Air Canada must pay spouses more than $500 each for cancelled flight, B.C. tribunal rules
![Air Canada planes in storage at YVR. Air Canada planes are shown here in storage at Vancouver International Airport during the pandemic.](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2020/5/21/air-canada-planes-in-storage-at-yvr--1-4949528-1649291253874.jpg)
B.C.'s small claims tribunal has awarded more than $1,000 to a couple whose arrival in Vancouver was delayed by more than four hours due to a cancelled flight from Montreal.
In two separate decisions published online Monday, Civil Resolution Tribunal vice chair Kate Campbell found in favour of Michael Zimmerman and James Sullivan in their bids to claim compensation from Air Canada under federal Air Passenger Protection Regulations (APPR).
The spouses were travelling from Fredricton, N.B., to Vancouver, and their journey was rerouted through Kelowna after a flight from Montreal to Vancouver was cancelled.
They arrived in Vancouver a little more than four hours after their scheduled arrival, a delay that large airlines must provide compensation for under the APPR if the delay "is within the carrier's control and not required for safety purposes," according to Campbell's decisions.
Air Canada told the tribunal the cancelled flight was required for safety reasons, noting that the plane that was scheduled to make the flight needed unscheduled repairs to fix an "engine delamination fault," and could not fly safely.
The airline claimed no alternative plane was available to make the trip.
The onus was on Zimmerman and Sullivan, as the parties bringing the complaints to the CRT, to prove their cases on the balance of probabilities. However, Campbell cited – and adopted the reasoning of – previous CRT and Canadian Transportation Agency decisions that found airlines arguing a delay was outside their control bear the burden of proving this assertion.
In this case, Campbell found Air Canada's evidence unpersuasive.
"The statement from Air Canada employee GW says the flight was not cancelled until after employees had unsuccessfully tried to find another Airbus A330 aircraft," Campbell's decision in Zimmerman's case reads.
"However, as Mr. Zimmerman argues, Air Canada has not explained why it only considered replacing (the plane) with another Airbus A330. GW’s statement says 'no other viable alternative could have been carried out to render the applicant to his final destination on time.' However, I find Air Canada has not proved this assertion."
The tribunal member noted that Air Canada has a large fleet and the cancelled flight was to be operated out of a major airport in Canada's second-largest city, factors that have been found in previous APPR cases to increase the expectation that an airline will be able to find a replacement plane.
Campbell further observed that there were other Airbus A330 planes – one in Montreal and one in Toronto – that were listed as "out of service" in records provided by Air Canada.
"Air Canada has not explained why these aircraft were out of service, and why they could not have been used to replace (the plane)," the Zimmerman decision reads.
"I find that Air Canada’s mere assertion that the aircraft were out of service is not enough to meet its burden of proving that the cancellation was unavoidable."
In the two separate decisions, Campbell awarded each spouse $546.38, representing the $400 compensation the travellers were entitled to under the APPR, plus $21.38 in pre-judgment interest and $125 in CRT fees.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7033216.1726021317!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Kamala Harris goes on offence against Donald Trump in combative debate
Democratic U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris put Republican Donald Trump on the defensive at a combative U.S. presidential debate on Tuesday with a stream of attacks on abortion limits, his fitness for office and his myriad legal woes.
Key quotes from the Trump-Harris 2024 U.S. presidential debate
U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris and former U.S. president Donald Trump took the stage on Tuesday night for their first and only scheduled presidential debate before the Nov. 5 election.
Trump campaign falsely accuses immigrants in Ohio of abducting and eating pets
Former U.S. president Donald Trump’s campaign and his allies are amplifying false rumours that Haitian immigrants in Ohio were abducting and eating pets, another instance of the inflammatory and anti-immigrant rhetoric Trump has promoted throughout his campaigns.
U.S. presidential historian predicts results of November elections. Here's who he says will win
An American presidential historian is predicting a Kamala Harris presidency as the outcome of the upcoming U.S. elections in November.
Some restaurants have increased their default tip options. Canadians think you should give this much
Despite what the default options on the payment terminal might read, most Canadians still want to tip around 15 per cent, according to a new survey.
Dave Grohl says he fathered a child outside of his marriage
The Foo Fighters frontman announced that he recently became a father again, writing in a statement on his Instagram page on Tuesday that his new baby girl was born 'outside' of his marriage to his wife Jordyn Blum.
$2M home belonging to children's musician Raffi on the market
Canada’s children’s troubadour is selling his B.C. home, which is now up for grabs for $1,995,000.
Sinaloa shootouts sparks fear of intra-cartel war in Mexico
Shootouts in the western Mexican state of Sinaloa have kindled fears that an intra-cartel war is about to break out in the wake of the arrest of legendary trafficker, Ismael 'El Mayo' Zambada, in July.
PwC plans to track employees' location while at work. Is this practice legal in Canada?
As PricewaterhouseCoopers plans to enforce its back-to-office policy by tracking employees in the U.K., one employment lawyer explains whether the practice is legal in Canada.