B.C. court decision explains story behind $750K listing for half of 5-bedroom Richmond house
A recent B.C. Supreme Court decision is shedding some light on a bizarre real estate listing offering "undivided half interest" in a five-bedroom home in Richmond for $750,000.
The listing made headlines last month not only for the strange ownership arrangement, but also for its self-aware tone.
"Yes, unusual it is," the description reads, at one point.
The listing, which has been up for 193 days, urges would-be purchasers to do their homework, asking them to consider questions like, "Who would I be sharing ownership with?" and "Does the other half want to sell?"
"WE DO NOT KNOW THESE ANSWERS," it adds, in all-caps. "Please call your Realtor and ask for the explanation with documents posted."
SALE PART OF OWNER'S US$17M DEBT IN CHINA
The court decision issued Monday and posted online Tuesday explains, to some extent, the situation behind the sale.
It begins by noting that the home's co-owner, defendant Chuming Qiao, owes "more than $17 million" to the plaintiff – a company called Asia Growth VIII LP – under an "arbitral award" issued in China in 2018.
The decision later explains that the award in Asia Growth's favour against Qiao was US$17 million, which is a little more than $23 million at Wednesday's Bank of Canada exchange rate.
According to Justice Sandra Wilkinson's decision, Qiao has co-owned the property on Lockhart Road since 2003 with his wife Liping Qin.
While court documents don't specify the exact address of the property featured in the listing, CTV News has confirmed through a title search that it is the same house.
The listing agent declined an interview with CTV News for a previous story about this property.
"The house is Mr. Qiao’s only known exigible asset in British Columbia," the decision reads, later noting that Asia Growth had received a court order allowing it to sell Qiao's 50-per-cent interest in the property in February 2022, and had begun the process of listing it in "early 2023."
TRANSFER TO DAUGHTER WAS 'FRAUDULENT CONVEYANCE'
While these details are all covered in the court decision issued Monday, they're not what the decision was about. Rather, the decision was about an application filed by Qiao and Qin's daughter, Yan Qiao.
In October 2021, title to the property was transferred from Chuming Qiao to Yan Qiao, with Qin remaining a joint tenant, according to the decision. The effect was to transfer the elder Qiao's 50-per-cent ownership to his daughter, and Asia Growth soon filed a lawsuit seeking to have the change reversed on the grounds that the transfer was a "fraudulent conveyance."
The Qiao family did not file a response to Asia Growth's claim, nor did they engage in any communication with the company or its lawyers for more than a year, according to the decision.
This led to a default judgment in Asia Growth's favour in January 2022, allowing the company to begin the process of selling Qiao's interest in the property.
The basis for Monday's decision was an application by Yan Qiao asking the court to set aside the default judgment on the grounds that she was never properly served with notice of Asia Growth's lawsuit.
For a variety of reasons, Wilkinson dismissed the application.
DAUGHTER CLAIMED SHE WAS LIVING IN CHINA
The crux of Yan Qiao's argument that she was not properly notified of the claim against her was an affidavit she filed claiming that she was residing in China at the time various notices and documents were delivered to the door of the Richmond home.
She told the court she was unaware of the legal proceedings and had no reason to believe there were any concerning her.
Wilkinson's decision notes that these assertions were "inconsistent with prior statements to the Land Title and Survey Authority of British Columbia (LTSA) and the Minister of Finance."
"By her own statements made to the LTSA and the Ministry of Finance, the property was her primary residence and had continually been her primary residence for nearly 19 years before the transfer," the decision reads.
"She admits in her first affidavit that she was residing in 'Vancouver' from January 2020 to March 2023. A reasonable inference is that she was living at the property when the notice of civil claim was alternatively served on Dec. 7, 2021. She does not depose that she resided at any specific address. She has provided no explanation for her apparent ignorance of dozens of legal documents delivered by Asia Growth to the attention of her father, and later, herself during the January 2020 to March 2023 period."
The judge further noted that, if the younger Qiao's affidavit asserting she was in China was correct, it would amount to an admission that she had fraudulently evaded property transfer and non-resident taxes at the time the property title was transferred to her name.
Similarly, the Qiao family had lawyers in both B.C. and China who had professional obligations to notify their clients of pending litigation against them, Wilkinson noted, concluding it was likely that both lawyers had fulfilled those obligations and the family had willfully ignored the case.
"The result of the conflicting evidence before me is that Ms. Qiao’s evidence in this proceeding lacks credibility and is unreliable," the decision reads. "She has not provided a plausible explanation for her alleged lack of knowledge of the proceeding."
'BADGES OF FRAUD'
Yan Qiao also sought to have the default judgment set aside under a different section of the B.C. Supreme Court rules that gives judges the discretionary power to do so.
Qiao claimed she had a meritorious defence against Asia Growth's lawsuit, and that the court should set aside the default judgment to allow her to make that defence.
Both father and daughter told the court the transfer of the property was a repayment of a debt the elder Qiao owed to a company owned by the younger.
However, the idea of loan repayment is nowhere to be found in the property transfer documents, according to the decision.
"The defendants all certified to the Land Title Office that the consideration for an inter-family transfer was '$1 and natural love and affection,'" the decision reads. "Now, Ms. Qiao deposes that the transfer was consideration for repayment of an inter-family loan. The transfer forms provide contemporaneous evidence that may be preferred over the after-the-fact evidence provided in response to (a Fraudulent Conveyance Act) action."
Wilkinson concluded that there were "a number of badges of fraud present in connection with the transfer," including the fact that the elder Qiao was insolvent at the time and that the transfer "was initiated with haste" as soon as the younger Qiao found out about her father's debt to Asia Growth.
"Asia Growth will suffer prejudice if the default judgment is set aside," the decision reads. "The $17,000,000 USD arbitral award was made in March of 2018, and very little of that has been recovered to date. It would be contrary to the interests of justice to allow Mr. Qiao to continue to avoid judgment enforcement by relying on affidavits that contradict earlier certified representations made to the LTSA and Minister of Finance."
Accordingly, Wilkinson dismissed Yan Qiao's application.
With files from CTV News Vancouver's Andrew Weichel
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'A step forward': New screening criteria for sperm donors takes effect
Canadians looking to grow their families with the assistance of sperm or egg donations should soon have more options for donors as the federal health agency does away with longstanding restrictions criticized as discriminatory.
What is whooping cough and should Canadians be concerned as Europe declares outbreak?
There is currently a whooping cough epidemic in Europe, with 10 times as many cases compared to the previous two years. While an outbreak has not been declared nationwide in Canada, whooping cough is regularly detected in the country.
Ontario Provincial Police arrest 64 suspects in child sexual exploitation investigation
Ontario Provincial Police say 64 suspects are facing a combined 348 charges in connection with a series of child sexual exploitation investigations that spanned the province.
Ippei Mizuhara, ex-interpreter for baseball star Shohei Ohtani, pleads guilty in sports betting case
The former interpreter for Los Angeles Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani pleaded guilty to bank and tax fraud Wednesday in a sports betting case where prosecutors allege he stole US$16 million from the Japanese baseball player to pay off debts.
Steve Albini, legendary producer for Nirvana, the Pixies and an alternative rock pioneer, dies at 61
Steve Albini, an alternative rock pioneer and legendary producer who shaped the musical landscape through his work with Nirvana, the Pixies, PJ Harvey and more, has died. He was 61.
Pfizer agrees to settle more than 10K lawsuits over Zantac cancer risk: Bloomberg News
Pfizer has agreed to settle more than 10,000 lawsuits about cancer risks related to the now discontinued heartburn drug Zantac, Bloomberg News reported on Wednesday, citing people familiar with the deal.
U.S. presidential candidate RFK Jr. had a brain worm, has recovered, campaign says
Independent U.S. presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. had a parasite in his head more than a decade ago, but has fully recovered, his campaign said, after the New York Times reported about the ailment.
Watch fighter jet pilots pummel fake enemy ship off coast of Philippines
The United States and Philippines held annual joint-training drills just off the Southeast Asian nation’s western coast on Wednesday. Military forces sunk a 'mock' enemy warship – the BRP Lake Caliraya, which was a decommissioned tanker made in China.
'Summer of discontent': Federal unions vow to fight new 3-day a week office mandate
Federal unions are launching legal challenges and encouraging public sector workers to file "tens of thousands" of grievances over the new mandate requiring federal workers to return to the office at least three days a week in the fall.