Supreme Court orders new trial for B.C. francophone who was not given French option
A francophone man in British Columbia convicted of sexual assault will get a new trial because he was not informed of his right to be tried in French, the Supreme Court ruled Friday.
Franck Yvan Tayo Tompouba appealed his conviction on the basis that his language rights were violated because he was not told his trial could be conducted in his preferred official language.
“There may be cases in which accused persons are not duly informed of this fundamental linguistic right and of how it is to be exercised,” Chief Justice Richard Wagner wrote in the 5-2 decision.
“This appeal is an example of such a situation, and it is a reminder that Canada's linguistic minorities too often still experience difficulties in accessing justice in the official language of their choice.”
The case arrived at the Supreme Court after the B.C. Court of Appeal dismissed the matter.
The top court heard the initial judge did not ensure Tayo Tompouba had been informed of his right to have a trial in French, as is required by the Criminal Code when an accused's language is either French and English.
The Appeal Court erred in dismissing his bid by saying it was the accused's responsibility to prove that his language rights had been violated, Wagner wrote for the majority.
As a result, the top court quashed his conviction and ordered that a new trial be held in French.
Wagner described as “fundamental” and “absolute” the right of an accused to be tried in the official language of their choice.
The decision details how the right is so essential that an accused only has to “assert” which language “is their own language,” unless the Crown chooses to challenge that.
Judges are not to try and determine an accused's cultural identity or wade into the issue of their personal language preferences, it added.
“In a context as intimidating as that of a criminal trial, when the accused's freedom is at stake,” Wagner wrote, it is crucial that a judge help protect one's language rights “by being vigilant, cautious and proactive.”
It's the role of a judge to remove the “fear” connected to exercising such rights, and to make sure their decision is both “free” and “informed,” the decision says.
“The judge cannot presume what the accused's choice is or assume that the accused has been or will be advised of their right,” including by their own lawyer.
In a dissenting decision, justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Sheilah Martin acknowledged the language rights of an accused, but disputed whether a failure to provide notice of such rights amounts to a “miscarriage of justice.”
They believe the appeal should have been dismissed.
The judges warn that public confidence in the system risks being undermined by granting someone a new trial who waited until after their conviction to raise their language rights.
They contend an accused must do more than simply point to how a court failed to inform them of their right.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 3, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Shooting at Michigan splash pad leaves 'nine, maybe 10 victims': authorities
Gunfire erupted at a splash pad in the Detroit suburb of Rochester Hills, leaving as many as 10 people wounded, authorities said.
As it happened: How the Oilers crushed the Panthers to force Game 5
The Edmonton Oilers' offence exploded in Game 4 to beat the Florida Panthers 8-1.
A new tax filing system could give Canadians more than $1 billion in unclaimed benefits: PBO
Canadians would get more than $1 billion in unclaimed benefits each year through an automatic tax filing system, according to a report published by the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO).
'They're not human beings, they're animals': Trump blasts immigrants for taking jobs
Donald Trump blamed immigrants for stealing jobs and government resources as he courted separate groups of Black voters and hardcore conservatives in battleground Michigan on Saturday.
Video shows northern Ont. storm hammer shoreline, breaking dock
The owner of a northern Ont. camp is continuing to clean up after an intense storm that prompted a tornado warning Thursday ripped through the area breaking his dock and downing trees.
'All hands on deck situation': City of Calgary declares state of local emergency over water main break
The City of Calgary declared a local state of emergency Saturday morning in response to the latest developments in a major water main break that is impacting the city.
BREAKING A 'brazen daylight shooting': 16-year-old boy was fatally shot in Scarborough during fight, say police
Toronto police are appealing for witnesses and information as they deploy a “significant amount of resources” into the investigation of the fatal shooting of a 16-year-old boy in Scarborough on Saturday afternoon.
Trudeau calls into question findings of stunning watchdog foreign interference report
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he has concerns with how conclusions were gathered in a spy watchdog report.
U.K. royals unite on palace balcony as Princess of Wales returns to public view after cancer diagnosis
London put on a display of birthday pageantry Saturday for King Charles III, a military parade that marked the Princess of Wales ' first public appearance since her cancer diagnosis early this year.