'Vindictive and malicious': B.C. court weighs in on long-running neighbour dispute
A B.C. judge has issued a decision in a years-long dispute between neighbours that began with a noise complaint over barking dogs, crowing roosters and quacking ducks – awarding $15,000 in damages to the plaintiffs in the case.
A hearing took place over five days in Quesnel earlier this year and Judge Michael J. Brecknell's ruling was posted online earlier this month.
Mark and Beverly Croxall filed a lawsuit in provincial court in 2022, claiming their previous attempts to resolve their issues with their neighbours – first through conversation and then through bylaw complaints to the regional district about excessive noise and "unauthorized poultry" – had failed.
Further, they alleged that their neighbours, James Laverdure and Carrie Graham, engaged in an escalating and "vindictive" series of "retaliatory acts" after they involved the district and filed the lawsuit.
"They presented extensive evidence of the defendants' interference with their life, including recordings of barking dogs, crowing roosters, quacking ducks, loud engine revving, horn honking, and stereo music early in the morning meant to wake them up," Brecknell wrote, summarizing the submissions the Croxalls made in support of their claim.
"They also presented evidence of lights shining, cameras pointing, and recordings being made from the defendant’s property."
Laverdure and Graham, for their part, filed a counterclaim – seeking damages from their neighbours on a number of grounds and asking for $20,000. All of their claims were dismissed, except one for trespass.
"The defendants presented video evidence of Mr. Croxall trespassing on their property to pick up stones from the grass," the judge wrote, adding that the trespass "was trivial, innocent, and transitory." Given that, the court awarded $50 in damages.
The bulk of the damages awarded to the Croxalls – $13,000 – was for nuisance. The legal test for nuisance, the judge's decision explained, is two-fold. First, a claimant must demonstrate that there was a " substantial, non-trivial interference with their use and enjoyment of their property." Second, the court must find that the interference was "unreasonable."
In this case Brecknell found the Croxalls had, on a balance of probabilities, proven nuisance.
"The dog barking, animal noises, truck engine revving and stereo playing, lights shining into their yard, yard waste burning, and the snow drift left in their driveway by the defendants constituted a substantial interference with their use and enjoyment of their property," the decision said.
"The interference is, in all of the circumstances, unreasonable. The claimants should not be expected to suffer the interference without compensation."
The Croxalls also sought punitive damages, which the judge said are rarely awarded at all in nuisance cases. In this case, Brecknell found the Croxalls were entitled.
"The actions of the defendants, and particularly Mr. Laverdure, were, at a minimum, vindictive and malicious. They took calculated and deliberate actions meant to interfere with the claimants’ peaceful use and enjoyment of their property. Punitive damages are necessary and appropriate in these circumstances," the judge wrote.
"They must be of a level to give the defendants’ pause before committing any further retaliatory actions against the claimants and to provide a warning to others in similar circumstances not to engage in such behaviour," the decision continued, awarding the Croxalls $2,000.
Because the case was in provincial court, compensation was the only remedy available, the judge noted. If it had proceeded in B.C. Supreme Court, either party could have sought "injunctive relief," meaning the court could have issued an order requiring either party to "take a specific action or be required to cease a specific action."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Arrests made after gunshots fired at Toronto Jewish girls' school
A 20-year-old man and a 17-year-old boy are facing multiple charges after allegedly firing gunshots at a Jewish girls' school last weekend.
Millions of Cubans lose power after national grid fails
Cuba plunged into a countrywide blackout on Friday after one of the island's major power plants failed and caused the national electrical grid to shut down, its energy ministry said.
Suspect charged in hand-scooping incident at B.C. frozen yogurt shop
Days after a man was recorded walking behind the counter at a frozen yogurt shop in Richmond, B.C., and scooping product with his hand, a suspect has been criminally charged.
There may be less chocolate at the door this Halloween
If you're heading out trick or treating this Halloween, you may end up with more chips, gummies, licorice and other goodies rather than chocolate. Cocoa prices have spiked, and that could be playing a trick with what your kids come home with and what you give out on Halloween night.
SaskPower receives largest workplace fine in province's history for 2020 deaths of employees in Weyburn
SaskPower was sentenced Friday morning in a Weyburn courtroom, receiving a record fine, after being found guilty of three workplace-safety related violations when two experienced employees were killed on the job in 2020.
Toronto to swiftly 'limit activity' near Rogers Centre during Taylor Swift's 6 concerts
Taylor Swift is coming to Toronto and the city is working to shake off its gridlock problems by implementing a '"limited activity zone' around the Rogers Centre during the two-week period when she is scheduled to play six sold-out shows.
Ticketmaster users to be credited for hidden fees in $6M Canadian settlement
Canadian music and sports fans could soon receive Ticketmaster credits after a settlement was reached in a class-action lawsuit.
Family says Uber driver abandoned teenage girl in Metro Vancouver parking lot
A Vancouver mom says she wants Uber to hold one of its drivers accountable for leaving her 14-year-old daughter in a parking lot in Burnaby.
Dog spotted hanging out on top of ancient pyramid in Egypt
While flying over Egypt’s famous Great Pyramids at sunrise earlier this week, U.S. paraglider Marshall Mosher and fellow paragliders spotted the unexpected sight of a stray hound also taking in views around the summit of one of the ancient wonders.