B.C. mom who suffocated 8-year-old daughter loses appeal of sentence
Warning: This story contains disturbing details
A B.C. woman who was convicted of killing her eight-year-old daughter by suffocating her with a plastic bag has lost her bid to have her sentence reduced, according to a decision from the B.C. Court of Appeal.
Lisa Batstone was found guilty of second-degree murder in 2019, nearly five years after Teagan was killed. Batstone's attempt to have the conviction overturned was rejected in October of 2021.
'CRUEL AND CALCULATED'
Batstone was sentenced to life in prison and ineligible for parole for 15 years. The May 10 appeal sought to have that amount of time reduced to 10 years, which is the minimum allowed for the offence. The appeal court noted that imposing a sentence above the minimum can be done at a judge's discretion after weighing the circumstances of the case.
"It is an egregious breach of parental trust to murder one’s own child. Teagan was murdered by the one who purported to love her the most. She was killed for a purely selfish reason. Ms. Batstone professed a desire to die but instead killed her innocent child, thereby depriving Teagan’s father, half-siblings, stepmother, and others in her life, of her precious life," the decision reads.
"Ms. Batstone’s actions were not spontaneous; they were cruel and calculated to hurt others."
The defence argued, in part, that the judge did not give enough consideration to Batstone's mental disorders when handing down the sentence.
"Prior to Teagan’s death, Ms. Batstone twice attempted suicide. She suffered from depression and anxiety. She demonstrated traits of borderline personality disorder, including a marked instability in mood with intense emotional reactions that could lead to impulsive acts," the appeal court noted in its decision.
However, the court also noted the issue of mental disorder had already been raised at the trial, along with intoxication, as potential factors negating Batstone's intent to kill Teagan.
"Ms. Batstone’s mental disorders, although perhaps diminishing her capacity and impairing her executive functioning, did not preclude her from forming the requisite intent to kill Teagan. The judge noted the conscious forethought and deliberate action necessary to smother a person, as well as the fact that Teagan’s death required a number of decisions and several steps," the appeal court noted.
"The judge did not simply say Ms. Batstone had the intent to kill and took steps to carry out that intent. Rather, the judge held that her goal-directed steps evinced a lack of major impediment from mental disorders, and thus a higher degree of moral blameworthiness."
Batstone's defence argued on appeal that the judge made a mistake, and that the "core impetus" to kill Teagan was Batstone's "suicidal ideation, borne of her mental disorders."
'TEAGAN WAS AN INNOCENT PAWN'
The court heard the Batstones divorced in 2010, and that the mother continued to feel "great resentment" toward her ex-husband.
"Ms. Batstone killed Teagan because she herself wanted to die, but she did not want to leave Teagan in the care of her father," the appeal court said.
"Teagan was an innocent pawn in her mother’s selfishness or revenge or misguided belief. It matters not what it is called. She wanted to kill herself, she felt betrayed by Mr. Batstone, she felt mentally and emotionally abused by him, she left him messages after she killed Teagan—'You win.' 'You broke me'—and she killed Teagan so her father could not have her."
Gabe Batstone is seen with his daughter, Teagan, in this undated photo.
The sentencing judge weighed Batstone's actions after the murder when considering the question of intent. The court of appeal agreed that leaving notes, "refusing to accept responsibility," the apparent attempt to cover up the killing, and the fact that Batstone "conjured up stories in an effort to be found not criminally responsible due to mental disorder" is not the behaviour of someone whose mental capacity is diminished. Ultimately, the court agreed with the Crown that the judge had "recognized the centrality of Ms. Batstone’s mental disorders to determine a fit sentence."
'UNTHINKABLE'
Another issue raised in the appeal was whether the sentencing judge had made a mistake when describing Batstone's love for her daughter as an "aggravating factor" that supported the imposition of a harsher sentence. The defense had argues the opposite, that Batstone's love for Teagan should instead be considered a mitigating factor supporting a lighter sentence.
"It was not wrong for the judge, in the circumstances of this case, to view Ms. Batstone’s love for Teagan as an aggravating factor," the court of appeal said.
"This was a loving relationship in which Teagan placed the utmost trust in her mother. To betray that innocent and steadfast trust in the most horrible of ways is unthinkable."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Indian envoy warns of 'big red line,' days after charges laid in Nijjar case
India's envoy to Canada insists relations between the two countries are positive overall, despite what he describes as 'a lot of noise.'
Stormy Daniels describes meeting Trump during occasionally graphic testimony in hush money trial
With Donald Trump sitting just feet away, Stormy Daniels testified Tuesday at the former president's hush money trial about a sexual encounter the porn actor says they had in 2006 that resulted in her being paid to keep silent during the presidential race 10 years later.
U.S. paused bomb shipment to Israel to signal concerns over Rafah invasion, official says
The U.S. paused a shipment of bombs to Israel last week over concerns that Israel was approaching a decision on launching a full-scale assault on the southern Gaza city of Rafah against the wishes of the U.S.
Former homicide detective explains how police will investigate shooting outside Drake's Bridle Path mansion
Footage from dozens of security cameras in the area of Drake’s Bridle Path mansion could be the key to identifying the suspect responsible for shooting and seriously injuring a security guard outside the rapper’s sprawling home early Tuesday morning, a former Toronto homicide detective says.
Northern Ont. woman makes 'eggstraordinary' find
A chicken farmer near Mattawa made an 'eggstraordinary' find Friday morning when she discovered one of her hens laid an egg close to three times the size of an average large chicken egg.
Susan Buckner, who played spirited cheerleader Patty Simcox in 'Grease,' dead at 72
Susan Buckner, best known for playing peppy Rydell High School cheerleader Patty Simcox in the 1978 classic movie musical 'Grease,' has died. She was 72.
Jeremy Skibicki has 'uphill battle' to prove he's not criminally responsible in Winnipeg killings: legal analysts
Accused killer Jeremy Skibicki could have a challenging time convincing a judge that he is not criminally responsible for the deaths of four Indigenous women, a legal analyst says.
Bye-bye bag fee: Calgary repeals single-use bylaw
A Calgary bylaw requiring businesses to charge a minimum bag fee and only provide single-use items when requested has officially been tossed.
Alcohol believed to be a factor in boating incident after 2 men die: N.S. RCMP
Two Nova Scotia men are dead after a boat they were travelling in sank in the Annapolis River in Granville Centre, N.S., on Monday.