Edited photos, virtual staging should void contract for home purchase, B.C. man argues
![Real estate contract This photo shows a contract for purchase and sale. (Credit: Shutterstock)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/8/14/real-estate-contract-1-7000918-1723668523811.jpg)
A B.C. man who backed out on a deal to buy a house after he realized online photos of it were edited and virtually staged has been ordered to pay a penalty for rescinding the contract.
Braden Messenger entered into a $490,000 contract of purchase and sale for a property being sold by Mary Bell in 2023, according to a decision from the Civil Resolution Tribunal on the dispute over the $1,225 fee.
"It is undisputed that Mr. Messenger did not view the property before agreeing to the CPS," tribunal member Alison Wake wrote.
After seeing the property, Messenger notified Bell that he was rescinding the contract. He argued he should not have to pay the fee, which Bell was claiming, because the property was misrepresented.
"Mr. Messenger says that before he made the offer that formed the basis for the CPS, Ms. Bell or her agent added photographs to the property’s online listing that had been virtually staged and significantly altered, without including a disclaimer or notation," the decision said.
"Mr. Messenger says these photographs constitute a misrepresentation, and so the CPS is void."
Bell did not dispute that the photos were edited and evidence reviewed by the tribunal showed that the listing photos were "significantly altered," including by being virtually staged. In one instance, according to the decision, a "large area of peeling paint" had been edited out of a photo of a bedroom.
However, the issue of whether the property was misrepresented was found to be irrelevant to the question of whether Messenger was required to pay the fee.
Messenger signed a "notice of rescission" exercising his right to terminate the contract under a particular section of B.C.'s Property Law Act. This, Bell argued, was not his only option in the situation.
"Mr. Messenger could have let his offer lapse by not removing the subjects to it, with no penalty," the decision says.
Contracts can be cancelled for "a material misrepresentation by the other party," the tribunal noted. But the document Messenger signed explicitly agreed to a penalty equivalent to 0.25 per cent of the property's sale price — an amount mandated by B.C.'s Home Buyer Rescission Period Regulation.
"I find that I do not need to determine whether Ms. Bell materially misrepresented the property’s condition, because Mr. Messenger agreed to pay the rescission fee in any event," Wake wrote.
In addition to the fee, Messenger was ordered to pay Bell $73.84 in pre-judgment and $125 in tribunal fees.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7033216.1726021317!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Kamala Harris goes on offence against Donald Trump in combative debate
Democratic U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris put Republican Donald Trump on the defensive at a combative U.S. presidential debate on Tuesday with a stream of attacks on abortion limits, his fitness for office and his myriad legal woes.
Key quotes from the Trump-Harris 2024 U.S. presidential debate
U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris and former U.S. president Donald Trump took the stage on Tuesday night for their first and only scheduled presidential debate before the Nov. 5 election.
FACT CHECK: A look at the false and misleading claims made during the Trump-Harris debate
In their first and perhaps only debate, former U.S. president Donald Trump and U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris described the state of the country in starkly different terms. As the two traded jabs, some old false and misleading claims emerged along with some new ones.
Trump campaign falsely accuses immigrants in Ohio of abducting and eating pets
Former U.S. president Donald Trump’s campaign and his allies are amplifying false rumours that Haitian immigrants in Ohio were abducting and eating pets, another instance of the inflammatory and anti-immigrant rhetoric Trump has promoted throughout his campaigns.
U.S. presidential historian predicts results of November elections. Here's who he says will win
An American presidential historian is predicting a Kamala Harris presidency as the outcome of the upcoming U.S. elections in November.
Taylor Swift endorses Kamala Harris for U.S. president after debate ends
Taylor Swift, one of the music industry's biggest stars, endorsed Kamala Harris for president shortly after the debate ended on Tuesday night.
Some restaurants have increased their default tip options. Canadians think you should give this much
Despite what the default options on the payment terminal might read, most Canadians still want to tip around 15 per cent, according to a new survey.
Dave Grohl says he fathered a child outside of his marriage
The Foo Fighters frontman announced that he recently became a father again, writing in a statement on his Instagram page on Tuesday that his new baby girl was born 'outside' of his marriage to his wife Jordyn Blum.
$2M home belonging to children's musician Raffi on the market
Canada’s children’s troubadour is selling his B.C. home, which is now up for grabs for $1,995,000.