B.C. widow successfully challenges ICBC's denial of death benefits
A B.C. widow who was denied spousal benefits after her husband died in a motorcycle crash has successfully challenged the move and the public insurer has been ordered to pay her more than $400,000.
The B.C. Civil Resolution ruled on the dispute Friday, finding that the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia wrongfully denied benefits on the basis that that the woman and her husband were not living together at the time of the fatal accident.
Ghislain Dion died in June of 2022 when he was 50 years old, leaving behind two young children and his wife Gian Dion – who he had been married to since 2014. When Mrs. Dion applied for the $380,000 spousal death benefit it was denied, according to the decision.
“ICBC says Mrs. Dion was not Mr. Dion’s spouse because even though they were legally married, they were not residing together when he died,” tribunal vice-chair Eric Regehr wrote.
“Mrs. Dion says that ICBC’s argument ignores the complexity of her relationship with Mr. Dion. She maintains that they were spouses and that she should receive a spousal death benefit accordingly.”
Disagreement over definition
The decision notes that the legal definition of the term “spouse” at issue in the case was the one contained in B.C.’s Enhanced Accident Benefits Regulation. The legislation defines a spouse as someone “who was married to and residing with the deceased on the date of death, or who lived in a marriage-like relationship with the deceased for at least two years immediately preceding the date of death.”
ICBC, for its part, argued that because Mrs. Dion did not meet all of the criteria in the first definition, she should not be considered a spouse under the second – and less restrictive – definition. Regehr found that these definitions were not mutually exclusive.
“Two people can ‘live with’ each other in a marriage-like relationship without residing in the same place, he wrote, rejecting ICBC’s argument that “the words ‘live with’ have the same effect as ‘resides with.’”
Mrs. Dion submitted evidence that acknowledged she had moved out of the family home in the months before her husband’s death, but said the separation was never meant to be permanent. In support of her claim she provided intimate details about her relationship and evidence that included text messages, photos, video, financial information and statements from family and friends.
What is legal separation?
Legally, the decision explains, a couple does not separate the moment they stop living under the same roof. Nor does someone need to move out of a shared home in order for a couple to be separated.
“Once formed, a marriage-like relationship continues to exist unless and until the spouses separate,” the decision says.
“When determining whether a marriage-like relationship has ended, the court asks whether a spouse has communicated an intention to permanently separate and acted on that intention. The court also considers several factors, including whether the couple continues to reside in the same home, remains sexually intimate, carries on activities in public as a couple, shares financial resources, and shares significant family events.”
In this case, there was no evidence that either Mr. or Mrs. Dion indicated that the separation was meant to be anything other than temporary. In addition, the couple’s relationship remained “marriage like” until Mr. Dion’s death.
“I find that Mr. and Mrs. Dion never separated,” Regehr wrote.
The tribunal’s decision also pointed out that ICBC was legally required to pay out the spousal benefit to Mr. Dion’s children regardless of the outcome of this dispute and that the insurer had “no financial stake” in the outcome.
In addition to the $380,000 spousal benefit, the insurer was ordered to pay Mrs. Dion $27,084.11 in pre-judgment interest and $125 in tribunal fees.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian gov't proposes new foreign influence registry as part of wide-spanning new bill
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government is proposing a suite of new measures and law changes aimed at countering foreign interference in Canada, amid extensive scrutiny over past meddling attempts and an ever-evolving threat landscape.
Boeing Starliner capsule's first crewed test flight postponed
The long-awaited first crewed test flight of Boeing's new Starliner space capsule was called off for at least 24 hours over a technical issue that launch teams were unable to resolve in time for the planned Monday night lift-off.
Teacher charged in historical sexual assault of Calgary teenage girl
Calgary police have charged a teacher with the alleged sexual assault of a teenage girl more than 20 years ago.
Winnipeg man admits to killing four women, argues he's not criminally responsible
Defence lawyers of Jeremy Skibicki have admitted in court the accused killed four Indigenous women, but argues he is not criminally responsible for the deaths by way of mental disorder – this latest development has triggered a judge-alone trial rather than a jury trial.
Man banned from owning animals after fatal Calgary dog attack
The owner of three Calgary dogs that got loose and mauled a woman to death in 2022 has been ordered to pay a $15,000 fine within one year and banned from owning any animal for 15 years.
East-end Ottawa family dealing with massive rat infestation
Residents in Ottawa’s Elmridge Gardens complex are dealing with a rat infestation that just won’t go away. Now, after doing everything they can to try to fix the issue, they are pleading with the city to step in and help.
Mediterranean staple may lower your risk of death from dementia, study finds
A daily spoonful of olive oil could lower your risk of dying from dementia, according to a new study by Harvard scientists.
An El Nino-less summer is coming. Here's what that could mean for Canada
As Canadians brace themselves for summer temperatures, forecasters say a weakening El Nino cycle doesn’t mean relief from the heat.
Newfoundland and Labrador latest province to tighten rules on Airbnbs
Newfoundland and Labrador is the latest jurisdiction to bring in stricter rules for short-term rentals, with a coming set of regulations that will force operators to register with the provincial government.