islam which promote violence, particularly against women and children."
"In doing so she has not only proven the elements of this human rights complaint but deepened the extent of the harm to Mr. Shahadat," Cousineau wrote.
Middleton chose to not participate in the tribunal hearing and instead submitted a written statement. CTV News Vancouver has reached out to Middleton for her response to the decision and this story will be updated if a comment is received.
Cousineau explained Middleton's response claimed she "is entitled and obliged to protect herself and the 'young girls' who work at the school." Cousineau said she cited "misinformation from what appear to be far-right, anti-Muslim" websites to justify her assessment that Shahadat allegedly posed a risk to her students.
Cousineau included nearly a dozen statements from Middleton's written submission, which she said "rests on stereotype and vilification of all Muslim people."
Some of those examples showed Middleton "conflating 'jihad' with violence and terrorism," which Cousineau said "is another marker of Islamophobia."
Middleton's submissions also included a demand for Shahadat to "'denounce certain parts of the Qur'an" and to bring a police officer along with him if he gets a massage.
"Ms. Middleton has taken patently untrue ideas about Islam and Muslim men, rooted in Islamophobia, and applied them to Mr. Shahadat," Cousineau wrote. "She then acted on that stereotyping to deny Mr. Shahadat a service customarily available to the public. This is discrimination in violation of the Human Rights Code."
Cousineau said that, as "repugnant" as Middleton's views may be, it's "unlikely" anything she writes in her decision will change her views. Cousineau wrote Middleton is free to hold her views but, as a business owner, she can't use them to determine who she will serve.
'Truly shocking'
In filing his complaint, Shahadat wrote it was "truly shocking" to learn "there were people with such strong, wrong viewpoints," even after being in Canada for 25 years.
"I've actually had to work really, really hard to get to where I am with my company, with my people, with our friends. And the fact that all that hard work just goes out the window simply because someone makes a call about what you are based on my colour, my religion, my ethnicity – that was what was really hurtful," Shahadat wrote. "The fact that I've worked so hard to get to where I am, and nothing matters in the end because one look at my face and they make a judgement call on what kind of person I am."
Cousineau wrote Shahadat's submission shows the discrimination he faced destabilized his sense of belonging and deprived him of "his right to equal access to the public life of this province."
Ultimately, Cousineau ordered Middleton to pay $10,000 in compensation for injury to Shahabat's dignity, feelings and self-respect. She noted this was about half the amount Shahabat asked for, but said the discrimination was "discrete, involving a single denial of service."
Cousineau also ordered Middleton to pay $2,500 for improper conduct during the tribunal process including submitting additional discriminatory materials and threatening to sue Shahabat in B.C. Supreme Court for his claims against her.
"It is unacceptable that, for Mr. Shahadat, the price of enforcing his quasi-constitutional human rights was that he had to endure further anti-Muslim commentary and threats," Cousineau wrote. "Ms. Middleton's submissions required Mr. Shahadat to repeatedly engage with content that baselessly associated him with the most vile acts of violence for no other reason than his identity as a Muslim man."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Spectacular aurora light show to be seen across Canada Friday night
A rare and severe solar storm is expected to bring spectacular displays of the northern lights, also known as aurora borealis, across much of Canada and parts of the United States on Friday night.
Town of Fort Nelson, B.C., ordered to evacuate due to wildfire
The entire town of Fort Nelson, B.C., as well as the nearby Fort Nelson First Nation, has been ordered to evacuate due to an out-of-control wildfire.
Bouchard lifts Edmonton Oilers to 4-3 overtime win over Canucks in Game 2
Evan Bouchard scored 5:38 into overtime and the Edmonton Oilers bounced back for a 4-3 win over the Vancouver Canucks in the second round of the Stanley Cup playoffs on Friday.
McGill University seeks emergency injunction to dismantle pro-Palestinian encampment
McGill University has filed a request for an injunction to have the pro-Palestinian encampment removed from its campus.
Which Canadian cities have the highest and lowest grocery prices?
Where you live plays a big factor in what you pay at the grocery store. And while it's no secret the same item may have a different price depending on the store, city or province, we wanted to see just how big the differences are, and why.
Swarm of 20,000 bees gather around woman’s car west of Toronto
A swarm of roughly 20,000 bees gathered around a woman’s car in the parking lot of Burlington Centre.
Video shows naked raccoon catching B.C. family by surprise
When Marvin Henschel spotted a strange and hairless creature wandering through a front lawn in B.C.'s Lower Mainland, he could barely believe his eyes.
Barron Trump declines to serve as an RNC delegate
Former U.S. President Donald Trump's youngest son, Barron Trump, has declined to serve as a delegate at this summer’s Republican National Convention, according to a senior Trump campaign adviser and a statement from Melania Trump's office.
Out-of-control wildfire prompts evacuation alert for Fort McMurray, Saprae Creek Estates Friday night
An evacuation alert was issued for two Wood Buffalo communities Friday night, as crews battled an out-of-control wildfire near Fort McMurray.