'Bad beyond argument': B.C. court dismisses claim opposing federal, provincial COVID-19 measures
![B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2022/9/4/b-c--supreme-court-in-vancouver-1-6055730-1662344282420.jpg)
A B.C. judge has ruled that a lawsuit opposing federal and provincial COVID-19 restrictions cannot proceed in its current form, noting its claims of "global conspiracies" and "crimes against humanity" can't be adjudicated in civil court.
The 391-page notice of civil claim was filed in B.C. Supreme Court in 2021. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Canada's Chief Public Health Officer Dr. Teresa Tam, Premier John Horgan, the RCMP, the CBC and BC Ferries are among the 19 defendants named.
The plaintiffs are a group called Action4Canada, 10 named individuals, three anonymous individuals and two businesses. They were asking for a combined $20 million in damages, alleging their Charter rights were violated.
Justice Alan Ross broadly summarized the case in his decision on Aug. 29.
"In this action, the plaintiffs seek relief for various hardships and damages they say they have suffered. They seek damages, and other relief, from various government entities and employees," he wrote.
"The plaintiffs allege that their damages flow from various restrictions instituted due to the COVID-19 pandemic."
Ross dismissed the notice of civil claim but stopped short of throwing the case out entirely.
THE CLAIM
Ross summed up the claim as alleging that restrictions such as mandatory masking, limits on gathering, vaccine mandates and mandatory COVID-19 testing "exceeded the authority of the government agencies."
The specifics of how the plaintiffs were impacted by these public health measures, Ross noted, spans 75 pages. Examples include several instances of individuals claiming they were arrested for not adhering to the mask mandate, others who said they were fined for not following public health orders, an employee whose workplace required her to be immunized, and two people who said their businesses were negatively impacted.
"In each of these interactions, the public agencies involved were enforcing the health mandates issued by the Federal Government and the Province of British Columbia," Ross said.
"The allegations at the operational level are then linked to the allegedly overreaching and ill-advised health mandates imposed by each level of government. Those mandates, in turn, are linked to individuals within government, either elected or employed."
The court also heard that the claim challenged the existence of the pandemic itself, argued that the public health orders were not based on science, accused government and health officials of criminal conduct and advanced conspiracy theories.
'PROLIX' AND IMPROPER CLAIMS
The defendants applied to have the entire Notice of Civil Claim struck as "prolix," which the court heard is a term describing a pleading that is "tediously lengthy" and too unwieldy to proceed.
Due to the sheer number of pages, Ross ruled, the claim was "clearly prolix."
Further, he accepted the defendants' argument that the "unlimited scope of the document" meant it would be impossible for them – individually or collectively -- to file a response.
"They would not know what case they were required to meet," he wrote.
The defendants also argued that the notice of civil claim asked the court to adjudicate a number of issues that are entirely out of its jurisdiction.
Those included asking the court to declare that vaccination against COVID-19 is experimental and violates the Nuremberg Code, that public health orders were designed to deliberately harm small businesses and that the World Health Organization's motive for declaring a global pandemic was in some way nefarious and at the "behest of global billionaire, corporate and organizational oligarchs" like Bill Gates.
The claim also asked for the court to declare that masks do not prevent transmission of the virus and that public health measures are based on case counts determined by the "fraudulent use' of the "debunked" PCR test.
Ross agreed that the claim asked the court to weigh in on a number of issues far outside the court's jurisdiction.
"It describes wide-ranging global conspiracies that may, or may not, have influenced either the federal or the provincial governments. It seeks rulings of the court on issues of science. In addition, it includes improper allegations, including criminal conduct and 'crimes against humanity,'" he wrote.
"In my opinion, it is 'bad beyond argument.'"
CLAIM CAN BE AMENDED
The defendants argued that due to the myriad problems in the Notice of Civil claim, the entire case should be thrown. They argues the lawsuit was "an abuse of process" that is "clearly frivolous and vexatious."
However, Ross declined to dismiss the case in its entirety and instead ruled that the plaintiffs can – individually or as a group – amend the claim.
"Put simply, individuals have standing to question whether state actions infringe their Charter protected rights. Hence, in this case, there is a prospect that the plaintiffs could put forward a valid claim that certain of the COVID-based health restrictions instituted by the Federal or Provincial governments infringed their Charter rights," he wrote.
"The existence of a single potential, viable cause of action means that it would be improper for me, at this stage, to foreclose upon the plaintiffs’ right to bring their claims."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6977053.1721909931!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'Sick to my stomach': People grieve Jasper National Park by sharing favourite photos
As an out-of-control wildfire roared through Alberta’s famed Jasper National Park and its townsite late Wednesday, many are fearing the worst as officials warned of 'significant loss' within the area.
DEVELOPING Jasper wildfire burns buildings, while poor air quality forces some fire crews out
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced on social media that Ottawa has approved Alberta's request for federal assistance after a fast-moving wildfire hit Jasper National Park and its townsite late Wednesday.
Canadian women's soccer team staffer given suspended prison sentence over drone incident, prosecutor says
A Canada women's soccer team staffer has been given an eight-month suspended prison sentence after flying a drone to film the closed-door training session of the New Zealand team on Monday, the prosecutor's office said in a statement.
Sale of envoy's NYC condo 'expected to exceed' $9M: government
The current official residence for Canada's representative in New York City is 'being readied for sale,' according to a spokesperson from Global Affairs Canada.
'I'm so broke': Two Toronto women speak out after losing $76,000 in romance scam
Two women from the Toronto area are speaking out after losing thousands of dollars to a romance scam, including a single mother who lost $62,000.
Barrie-Innisfil MPP 'blacked-out' and crashed car into window of child care centre
Staff at a Barrie child care centre say they are frustrated by what they call a local MPP's inadequate response after a car crashed through a window in one of the toddler rooms.
Loblaw, George Weston to settle class action over bread price-fixing for $500 million
Loblaw Cos. Ltd. and its parent company George Weston Ltd. say they have agreed to pay $500-million to settle a class-action lawsuit regarding their involvement in an alleged bread price-fixing scheme.
EXCLUSIVE One address, 76 foreign currency dealers: Inside Canada's money service business 'clusters'
An IJF and CTV News investigation has found dozens of cases across Canada where multiple money services businesses (MSBs) are incorporated at the same address, sometimes without the knowledge or consent of the location's actual occupant. One money laundering expert calls it an 'abuse of the system.'
An unwelcome attendee has joined the Paris Olympic Games: COVID-19
After a handful of Australian water polo players tested positive for COVID-19 this week, questions have emerged around how the spread of the disease will be mitigated at the Summer Olympic Games in Paris.