B.C. mother found not guilty of 1st-degree murder of 7-year-old girl
A judge has found a Metro Vancouver mother not guilty of first-degree murder in the death of her seven-year-old child.
The body of Aaliyah Rosa was found in her mother's Langley, B.C., apartment in July 2018. Her mother, Kerry Ann Lewis, was charged with first-degree murder in the case.
The Crown's theory, the court heard, was that Lewis sedated her daughter then drowned the girl in the bathtub of her suite.
The defence argued there was a "huge lack of evidence" in the case, including proof of how the drugs found in the girl's system got there.
Justice Martha Devlin agreed with the Crown, saying that on a balance of probabilities, it was likely Lewis gave the girl sedatives.
But she took issue with the work done by pathologist Dr. Lisa Steele, who conducted the autopsy.
“I have some concerns regarding the reliability of Dr. Steele’s evidence,” she said, noting the pathologist had apparently failed to notice evidence of a pre-existing brain condition.
A pair of neuropathologists who testified as expert witnesses for the defence said Aaliyah lived with hydrocephalus, which is an abnormal buildup of fluid deep within the brain.
The judge accepted their evidence that the condition could have been a contributing factor in Aaliyah’s death.
In delivering her decision, Justice Devlin said the Crown had not proved its theory beyond a reasonable doubt and found Lewis not guilty.
About eight friends and family of Aaliyah were in the gallery, with many more watching on a monitor in an adjacent room.
When the verdict was read, many became very emotional, with some crying and others needing to be restrained by sheriffs as they attempted to move towards Lewis, who was being led out of the courtroom by other sheriffs.
Outside the courthouse, a visibly distraught Stephen Rosa, Aaliyah’s father, declined to speak to the media as friends and family huddled with him in support.
Crown lawyers also declined to address the media so it is not clear yet if they plan to appeal the decision.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Toronto mother now facing murder charge in death of four-month old baby
Toronto police say they have charged a mother with second-degree murder following the death of her infant, who was found with critical injuries in midtown Toronto last week.
Justin Trudeau defends spending record on military amid fresh criticism
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is defending his government's record on supporting national defence, following fresh criticism that Canada is failing to live up to its NATO defence-spending commitments.
Prosecutors demand maximum sentence of 20 years for Gisele Pelicot's ex-husband in mass rape trial
A mammoth rape trial in France moved into a new phase Monday as prosecutors began to lay out the verdicts and punishments they want for dozens of men accused of raping Gisele Pelicot while she was drugged and rendered unconscious by her husband.
Should sex abuse evidence set the Menendez brothers free? A judge will decide
A judge will decide Monday whether new evidence warrants a re-examination of the convictions of Erik and Lyle Menendez in the shotgun murders of their parents in their Beverly Hills home more than 30 years ago.
CEOs say Canada's failure to hit NATO targets by 2030 like playing economic 'Russian Roulette'
The federal government risks jeopardizing the economy unless it meets its NATO military alliance spending obligations within the next five years, says the Business Council of Canada.
Elliot Lake, Ont., woman charged with choking neighbour's dog
An intoxicated woman in Elliot Lake has been charged with breaking into her neighbour's apartment and choking their dog.
'Embarrassing:' NHL team ditches bus and walks to Scotiabank Arena amid gridlock
The Utah Hockey Club got the full Toronto experience Sunday night ahead of their first-ever matchup against the Maple Leafs—bumper-to-bumper traffic that forced the team to walk to the game.
Horse's head and pregnant cow used in 'barbaric' mafia threat in Sicily
The discovery of a severed horse head, and a cow quartered with its bloodied dead calf on top, have rattled a Sicilian town, with authorities treating the incident as a mafia threat.
WATCH Brawl erupts in Serbian parliament
Scuffles broke out in the Serbian parliament on Monday after opposition legislators raised banners accusing the ruling coalition of trying to shirk responsibility for the collapse of a train station roof that killed 15 people earlier this month.