Ministry staff refuse to answer questions as B.C. health researchers offered rapid tests for a party
Ministry of Health staff are denying that some health researchers were promised rapid antigen tests to screen for COVID-19 at a Christmas party, even though CTV News Vancouver has obtained the internal memo outlining the plan.
In total, three questions were posed to the ministry, and despite follow-up attempts to address the quantity, distribution and availability of rapid tests, communications staff did not respond.
The provincial government will not provide rapid antigen tests to the public despite having millions in storage, but in an email about a holiday party the BC Centre of Substance Use told employees that “as part of the safety planning, (Providence Health Care) will be supplying us with rapid COVID tests” for their in-person gathering next week.
“No, that is incorrect, BCCSU is not being provided rapid tests for their holiday party,” insisted a Ministry of Health spokesperson nearly six hours after CTV News referenced the memo in an email inquiring about rapid tests. The questions CTV News asked were:
- How many rapid tests are going to health authorities or other government ministries and agencies for holiday parties?
- Public Health Agency of Canada data shows two million rapid tests provided by the federal government have not been distributed in B.C. Is that accurate?
- How and why has the province kept B.C. pharmacies from selling the tests here?
TOP DOCTOR DEFENDS RAPID TEST STRATEGY
While the ministry refused to answer those questions, the provincial health officer shot down the idea of providing families with rapid tests ahead of the holiday season, pointing out she has decided that the federally-provided tests will only be used in certain situations – typically for people who have COVID-19 symptoms.
"I think my focus is on where they make a difference in terms of a parent assessing whether a child should go into school today. We've been using them in more remote communities where access to PCR testing can be a challenge,” said Dr. Bonnie Henry on Tuesday, adding they’re also being used for care home visitors and occasionally in school outbreaks and other situations.
“We are looking at whether it makes sense to have rapid tests available for people … It is an evolving issue.”
Henry insisted there are not enough rapid tests, but the province has not been distributing the units provided by the federal government, so it’s likely the federal government has not bothered sending more with so many unused and belated use of the ones that have been distributed.
B.C. has received 3.2 million rapid antigen tests and distributed 1.17 million, while Ontario has received 31 million from the federal government and distributed 33 million; that province’s population is roughly triple British Columbia’s.
RAPID TESTS ‘NOT A SILVER BULLET’
One of the most high-profile proponents of rapid testing, who’s guided Nova Scotia’s implementation of the technology, pointed out that rapid tests alone cannot curb or avoid infections.
“They’re not a silver bullet,” said Dr. Lisa Barrett, an infectious disease specialist and professor at Dalhousie University.
“But it's a tool worth considering and we have tonnes of people who tell us 'there's no way I'm getting vaccinated’ and they come and get tests all the time."
Barrett described a culture shift in her province, where the tests are readily available to take home or administer at various testing sites, providing results in less than half an hour in a de-medicalized procedure. Most people self-administer the test, which is not much different than taking a blood-glucose reading.
When CTV News raised Henry’s objection to the technology on the grounds the tests don’t find many cases, Barrett said it’s true that there haven’t been huge numbers of cases identified, but said the constant asymptomatic testing and monitoring for cases has helped. She also emphasized “testing will never take the place of basic public health measures,” including a robust vaccination campaign and consistent rules around distancing and indoor mask-wearing.
“Having early asymptomatic testing has been helpful,” Barrett said. “About 20 per cent of early cases through wave three were found in no-symptom testing before lots and lots of contacts."
And while she emphasized that rapid tests alone are not a panacea and won’t be required forever, she said they’re a useful tool right now for people who want to feel like they’re contributing in the battle to curb infection and help avoid exposing seniors and other high-risk people to the virus. Nova Scotia is currently ramping up its campaign to encourage people to take testing kits home before the holidays.
“It’s important when we’re trying to have a goal of keeping things at a low community virus level,” said Barrett, saying the tests provide many people with peace of mind.
“We’re not quite at what we call the endemic stage, thinking of this as just a cold virus.”
Vancouver Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canada's Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly has an 'open invitation' to visit Moscow to meet with Russian officials, an offer first extended in December, says Ambassador to Canada Oleg Stepanov.
Global Affairs Canada confirmed Saturday it is aware of the deaths of two Canadian citizens in Mexico, a day after local officials in the country reported a shooting at a resort near Playa del Carmen that also injured a third individual.
Britain on Saturday accused the Kremlin of seeking to install a pro-Russian leader in Ukraine, and said Russian intelligence officers had been in contact with a number of former Ukrainian politicians as part of plans for an invasion.
Royal Canadian Navy commander Vice-Admiral Craig Baines admits he made a mistake by golfing with retired general Jonathan Vance last summer while the former chief of the defence staff was being investigated for alleged sexual misconduct.
Canada's foreign ministry has advised staff serving around the world to watch for mysterious illness symptoms following unexplained health incidents among diplomats in Cuba and U.S. personnel in various countries.
The president of Ukraine is thanking Canada for a $120-million loan aimed at bolstering his country's economy amid a hostile buildup of 100,000 Russian troops along its borders.
The discovery of four people who perished in the cold trying to cross the Canada-U.S. border could put a new twist on the immigration debate in the United States.
As icebergs drifted by his Antarctica-bound ship, David Holland spoke this week of how the melting glacier he's cruising towards may contain warning signals for the coasts of far-off Canada.
Certain sets of the popular toy Lego could result in fairly high returns once resold, with some research suggesting gains of as much as 11 per cent.
The Salish Sea has been alive with rare cetaceans lately. Risso’s dolphins were sighted Friday near Nanaimo in the Strait of Georgia, and last week a fin whale was spotted foraging for food near a popular beach in North Seattle.
Residents of the Seabreeze Inne on Salt Spring Island are breathing a sigh of relief after the province announced new permanent homes and shelter space for the homeless and most vulnerable.
BC Housing is in the early stages of redevelopment planning for the decades-old Evergreen Terrace affordable housing complex in Victoria.
The Calgary Food Bank has no shortage of food on its shelves right now but what it does need, however, is volunteers.
Calgary fire is investigating after two fires at a condo building in Beltline Saturday afternoon.
The Calgary Fire Department says all of the occupants, as well as their pets, are safe after a fire broke out in the basement of a home Saturday afternoon.
Cheerleaders, parents frustrated with EPSB short notice not allowing them to attend Expo Centre event due to COVID-19 rules
Some cheerleaders and parents from two Edmonton Public Schools are frustrated with the district after they were not allowed to attend a competition in person this weekend.
An Edmonton man will spend three nights in an igloo he built if he raises money for multiple sclerosis (MS) research.
Three people are in custody after an incident in Morinville on Saturday, RCMP said. There was a heavy police presence in the area of 103 Street and 100 Avenue.
The province’s police watchdog is investigating after an officer-involved shooting left a man dead in Markham on Friday night.
A 75-year-old man is among multiple people in Ontario who say they were accidentally given the equivalent of six doses of the COVID-19 vaccine while getting their booster shot.
Businesses in Quebec are reopening on Sundays, after being forced to close their doors on Jan. 2, 9 and 16. On Monday, vaccine passports will be required at big box stores.
The American Hockey League has suspended San Jose Barracuda forward Krystof Hrabik 30 games for making a "racial gesture" at Tucson Roadrunners left-wing Boko Imama during a game last week.
A smog warning remains in effect in Montreal, Quebec City and other regions of the province on Sunday.
A new study shows a majority of Canadians are finding it difficult to keep their cupboards stocked with food.
Canada's top doctor has said the latest wave of COVID-19 driven by the Omicron variant may have reached its peak. But while the modelling appears encouraging, experts say the news should be interpreted with cautious optimism.
‘In the Name of Love’ spaceman snow sculpture is the creation of Bradley Gerbrandt.
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau shared their condolences to mark the six year anniversary of the La Loche shooting that killed four people and injured seven others on Jan. 22, 2016.
'Sewer smell in there is horrible': Saskatoon residents frustrated with city over basements repeatedly flooding
Residents living in the 3400 block of 11th Street W in Saskatoon whose basements have flooded say this isn’t the first time its happened.
The Saskatoon Blades beat the Medicine Hat Tigers 9-2 in a Friday night matchup at the SaskTel Centre.
Clark Gillies, a Hockey Hall of Famer and Regina Pats legend, has died at the age of 67.
Sask. has broken its daily increase in COVID-19 cases record for the fourth time this month, with 1,483 new cases reported Saturday.
A Canada-wide warrant has been issued for a Saskatchewan man charged with the abduction of his seven-year-old daughter.
New Brunswick reported six additional deaths related to COVID-19 on Saturday.
Dan Shaw from the Dalhousie Rowe School of Business believes the increase in property assessments in Nova Scotia is linked to the current real estate market, especially in Halifax.
Level 3 restrictions have been hard on businesses across New Brunswick - many have had to close, reduce capacity, or turn to take out only.
Teenagers Tanner Ducharme and Dylan Wilkins were the first to test out the ice at London's newest community ice rink.
Firefighters arrived to heavy smoke when responding to a house fire in Sarnia early Saturday morning.
The Samaritan Centre is a multi agency facility that offers services for Sudbury’s vulnerable population dealing with barriers like homelessness, food insecurity, mental health and substance abuse issues.
Snowmobilers, UTV and snow bike racers from across Canada are in Sault Ste. Marie to participate in the 2022 Snowcross racing event.
A West Nipissing woman living with ALS is speaking out about how the shortage of Personal Support Workers is impacted her life.
Parents and guardians will be able to watch their kids play sports in Ontario when action returns on January 31, with a 50 per cent capacity limit on spectators.
The province's Special Investigations Unit says a snowmobiler suffered serious injuries after allegedly fleeing from police outside of Fergus.