Judge promises ruling 'quickly as reasonably possible' in Surrey's challenge over policing transition
Lawyers for the Surrey Police Union say officers were subjected to harassment and disrespect by members of the Surrey RCMP, only to be left in a “jurisdictional void” when both federal and British Columbia bodies declined to investigate their allegations.
The claims that Surrey Police Service officers working alongside the RCMP in Surrey were subjected to a “toxic work environment” are contained in documents related to the City of Surrey's legal challenge against a transition from the RCMP to the municipal force.
Five days of hearings concluded Friday with Justice Kevin Loo saying he recognized the “urgency” of the situation, and would make a ruling as “quickly as reasonably possible.”
At the outset of the hearings, lawyers for the B.C. Public Safety Ministry had sought to seal exhibits containing the harassment allegations, but that was denied by Loo and the union's documents were filed Thursday.
The exhibits are attached to an affidavit by union president Rick Stewart, who says in one of the documents that the experiences of union members “illustrate systemic understaffing, under-supervision and unsafe tactics at the Surrey RCMP.”
A “respectful workplace investigation summary” dated January 2023 by Surrey Police Service Insp. Bal Brach says 12 Surrey officers reported 50 incidents of “harassment and/or disrespectful behaviour” by RCMP colleagues.
Brach's report says some RCMP supervisors engaged in an “ongoing scheme of disrespect and harassment” and “negatively reported on” Surrey officers deployed alongside them during the transition.
It says a Surrey officer of “mixed race” reported that an RCMP or City of Surrey employee said they “disliked” the city of Toronto because there were “too many 'Black' people there,” and a month later saw two Mounties “play a racialized and discriminatory game that mocked a Black male suspect.”
Brach's report says other Surrey Police Service members complained of being publicly ridiculed, intimidated or ostracized while working with the Surrey RCMP.
It says one RCMP member had a “Keep the RCMP in Surrey” flag and a political poster supporting Surrey Mayor Brenda Locke displayed at his desk.
Locke was elected on a promise to halt the transition and keep the RCMP in Surrey, but the province made legislative changes compelling the switch. That move has been the subject of the city's legal challenge this week, which seeks a judicial review.
The documents say efforts by the union's lawyers to have the matters investigated were hampered when both federal and provincial bodies declined jurisdiction over the bullying and harassment concerns.
A letter from union lawyer Sebastian Anderson to a private third-party arbitrator describes the situation.
“In spite of complaints being made to both WorkSafeBC and Labour Canada, both governmental agencies have declined jurisdiction - WorkSafeBC because the work sites are federally regulated and Labour Canada because the employees are provincially regulated,” the letter that is among the exhibits says.
“We recognize the unique nature of this dispute gives rise to challenging and interesting jurisdictional issues due to the deployment of provincially regulated employees to federally regulated work sites.”
In their efforts to have the harassment claims sealed from public view, ministry lawyers had warned the documents could cause “undue public concern” over the state of affairs at the Surrey RCMP detachment.
The RCMP is not involved in the court dispute but issued a statement after the court declined to seal the materials on Tuesday.
“RCMP is committed to providing a healthy, safe and respectful workplace for all employees, free of harassment and discrimination,” it said.
“Surrey RCMP and SPS officers have worked together in the detachment for over two years and have done so with professionalism.”
During the hearings that began Monday, City of Surrey lawyers argued that the Ministry of Public Safety overstepped its legal authority by ordering the city to complete the transition to the Surrey Police Service.
The city is seeking a judicial review of the minister's decision, and a declaration that the province had no authority to assign the city responsibility for the transition without providing adequate funding.
City lawyers also argued this week that the province had “nullified” voters' Charter right to freedom of expression because they had elected Locke on a pledge to stick with the RCMP.
On Friday, the court heard that the ministry believes the provincial Police Act is clear that cities have to bear their own costs for policing, in a “long-standing” obligation.
Lawyer Trevor Bant for the ministry told the court that the minister's “only role” was to determine what was safe, regardless of cost, when he ordered the transition to continue in July 2023.
Craig Dennis, representing the City of Surrey, said that decision ignored how the Surrey RCMP detachment planned to deal with potential staffing shortfalls if the transition was abandoned.
He said the city was open to offering Surrey Police Service officers a signing bonus to join the RCMP, and the minister's failure to consider its contingency plan was a “flaw in the reasoning process.”
“Public safety is hardly the only consideration in the choice,” Dennis said. “Other factors like costs and local priorities, the representativeness of the community, also are relevant, and that's why the optimal choice belongs at the local level to Surrey.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 3, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Feels like mid-30s in parts of Canada, while other areas expecting snow
Anything is possible this week, as far as Canada's weather is concerned, with forecasts ranging from scorching heat in some parts of the country to rain and snow in others.
BREAKING Canada's inflation cools to 3-year low of 2.7%, in boost for rate cut bets
Canada's annual inflation rate slowed to a three-year low of 2.7 per cent in April, matching expectations, and core measures continued to ease, data showed on Tuesday, likely boosting chances of a June interest rate cut.
One dead and 30 injured after severe turbulence hits Singapore Airlines flight
One person has died aboard a London-Singapore flight that encountered severe turbulence, Singapore Airlines said Tuesday. The plane was diverted to Bangkok, where emergency crews rushed to help injured passengers amid stormy weather.
Independent stores and grocery alternatives see sales boost amid Loblaw boycott
As the month-long boycott of Loblaw-owned stores wears on, small independent food retailers and alternative grocery options say they're seeing a boost in traffic and sales.
What is BORG drinking, and why is it a dangerous trend? An expert explains
If you've been to a party lately and haven't seen someone drinking a BORG, you're likely not partying with college students.
How to check the Air Quality Health Index and assess your health risks
As we enter another wildfire season, Environment and Climate Change Canada is advising people to pay attention to air pollution levels and check the Air Quality Health Index – especially on smoky days.
Cardinal Lacroix cleared after investigation ordered by the Pope
The Vatican has announced that the investigation it commissioned into allegations of sexual touching against Cardinal Gerald Cyprien Lacroix did not confirm any act constituting misconduct or abuse on the part of the Vatican.
Trudeau making 'Team Canada' pitch in visit to Philadelphia
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is in Philadelphia today, on his first trip south of the border since his government launched a new 'Team Canada' charm offensive in the United States.
Oilers win Game 7 over Canucks, advance to Western Conference Final
The Edmonton Oilers weathered a late Vancouver Canucks charge on Monday night, beating the hosts 3-2 to win their seven-game second-round playoff series in the decisive showdown.