Experts doubt foreign buyer ban extension will help affordability
Over the weekend, Ottawa quietly extended its foreign homebuyer ban until 2027.
But some experts question whether it will make any difference to affordability in the Lower Mainland.
“The analogy I like to draw is a lemon that has had all the juice squeezed out of it by the foreign buyer taxes here, and by the empty homes and speculation taxes, so no real room for this to have an effect on affordability,” economist Tom Davidoff with the University of British Columbia’s Sauder School of Business said Monday.
In 2021, the year before the foreign buyer ban was announced, roughly 1.1 per cent of sales in B.C. involved a non-Canadian buyer.
"Notably, in 2023, prices basically rose steadily from the start of the year, so as soon as the ban was in effect, we had nothing but rising prices,” said Brendon Ogmundson, chief economist for the BC Real Estate Association. “So, as a sort of salve for affordability, it certainly is not a very effective policy."
And given the other measures in place locally, Premier David Eby offered a muted response to the ban’s extension.
“I don’t expect the extension of the federal foreign buyer ban to have a significant impact on the housing market in British Columbia as a result, but it may have an impact in other provinces where they don’t have these protections,” Eby said Monday.
While B.C. brought in a foreign buyer tax in 2016, the federal government only decided to implement a ban in 2022 – after local measures had already changed buyer behaviour.
“Canada, federally, is a little bit late with this foreign buyer ban, and a two-year extension just seems like a little bit of a fluff – maybe there’s an election coming up or something like that,” remarked David Hutchinson, a Vancouver realtor.
But others feel some restrictions around real estate are appropriate – and needed – even beyond this ban.
“There is going to be a needed national discussion about how you work with people who have second, third and fourth homes, who keep them empty,” said Andy Yan, director of the City Program at Simon Fraser University.
One area of focus for some researchers is what to do with people who clearly have significant wealth, but don’t contribute much tax.
“I think there are sensible demand-side measures,” Davidoff said. “There’s lots of homes that are occupied by Canadians really not connected to the local labour market, so not foreign buyers, but homeowners who are very affluent, but not through the work force.
“A lot of these people who own very fancy homes and are obviously very rich, but pay very little tax in Canada.”
Along with other researchers, Davidoff has calculated if there were a requirement on the owners of the top 10 per cent of homes by value to pay at least one per cent of property value in taxes to Canada and the province, that could generate $2 billion in each of Metro Vancouver and the Greater Toronto Area.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
B.C. serial killer Robert Pickton dead following prison attack
Convicted B.C. serial killer Robert Pickton, who preyed on women he lured from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside to his rural pig farm, has died.
2 children among 5 people hospitalized after head-on crash on Hwy. 417 in Ottawa's west end
Two young children and three adults were seriously injured in a major collision on Highway 417 between Palladium Drive and Carp Road in Ottawa's west end Friday afternoon.
DND moving 1,000 employees out of Ottawa office building due to safety concerns
The Department of National Defence is moving approximately 1,000 employees out of an office building in Ottawa's Lowertown neighbourhood, citing safety concerns for its employees.
Baby dead after being delivered via emergency C-section to woman who was in police custody
A newborn is dead after being delivered via emergency C-section to a woman in police custody.
Marian Robinson, mother of Michelle Obama, dies at 86
Marian Shields Robinson, the mother of Michelle Obama who moved with the first family to the White House when son-in-law Barack Obama was elected president, has died. She was 86.
Jennifer Lopez cancels summer tour: 'I am completely heartsick and devastated'
Jennifer Lopez has cancelled her 2024 North American tour, representatives for Live Nation confirmed to The Associated Press.
This Calgary home has a giant tree in the middle, and it's for sale
There's a luxury 'tree home' for sale in Calgary.
'We will go with the majority': Liberals slammed by opposition over proposal to delay next election
The federal Liberal government learned Friday it might have to retreat on a proposal within its electoral reform legislation to delay the next vote by one week, after all opposition parties came out to say they can't support it.
These are the recalls in Canada this week
Health Canada recalled various items this week, including more unauthorized products, counterfeit drugs and bassinets.