B.C. woman fired after 'strongly worded' email wins $81K for wrongful termination
A B.C. woman who was fired over one "strongly worded" email has been awarded $81,100 in compensation for wrongful dismissal, according to a supreme court decision.
Construction company Gisborne Holdings Ltd. was found to have terminated Kavita Lefebvre without cause in 2022. After a trial earlier this year, the judge determined that email in question did not constitute the sort of "egregious misconduct" that justifies firing a worker for cause.
"Summary dismissal was not a proportionate response to the email, which I find did not rise to the level of insubordination. The email was direct and strongly worded, but it was not rude or unprofessional," Justice Julianne Lamb wrote in a decision posted online Wednesday.
The court heard that Lefebvre was hired on an 18-month contract as an administrator to cover a parental leave.
However, she was fired about six weeks after she started the job after the human resources manager and Lefebvre's direct supervisor "took issue with the tone and content" of an email she sent.
The company argued that the email in question – which is not reproduced in full in the court documents – caused "an irreconcilable breakdown of the employment relationship," the decision says.
The decision lays out the circumstances leading up to the email, describing how there was some tension and conflict in the working relationship, but notes that there was no record of Lefebvre being disciplined at any point prior to her firing and there was no record of anyone following up on the email with a warning or reprimand of any kind.
Lamb explained that the company has a written policy of "progressive discipline," which requires a formal warning and a suspension prior to termination.
"I am not suggesting that Gisborne was not entitled to move right to termination in certain circumstances; however, the fact that Gisborne has a progressive discipline policy that it did not make any attempt to follow after one objectionable email is a factor that suggests Gisborne’s response to the email was not proportionate," Lamb wrote.
"Gisborne was not able to direct the court to any cases in which analogous conduct was found to justify termination," the judge continued.
The judge said the most "objectionable" parts of Lefebvre's email were an allegation that her supervisor engaged in “at best, a deliberate misdirection” and other parts that could be argued to have amounted to "implicit criticism" of the supervisor's behaviour.
Other parts, such as Lefebvre asking to discuss her pay in light of what she understood to be demands that she perform duties outside of her job description, were found to have been reasonable in the circumstances.
"It is not insubordination for an employee to ask to discuss their compensation," the decision said.
The conclusion of the email, according to Lamb, also showed a willingness and intent to continue and improve the working relationship.
"My expectation is that all parties concerned will be held to the same standard, and that the courtesy, honesty, and accountability that I extend will be reciprocated. I too, look forward to positive outcomes and to cordial and professional working relationships and it is my hope that we all work towards this," the email is quoted as saying.
In order for a worker to be fired for cause, the court needs to find that the conduct is "so egregious as to effectively render continuation of the employment relationship impossible," the judge explained.
"In my view, the email cannot reasonably be described as 'egregious' misconduct," Lamb concluded.
The amount of damages awarded reflects what Lefebvre would have earned if she worked the full term of her contract.
The judge declined to award any punitive damages, saying what the company did was not "reprehensible and worthy of censure."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Princess Anne to take part in B.C. ceremony bringing new ship into Pacific fleet
Canada's first Arctic and Offshore Patrol Vessel will officially be brought into the Pacific fleet today and Princess Anne, the sister of King Charles, is scheduled to take part in its commissioning ceremony.
NEW Biscuits with possible plastic pieces, metal found in ground pork: Here are the recalls for this week
Here are the latest recalls Canadians should watch out for, according to Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency.
More than half of Canadians say freedom of speech is under threat, new poll suggests
A new poll suggests a majority of Canadians feel their right to freedom of speech is in danger.
How falling for a stranger she met on a beach led this woman to ditch the U.S. for the French Riviera
Niki Benjamin, from the U.S., had travelled to a paradise island to do some soul searching, and her life ended up going in a very different direction when her dog ran up to a stranger.
Britney Spears 'home and safe' after paramedics responded to an incident at the Chateau Marmont, source tells CNN
A source close to singer Britney Spears tells CNN that the pop star is 'home and safe' after she had a 'major fight' with her boyfriend on Wednesday night at the Chateau Marmont in West Hollywood.
Feds giving Toronto more than $104M to host 2026 FIFA World Cup
The federal government will provide Toronto just over $104 million in funding to host the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Police move in to clear NYU encampment, U.S. campus arrests grow to 2,200 in pro-Palestinian protests
Police moved in to clear an encampment at New York University on Friday at the request of school officials, a move that follows weeks of pro-Palestinian protests at college campuses nationwide that have resulted in nearly 2,200 arrests by police.
Wally, the emotional support alligator once denied entry to a baseball game, is missing
Emotional support animal registrations in the United States reached 115,832 last year, by an industry group’s count. But in the eyes of reptile rescuer Joie Henney, there’s only one: 'Wally Gator.'
Parents of infant who died in wrong-way crash on Ontario's Hwy. 401 were in same vehicle
Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit has released new details about a wrong-way collision in Whitby on Monday night that claimed the lives of four people.