B.C. woman wins right to continue using parking stall that strata says doesn't exist
![Underground parking An underground parking area is seen in this undated stock image. (Shutterstock.com)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2022/10/7/underground-parking-1-6101107-1665176828156.jpg)
B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal has ordered a Burnaby strata corporation to allow the owner of one of its units to continue parking in the parking stall she has used for more than a decade, even though the strata claims such a stall does not exist.
Elsie Yuen Ching Chan took her case to the CRT after the strata declined to designate her parking space as "limited common property" associated with her unit at a hearing last year.
Chan told the tribunal she had parked in "Stall 4" of the building's underground parkade from 2006, when she purchased her unit, until 2019, when the strata sent her a letter indicating that she had to stop parking there because there was no parking stall associated with her unit.
Tribunal member Leah Volkers, in a decision issued and posted online Tuesday, noted that the strata's letter did not provide any further explanation for why Chan was no longer allowed to park in Stall 4.
Chan has been renting a parking stall from another owner in the building ever since, according to the decision.
'AN OBVIOUS PARKING SPACE,' NOT A WALKWAY
The strata provided a little more explanation in its submissions to the tribunal, which argued that there is no Stall 4 on the strata plan, and that the space Chan had been parking in was actually a common property walkway leading to the building's storage room.
The need for other owners to be able to access the storage room was the strata's "primary argument" for its decision to stop allowing Chan to park there, Volkers wrote.
The tribunal member was unmoved by either of these arguments, noting early in her decision that a parking stall clearly exists in the space.
"The strata plan shows 33 (limited common property) parking stalls in the strata’s parkade, numbered 1-3 and 5-34, respectively," the decision reads.
"Although not specifically identified as a stall on the strata plan, a photograph shows what I find is an obvious parking stall space between Stall 3 and Stall 5 without a stall number, and a door offset to one side at the end of the stall. I find this stall space is the area both parties refer to as Stall 4. For clarity, I will refer to this area as Stall 4 throughout this decision, even though the strata says Stall 4 does not exist."
STRATA MUST GRANT PARKING PERMISSION
While it is not limited common property associated with Chan's condo, Stall 4 is a parking space on the strata's common property, Volkers concluded.
Moreover, Chan submitted evidence showing the strata had given her permission to park in Stall 4 in 2007, shortly after she moved into her unit.
According to the decision, under B.C.'s Strata Property Act, stratas may grant their members permission to exclusively use a common property parking space for up to a year, after which point such permission must be renewed.
While the strata never explicitly renewed its permission for Chan to park in Stall 4, Volkers concluded that it had effectively done so by allowing her to continue parking there for roughly 12 years.
Largely because of this fact, the tribunal member concluded that Chan had an "objectively reasonable" expectation that she was entitled to use Stall 4, and the strata's sudden, unexplained revocation of that entitlement was "significantly unfair" to her.
Chan asked the CRT to declare that Stall 4 is limited common property for the use of her strata lot, but Volkers declined to make such a declaration, because doing so would restrict access to the storage room.
"If Stall 4 is designated as (limited common property) for (Chan's unit's) exclusive use, other owners are not entitled to use it, even if they are only doing so to access the storage door," the decision reads. "Therefore, I find ordering the strata to designate Stall 4 as LCP for (Chan's unit) is not an appropriate remedy."
Instead, the tribunal member ordered the strata to grant Chan exclusive use of Stall 4 – which will remain a common property parking stall – until she sells her strata lot, at which point the permission will expire.
Volkers also imposed the condition that Chan must always leave two metres of space between her vehicle and the storage door.
Because Chan was the successful party in the case, the tribunal member ordered the strata to pay her $225 to reimburse her CRT fees.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6972157.1721587842!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
BREAKING NEWS Joe Biden drops out of 2024 race, endorses Kamala Harris to be Democratic nominee
U.S. President Joe Biden dropped out of the 2024 race for the White House on Sunday, ending his bid for re-election after a disastrous debate with Donald Trump that raised doubts about the incumbent's fitness for office with the election just four months away. It was a late-season campaign thunderstrike unlike any in American history.
What happens next: Joe Biden wants to pass the baton to Kamala Harris. Here's how that might work
With U.S. President Joe Biden ending his re-election bid and endorsing Vice President Kamala Harris, Democrats now must navigate a shift that is unprecedented this late in an election year.
Justin Trudeau reacts to Joe Biden announcing he won't run for re-election
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau responded to the news that U.S. President Joe Biden won’t run for re-election Sunday, calling Biden a 'true friend.'
Harris, endorsed by Biden, could become first woman, second Black person to be U.S. president
Kamala Harris could become the first Black woman to head a major U.S. party presidential ticket after U.S. President Joe Biden abruptly ended his re-election bid and endorsed her.
Read Biden's full text announcing the end to his re-election campaign
U.S. President Joe Biden ended his re-election campaign on Sunday after fellow Democrats lost faith in his mental acuity and ability to beat Donald Trump. He announced his decision in a letter posted on social media. Read the full text.
LCBO workers ratify tentative agreement, strike ends Monday
The union representing 10,000 workers at the Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO) has ratified a tentative agreement, which will officially end its two-week strike at 12:01 a.m. Monday.
Joy in Newfoundland after 'Lucky 7' fishers survive harrowing days lost at sea
There was a powerful word being repeated in the joyful Newfoundland community of New-Wes-Valley on Sunday: 'Miracle.'
The pilot who died in crash after releasing skydivers near Niagara Falls has been identified
NEW YORK (AP) — Officials on Sunday released the name of a pilot who died in a skydiving flight after her passengers jumped from the aircraft near the Niagara Falls.
A 12-year-old girl is accused of smothering her younger cousin over an iPhone
A 12-year-old girl in Tennessee has been charged with murder, accused of smothering her eight-year-old cousin as the younger girl slept. A relative said they had been arguing over an iPhone.