Court rules against absentee landlord who lived in China while his B.C. tenants caused nuisance
The China-based owner of a house in Coquitlam has lost his bid to get a default judgment against him thrown out.
In the summer of 2020, Xian Yu Tang was the owner of a house on Dory Street, which he rented to tenants who owned two large dogs – a Rottweiler and a German shepherd – according to a B.C. Supreme Court decision issued last week.
In the decision, Justice Baljinder Kaur Girn notes that the dogs barked "incessantly" and the tenants "played loud music throughout the day and night."
Neighbours Heide Goldmanis and Micka Devkota were among those frustrated by the noise, and would eventually become plaintiffs in a small claims case against Tang.
Before commencing that action, however, Goldmanis attempted to address the situation by engaging with the tenants and their landlord directly.
"Ms. Goldmanis spoke to the tenants and asked them to control their dogs," the decision reads. "The tenants refused and also refused to identify themselves. Thereafter, Ms. Goldmanis wrote a note to the landlord, the petitioner, addressed to the house in question. She gave the letter to the tenants and asked that they forward it to the landlord. The tenants told her that the petitioner lived in China and would not provide his mailing address."
Goldmanis conducted a land title search and determined that Tang was the owner, and that his listed mailing address was the property in question, according to the decision.
She and Devkota then filed their notice of claim in small claims court and sent notice to Tang by registered mail at the Dory Street address.
Tang never responded to the claim, and a default judgment was awarded in favour of the plaintiffs. In March 2022, a provincial court judge awarded damages of $7,500 to each plaintiff, plus an additional $5,000 to Goldmanis for what Girn describes in her later decision as "pain, suffering and mental stress caused by the noise disturbances."
Landlord responds
Girn's decision indicates a "certificate of judgment" was sent to the Dory Street address, and this time, Tang received it.
His lawyer filed an application asking the provincial court to set aside the default judgment and dismiss the nuisance claim in its entirety.
The provincial court judge who heard the application rejected it, finding that – although the absentee landlord had not willfully or deliberately ignored the initial notice of claim and had filed his application to set it aside without unreasonable delay – Tang did not have "a meritorious defence" against the claim.
Specifically, the lower court judge found that Tang's lawyer had provided no evidence to suggest that a landlord is not liable for his tenant's nuisance. Indeed, Tang's lawyer told the court no such case law exists in Canada, and instead asked the court to consider a U.K. case that established such a precedent.
Canadian judges are not bound by decisions from other countries, even those with very similar legal systems, and the provincial court judge dismissed Tang's application.
"The defendant certainly has an opportunity now to sue the tenants for the debt owing by the defendant to the claimant," the lower court judge wrote when dismissing the application, as quoted in Girn's B.C. Supreme Court decision.
The day after the provincial court decision, Tang's lawyer "attended the court registry" to ask the judge to reconsider, according to Girn's decision. The reason for the request was that the lawyer had found a B.C. case that he claimed would establish the same principle he had argued citing the U.K. case.
"Having already issued his reasons, Judge Smith declined to accept the new case for reconsideration," Girn's decision reads.
B.C. Supreme Court ruling
Girn issued her decision in response to Tang's application for a judicial review of the lower court's rulings.
Tang sought to have Girn set aside the provincial court decisions and issue her own ruling on the case. Goldmanis and Devkota opposed Tang's application.
Tang's lawyer argued that the lower court judge's decision was unreasonable, and that he should have reopened the case when presented with the newly discovered B.C. decision that supported Tang's position.
Girn disagreed with this argument, concluding it was reasonable for the judge to rely on Tang's lawyer's assertion that there was no Canadian case law on the subject.
"Counsel for the petitioner informed Judge Smith that the only case on point was from the United Kingdom," Girn's decision reads.
"If I were to accept the petitioner’s submissions, it would require me to conclude that Judge Smith should have rejected the petitioner’s argument that there were in fact no cases in Canada on this point. It simply cannot be."
Further, the Supreme Court justice declined to consider the B.C. case Tang's lawyer had belatedly brought forward, noting that a judicial review is not an opportunity to re-argue the facts of a case.
"In my respectful view, the failure of the petitioner’s counsel to adequately research the issue prior to bringing his application before Judge Smith should not now permit the petitioner a further opportunity to re-argue his claim," the decision reads.
"He ought to have raised this case before Judge Smith in the first instance. The respondents are entitled to finality on the underlying issue of nuisance that occurred almost four years ago."
Girn dismissed Tang's case and awarded court costs to Goldmanis and Devkota.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Indigo Books & Music shareholders vote to approve privatization sale
Indigo Books & Music Inc. shareholders have voted to approve a deal that will see the retailer become a private company. Shareholders voted Monday in favour of a $2.50 per share offer from Trilogy Retail Holdings Inc. and Trilogy Investments L.P., which have a 56 per cent stake in Indigo and are owned by Gerald Schwartz, the spouse of Indigo chief executive Heather Reisman.
Canada pledges visas for 5,000 Gaza residents related to Canadians
Canada said on Monday it would grant temporary visas to 5,000 Gaza residents under a special program for Canadians' relatives living in the war-torn enclave, a preparatory move in case they are able to leave in the future.
What Canadian grocery shoppers need to know about anticompetitive allegations
Amid mounting outrage over high grocery prices, a retail expert says there's a solution to fostering more competition in the country.
Arrests made in 'highly orchestrated' GTA auto theft operation: police
Peel Regional Police say they have arrested 16 suspects and issued arrest warrant for another 10 individuals in connection with an auto theft investigation carried out by a 'highly orchestrated criminal operation.'
Latest deadly weather in U.S. kills at least 20 as storms carve path of ruin across multiple states
Powerful storms killed at least 20 people, injured hundreds and left a wide trail of destruction across Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas after obliterating homes and destroying a truck stop where dozens sought shelter during the latest deadly weather to strike the central U.S.
North Korea launched a rocket likely carrying a second spy satellite. It's unclear if successful
North Korea launched a rocket likely carrying its second military spy satellite on Monday night, hours after its announcement of a plan to put a satellite into orbit drew strong rebukes from its neighbours.
She developed a passion for genealogy while finding her roots. Now she helps others find their own
Lauren Robilliard always knew she was adopted. As the B.C. native grew older, she developed a passion for genealogy, tracing her roots and paving the way for a career to help others find their own.
'We're standing strong': Rally held outside Jewish school in Toronto hit with gunfire
Toronto’s Jewish community held a rally Monday morning outside of a Jewish girls’ school which was hit with gunfire over the weekend and said they won't be intimidated by acts of violence.
Former 'General Hospital' actor Johnny Wactor fatally shot in Los Angeles
Former 'General Hospital' actor Johnny Wactor was fatally shot in downtown Los Angeles while interrupting thieves Saturday, according to his agent and CNN affiliate KABC.