Evacuee from fire-ravaged Lytton, B.C., files lawsuit against railways
A woman who lost her home and business in the devastating fire that devoured Lytton, B.C., this summer has filed a lawsuit arguing two Canadian railway companies were at least partially responsible for the blaze.
Carel Moiseiwitsch's claim, filed Wednesday in B.C. Supreme Court, alleges Canadian Pacific Railway and Canadian National Railway "caused or contributed" to the fire that razed most of the village on June 30.
Moiseiwitsch's three-bedroom home, where she operated an IT and graphic design company, was among the properties lost.
“We didn’t realize how fast (the fire) was going and we didn’t realize that the whole town was going to be consumed,” she said Wednesday.
According to the proposed class-action lawsuit, the blaze was not related to other fires burning in the area, but rather began as a result of "heat and/or spark emanating from a freight train" that was owned by CP Rail and operated by CN Rail.
"The Lytton fire was not caused by the forest fire or the Boston Bar fire or a lightning strike. The burn area of the Lytton fire does not overlap with the area of the forest fire or the Boston Bar fire," it reads.
The lawsuit argues the record-breaking temperatures registered in Lytton in the days leading up to the fire – including a sweltering 49.6 C recorded on June 29 – left it unsafe to operate trains.
One of Moiseiwisch’s lawyers, Jason Gratl, told CTV News:
“We are reasonably confident that the eyewitness, train schedule, and burn pattern evidence converge on the conclusion that a CP train operated by CN personnel on CN tracks caused the Lytton fire.”
None of the allegations in Moiseiwitsch's lawsuit have been proven in court, and neither CP Rail nor CN Rail has filed a statement of defence in the suit. Both previously denied they had anything to do with the blaze.
In a statement, a spokesperson for CP declined to comment on the civil filing and told CTV News “any conclusions or speculation regarding any cause … remains premature.”
Spokesperson Salem Woodrow pointed to a previously issued statement that read, in part:
“Based on our review of train records, including contemporaneous video footage, CP has found nothing to indicate that any of CP's trains or equipment that passed through Lytton caused or contributed to the fire.”
CN told CTV News it had received the lawsuit, and the investigation into the cause remains ongoing.
Canada's Transportation Safety Board has been investigating the Lytton fire since July 9. The probe was launched after an initial investigation into the ignition point by the RCMP and B.C. Wildfire Service "raised concerns regarding the potential involvement of a freight train," according to the TSB website.
The TSB has not released a report into the incident or shared any preliminary findings. Officials said the investigation could take two years to complete.
Moiseiwitsch's lawsuit alleges the railways should have known it was unsafe to operate in the Lytton area during the heat wave, and failed to ensure there were "spark arrestors, braking, and other systems on the train that are less prone to cause fire in the vicinity of the tracks."
It also alleges there was a failure to remove brush, shrubbery and other potential fire fuel from the area around the tracks.
Moiseiwitsch is seeking financial compensation in the form of general damages for alleged negligence on the part of the defendants, as well as punitive damages and aggravated damages. Her lawsuit also asks that the court declare the fire a private and public nuisance.
She and her partner are temporarily living with family in Vancouver, and even if they rebuild their home in Lytton, she’s not sure if she wants to return.
“(The fire) was like a massive monster or something. It was all your worst nightmares,” Moiseiwitsch said.
“I think I would be too afraid (to return),” she added.
Vancouver Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
As a convoy of truckers head to Ottawa to protest the federal government's cross-border vaccine mandate, some truckers are distancing themselves from the movement as it attracts support from fringe groups and generates dangerous rhetoric.
While vaccines have played a major role in protecting long-term care homes from the same deadly toll the first wave of COVID-19 took on residents, the impact has still been profound during the Omicron wave.
As a convoy of truckers made its way through Ontario on Thursday, hundreds of supporters gathered along roadways and overpasses in the Greater Toronto Area, with police warning of major traffic delays.
CTV NEWS IN UKRAINE | New York, Ukraine: City close to Russian border watches prospect of invasion closely
Residents of a Ukrainian city near the Russian border who have sought to distance themselves from the historical influence of their neighbour are now feeling the unease of a potential invasion.
CTV NEWS IN AFGHANISTAN | 'We have nothing now': Female taekwondo star banned from sport by Taliban
Anzorat Wali is a female Afghan taekwondo star who took up the sport to learn self defence. She swiftly began earning medals, more golds than she can remember, but her dream of competing in the Olympics died the day the Taliban arrived. 'We have nothing now. We have nothing,' she tells CTV National News' Paul Workman in Kabul.
Family of four found frozen to death near Canada-U.S. border identified; RCMP investigation continues
Four people who froze to death while trying to cross the Canada-U.S. border in Manitoba have been identified. According to a release from the High Commission of India, the four people have been identified as Jagdish Baldevbhai Patel, 39, Vaishaliben Jagdishkumar Patel, 37, Vihangi Jagdishkumar Patel, 11, and Dharmik Jagdishkumar Patel, 3.
Canadian musician Jann Arden said writing her newest album in the middle of the pandemic gave her 'a lot of time to be reflective.' The writing process for 'Descendant,' Arden's 15th studio album out Friday, began in the spring of 2020, in the early days of the global outbreak of COVID-19.
A number of provinces are tweaking their public health protocols to ease restrictions as COVID-19 hospitalizations continue to show signs of stabilizing.
A deer that had fallen through the ice-covered Westwood Lake in Nanaimo, B.C. was rescued by firefighters on Tuesday afternoon.
B.C. health officials say 13 new COVID-19-related deaths were confirmed across the province Thursday, including one in Island Health. The update brings B.C.'s pandemic death toll to 2,588, including 168 deaths in Island Health.
'People want to save money': Popularity of consignment and thrift stores growing as cost of living climbs
If you find your dollar isn't going as far as it once did, you are not alone. That means more people are turning to consignment and thrift stores to save a buck.
Alberta reported 14 new COVID-19 deaths on Thursday as hospitalizations continue to put pressure on the health-care system.
Alberta's nurses have overwhelmingly ratified a new collective bargaining agreement.
Premier Jason Kenney says he wants to eliminate Alberta's COVID-19 vaccine passport program as soon as it's safe to do so.
Ontario's top doctor says it’s time to 'learn to live with COVID-19' as he anticipates the province is in for a much better spring.
Although the scale of COVID-19 and its impact on the Canadian health-care system has been unprecedented, there are lessons to be learned from previous viruses, some of which are being used right here in Ontario.
There's nothing standard about Ontario's provincewide high school math test this year.
As Canadian truckers and their supporters make their way from western Canada to Ottawa this weekend, Quebec truckers are expected to gather at several border crossings, including Lacolle, Stanstead and St-Theophile, hoping to support the cause.
Quebec public health officials expect 'modest' drop in hospitalizations, measures to be relaxed weekly
The number of patients in Quebec hospitals is expected to dip over the next few weeks based on projections, but public health officials warn sanitary measures need to be lifted cautiously and gradually.
The man who organized a 'party plane' of Quebec influencers on an ill-fated New Year's trip to Mexico says he's now planning to sue Sunwing, the airline that flew them down on a charter flight before cancelling their return trip.
New national guidelines aimed at improving the quality of life and care for people in nursing homes are now available for public review and feedback.
As of Friday, Saskatchewan parents and caregivers are no longer required to tell schools if their child has COVID-19 - a decision that isn't sitting well with two Saskatoon parents.
Saskatchewan Medical Health Officer Saqib Shahab compared living with the Omicron COVID-19 variant to the annual flu season.
The province is lowering the self-isolation period to five days for unvaccinated residents, effective Friday. Unvaccinated residents were previously required to self-isolate for 10 days.
'I would never do that': Former doctor responds to sexual assault allegations from fifth and final complainant
Sylvester Ukabam, a former doctor accused of sexually assaulting five patients, responded to allegations from the fifth and final complainant from the witness stand on Thursday morning.
Saskatchewan reported another 1,273 cases of COVID-19 on Wednesday, along with two more deaths.
A low-pressure system east of Florida will merge with a cold front to develop into a powerful winter storm that will move northward, just off the eastern U.S. seaboard, before crossing Nova Scotia into the Gulf of St. Lawrence by Sunday.
Halifax Regional Police has arrested a 12-year-old boy from Dartmouth, N.S. following a robbery at a variety store.
Hundreds of Maritimers lined highways, packed parking lots and showed their support on Thursday for the rally of truckers headed to Ottawa, protesting Canada-wide COVID-19 mandates.
Supporters showed up in droves, converging on highway overpasses and along roadways waving flags and signs, backing the 'Freedom Convoy' as it made its way through London, Ont. Thursday.
On an empty lot in a retail section of west London, Ont. lives a man trying to escape homelessness. His name is Brian McManus.
The London Health Sciences Centre is reporting it has 166 inpatients with COVID-19, hitting the same record high at the hospital for the third time this month.
Those who need to get warm are heading to the transit terminal in the North Bay's downtown.
Various legion branches of the Royal Canadian Legion are distributing funds from the 2021 Poppy Campaign.
Addictions and Mental Health Advocates have opened a new community hub on Gore Street, with the hope of filling the void left by the shutdown of the neighbourhood resource centre.
Two housing units at A Better Tent City in Kitchener were damaged Thursday in a fire.
Ontarians will be allowed to eat at sporting events on Monday, will not need to provide contact information
Ontario has released more details about what individuals should expect when the province moves to the first step of the latest reopening plan.
In November 2021, the Waterloo Regional Police Service decided to close its Rural North Division in Elmira and instead deploy officers from the North Division in Waterloo, about 13 kilometres away.