Toxicity and tight race fuel B.C. election integrity doubters, says professor
A British Columbia political scientist says social media questioning of the provincial election's integrity is an "inevitable" result of political "toxicity" and a tight race.
University of British Columbia professor emeritus Richard Johnston says questions about mail-in votes and the handling of ballots also reflect circumstances south of the border.
He said other factors include use of more complicated voting apparatus and social media platforms where anyone can publish doubts.
"There is a relationship between the closeness of results and the toxicity of the commentary around it," Johnston said.
"I mean, we're describing almost exactly the situation in the U.S., right? Basically a 50/50 result, so close that each side might have suspicions about the other."
The British Columbia election came down to absentee ballots on Monday, after neither Premier David Eby's NDP nor the B.C. Conservatives, led by John Rustad, secured a majority.
After a count of mail-in votes over the weekend saw prospects for an NDP victory increase, online posts questioned the number of mail-in and absentee votes, the ballots' origins, the wait between the initial and final counts, and how the votes were handled during that time.
In a written response, Elections BC spokesman Andrew Watson said the voting authority has "observed misinformation about the electoral process online" and it urged voters to go to its website to get accurate information.
"Initial count takes place on election night," Watson said. "Final count takes place one week later and lasts three days. This timing is established under the Election Act and has long been the process in B.C.
"At the end of each day of advance voting, cast ballots are secured in a ballot box that is sealed and signed by election officials and scrutineers," he said. "All election officials swear an oath of office to administer the provisions of the Election Act faithfully."
Watson said any election official convicted of an offence may face a fine up to $10,000 and a prison term of up to a year.
B.C. Conservatives president Aisha Estey said in a post on social media platform X on Sunday that she "spent the last two days in a warehouse watching the transcription and counting of mail-in ballots," and saw nothing problematic.
"Elections BC staff have been working tirelessly and doing their best within the confines of the legislation that governs their work," Estey said in her post.
"Would we have liked mail-ins to be counted closer to E-Day? Sure. But I saw nothing that caused me concern."
Premier and B.C. New Democrat Leader David Eby also took to X on Sunday to express support for Elections BC staff "making sure every vote gets counted."
Johnston said Elections BC's efforts to make voting more accessible and counting more efficient had actually been feeding integrity doubts.
He said increased use of advance voting, mail-in and absentee ballots, as well as digital vote tabulation, were being compared unfavourably by some with more basic voting and hand-counting systems used in the past.
"Basically, the whole voting process was simpler," Johnston said. "You had to turn up on election day. You had to have a reason for voting in advance polls … and you really had to basically make a declaration that you were going to have either a surgical procedure or you could not avoid being out of the constituency on election day.
"The count may take a long time on election day if it's a particularly close riding," he said. "But … there's a sense in which all the players who were on the ballot were in a position that was easily interpretable as verifying the facts. Everybody had an interest in defending its side, and the result would be in a sense accurate and fair."
Dominion Voting Systems, which manufactured the electronic tabulators used in the B.C. election, referred questions to its website page dedicated to misinformation about the company and its technology. It addresses concerns about misinformation that emerged after the U.S. presidential election in 2020.
Fox News agreed last year to pay Dominion nearly US$800 million to avert a trial in the company’s lawsuit that would have exposed how the network promoted lies about the election.
"All Dominion systems are based on voter-verifiable paper ballots or paper records for auditing," the company said on its web page. "Dominion systems comply with all requirements for system updates and election records retention."
Johnston also said the very idea of making voting more accessible could create a "background for paranoia," as doubters questioned the nature and origins of people who would not otherwise have been able to vote.
"Historically, paranoia about the conduct of elections has hardly been peculiar to the right wing of the political landscape," he said. "It's also been a feature on the left. It kind of depends on who wins and who loses.
"If you were to go back 20 years and look forward, I think a lot on the left would be shocked that it would be people on the left who are defending the integrity of the establishment, so to speak."
One major difference with discourse in the United States, Johnston said, was that B.C. party leaders, such as Estey, had so far not engaged in "delegitimization tactics."
Whether that changes would be something to watch for, he said.
"It'll be interesting to see whether there's blowback from the fringes of the Conservative Party against the party's own leadership," he said.
He added, "Let's see whether there are any dynamics inside the Conservative Party over the next few days that makes John Rustad worried that perhaps the party president's acceptance of the process was premature from a political point of view."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 28, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING B.C. NDP poised to win 2024 election, with judicial recounts increasingly likely
Incumbent B.C. Premier David Eby’s NDP appears poised to win the province’s nail-biting 2024 election – and could potentially retain the party’s majority, by the narrowest of margins.
'We promise to be better': N.S. firefighter club criticized after group in KKK costumes attends Halloween dance
A group of Cape Breton firefighters are apologizing after four people showed up at a Halloween dance dressed in what appeared to be Ku Klux Klan costumes.
'Nobody wants to blow up the party': Trudeau staying, despite resignation calls
Several Liberal MPs are calling for a secret ballot vote on Justin Trudeau's leadership after he made clear he isn't going anywhere in spite of the calls from within his caucus to step down.
Previously unseen photos of Prince William with his mother Diana visiting homeless charity released
Prince William has opened up about how a powerful childhood experience with his brother and late mother helped shape his work in combatting homelessness.
Next CPP payment coming on Tuesday for Canadian retirees
Here's how retirees will get their funds from the federal benefit.
Ont. couple accused of human trafficking plead not guilty as complainant testifies
Marred by several delays, the trial of alleged human traffickers Lauriston and Amber Maloney finally got underway on Monday in a Bradford courtroom, with a woman who worked and lived with the couple testifying.
Google exempt from Online News Act for 5 years, must pay news outlets $100M: CRTC
The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission has granted Google a five-year exemption from the Online News Act, ordering it to pay $100 million to Canadian news outlets within 60 days.
'Pieces of wood': Gummy candies recalled, Canadian Food Inspection Agency says
A recall has been issued for gummy candies due to pieces of wood, according to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency.
'Bob's Burgers' actor sentenced to 1 year in prison for role in Capitol riot
An actor known for his roles in the television comedies “Bob's Burgers” and “Arrested Development” was sentenced on Monday to one year in prison for his part in a mob's attack on the U.S. Capitol nearly four years ago.