'Sleeping with the enemy': Mistrial in B.C. sex assault case over Crown dating paralegal
Scales of justice. (Shutterstock)
The B.C. Supreme Court has ordered a new trial for a man convicted of sexual assault after he learned his defence lawyer's paralegal was dating the Crown prosecutor during his trial.
Justice Veronica Jackson ruled last week in Courtenay, B.C., that Cameron Gagne should get a new trial because his lawyer, Eric Chesterley, and prosecutor Nicholas Grabe failed to tell the court about the relationship.
Gagne was found guilty of sexual assault by a jury in November 2023, and the judge's ruling said that at a hearing last March, Chesterley disclosed that he knew his paralegal had been dating the prosecutor, telling the court the relationship was not "entirely unknown" to him.
The ruling said Gagne was shocked to learn of the "romantic relationship" between the prosecutor and his lawyer's paralegal, who assisted Chesterley throughout the trial that began in October 2023.
Neither Gagne's current nor former lawyer responded to a request for comment.
In an emailed statement, the BC Prosecution Service said it is "reviewing the decision and will have no further comment" while the case is still before the court.
The service's statement said the next scheduled court date in the case is Dec. 16.
Jackson's decision said Gagne applied for a mistrial, claiming his trial was unfair due to a "miscarriage of justice" because neither his lawyer nor the prosecutor told him about the relationship.
The judge ordered a new trial for the man, finding the relationship was "concealed" from Gagne and not disclosed to the court, which she found to be "egregious" conduct that created "an appearance of unfairness."
"A reasonable and objective observer would consider it a betrayal and a fundamental breach of trial fairness for an accused to learn only after he has been convicted at trial that a member of his defence team had been, at least metaphorically, sleeping with the enemy, by being involved in a personal relationship with the Crown, a relationship known to both counsel, but concealed from him," Jackson's ruling concludes.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 3, 2024
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Mark Carney reaches out to dozens of Liberal MPs ahead of potential leadership campaign
Mark Carney, the former Bank of Canada and Bank of England governor, is actively considering running in a potential Liberal party leadership race should Justin Trudeau resign, sources tell CTV News.
Here’s why you should monitor your blood pressure, keep it in check
An Ottawa pharmacist says blood pressure is a good indicator of overall health, noting the importance of keeping it at healthy rates.
WATCH
WATCH Woman critically injured in explosive Ottawa crash caught on camera
Dashcam footage sent to CTV News shows a vehicle travelling at a high rate of speed in the wrong direction before striking and damaging a hydro pole.
Big Dreams for ‘The Littlest Hobo’: Fans push for star on Canada’s Walk of Fame
When Terry Bush co-wrote and sang Maybe Tomorrow, the theme song for The Littlest Hobo, he thought it was just another gig—a catchy tune for a TV show about a wandering German Shepherd. Forty-five years later, that 'little tune' still tugs at heartstrings, pops up on playlists, and has even been known to be played at closing time in English pubs.
Britain wants to get close to Trump. Will Elon Musk stand in the way?
It was not the start to 2025 that Keir Starmer wanted or expected: in the early hours of New Year’s Day, Elon Musk lobbed a series of angry posts and allegations towards the British prime minister, engulfing his government in a very public fight.
TikTok creators left in limbo while awaiting decision on potential platform ban
At the heart of the case is whether the law violates the First Amendment with TikTok and its creator allies arguing that it does.
Here’s the latest on this weekend's winter storms in Canada
From snow, to high winds, to extreme cold, much of Canada is under a severe weather alert this weekend. Here's what to expect in your region.
This Canadian couple has been to 195 countries. Here's what they learned on their eight-year journey
Masha and Robert Glanville, a Canadian couple, sold everything they owned to travel the world full-time. With over 195 countries visited, they focus on mindful, eco-friendly travel and giving back. Here’s what they had to say about their global journey.
Peel police investigate possible connections between gunshot injury, luxury vehicle carjacking
Police are investigating possible connections between a gunshot injury and an attempted carjacking in Mississauga.
Vancouver Island
-
Driver dead after collision with construction vehicle in Saanich, B.C.
A driver is dead after colliding with a construction vehicle in Saanich Friday night.
-
B.C. man ordered to pay damages for smashing Smart car window during road rage incident
A man who smashed the window of a woman’s Smart car during a road rage incident with a former co-worker has been ordered to pay $1,245 in damages by the B.C. Civil Resolution Tribunal.
-
WestJet denies compensation to Taylor Swift fan after flight cancellation
WestJet has denied compensation to a devout Taylor Swift fan whose cancelled flight triggered a 10-hour drive through the night from Prince George to make the singer's shows in Vancouver last month.
Kelowna
-
Lost skiers rescued off B.C. mountain
Search and rescue volunteers in B.C.’s Okanagan successfully reunited two skiers with their family Friday evening.
-
Charges laid after child porn investigation that 'spanned several different countries,' Kelowna RCMP say
Police in Kelowna say an international investigation has led to child pornography charges against a 46-year-old man.
-
Mounties investigate discovery of 'very small pipe bomb' in Kamloops, B.C.
Mounties are investigating and appealing for witnesses after an explosive device was discovered Wednesday on a beach in Kamloops, B.C.
Edmonton
-
Oilers pounce on Kraken early en route to 4-2 win
Vasily Podkolzin and Jeff Skinner scored in the first 5 1/2 minutes and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Seattle Kraken 4-2 on Saturday night for their third straight victory.
-
'Flames were shooting higher than the garage': Block heater cords cause 2 fires in 2 days in Edmonton
Peter Claffey was shocked Thursday morning to find his truck in flames outside his southwest Edmonton home.
-
Health care dominated Alberta lobbying registry in 2024
Health care dominated the lobbying agendas of Alberta’s influencers this year after the provincial government promised to dismantle and decentralize the public health system.
Calgary
-
Kuzmenko's costly penalties overshadow return to Flames' lineup
Andrei Kuzmenko's troubles continued on Saturday as he went from the press box to the penalty box.
-
Community grieves as one at vigil for Calgary double homicide victims
They braved the cold to pay tribute to a Calgary mother of three and her father, killed just days after Christmas.
-
Oilers pounce on Kraken early en route to 4-2 win
Vasily Podkolzin and Jeff Skinner scored in the first 5 1/2 minutes and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Seattle Kraken 4-2 on Saturday night for their third straight victory.
Lethbridge
-
Family of hospitalized Lethbridge man in Thailand reach out for support
The family of a Lethbridge man is reaching out to the public for help after he suffered a series of medical emergencies while travelling in Thailand.
-
Checkstop Campaign ends in Lethbridge with 10 impaired drivers removed from the road: police
The Lethbridge Police service concluded its annual Checkstop Campaign over the holiday season, resulting in the removal of 10 impaired drivers from the road.
-
Threat made to Lethbridge casino deemed to be a ‘swatting’ hoax: police
Investigators with Lethbridge police determined that a threat made to a local casino Thursday night was deemed to be a ‘swatting’ hoax.
Winnipeg
-
'A really powerful day': Commemorating National Ribbon Skirt Day in Winnipeg
Dozens donned colourful fabrics and patterns Saturday in honour of the third-annual National Ribbon Skirt Day celebrated across the country.
-
Vacant apartment building demolished after third fire in 2 years
A vacant three-storey apartment building on Mountain Avenue has been demolished after its third fire since 2023.
-
Manitoba's top baby names for 2024
Manitoba’s top baby names remained mostly unchanged for 2024, though some new contenders made their way into the top 10.
Regina
-
Family of man shot by Hamilton police hold vigil and rally in Regina
The family and community of a man shot by police in Hamilton in November continue to seek answers surrounding the circumstances of his death.
-
Regina woman turns to social media to find donor match for kidney transplant
A Regina woman currently waiting for a kidney transplant is now seeking a donor through a social media post.
-
Here’s the latest on this weekend's winter storms in Canada
From snow, to high winds, to extreme cold, much of Canada is under a severe weather alert this weekend. Here's what to expect in your region.
Saskatoon
-
$20k of equipment stolen from rural Sask. Fire hall. And it's not the only one
Rural firehalls surrounding Saskatoon are having to deal with escalating thefts that could put rescue efforts in jeopardy.
-
Two people charged with murder after suspicious death on Sask. First Nation
A man and a woman have been charged with first degree murder after a 24-year-old man died of injuries on Saulteaux First Nation.
-
Extreme cold warning remains in effect for parts of Saskatchewan
The frigid weather continues to grip Saskatoon and parts of Saskatchewan as the extreme cold warnings are in effect across the prairies.
Toronto
-
Up to 15 more centimetres of snowfall in parts of Ontario before snow squalls set to end
An additional five to 15 centimetres of snow is expected to fall in parts of southern Ontario before snow squall warnings end on Sunday, according to Environment Canada.
-
Police search for suspects after jewelry store robbery at Burlington mall
Police are searching for multiple suspects following a smash-and-grab robbery at a mall jewelry store in Burlington Saturday afternoon.
-
Peel police investigate possible connections between gunshot injury, luxury vehicle carjacking
Police are investigating possible connections between a gunshot injury and an attempted carjacking in Mississauga.
Montreal
-
A year after his son overdosed, a Montreal father feels more prevention work is needed
New data shows opioid-related deaths and hospitalizations are down in Canada, but provincial data paints a different picture. In Quebec, drug related deaths jumped 30 per cent in the first half of 2024, according to the public health institute (INSPQ).
-
Montreal arson squad investigating second fire in building that was set ablaze under a year ago
The Montreal police’s (SPVM) arson squad is investigating after a vacant commercial space was fire bombed on Saturday night. The same building was set on fire in May.
-
Bus crashes near Quebec border: several people injured
Poor weather and road conditions could be to blame for the bus crash in Saint-Armand, Que. on Saturday evening near the Canada/United States border in the Montérégie region.
Ottawa
-
Here’s why you should monitor your blood pressure, keep it in check
An Ottawa pharmacist says blood pressure is a good indicator of overall health, noting the importance of keeping it at healthy rates.
-
Pedestrian killed in South Frontenac collision, driver facing 'administrative' licence suspension
Ontario Provincial Police say the van driver involved in the collision that killed a teenager and injured another pedestrian in a rural area north of Kingston on Saturday afternoon is facing "an administrative driver's licence suspension, for a three-day period."
-
WATCH
WATCH Woman critically injured in explosive Ottawa crash caught on camera
Dashcam footage sent to CTV News shows a vehicle travelling at a high rate of speed in the wrong direction before striking and damaging a hydro pole.
Atlantic
-
Second aircraft emergency in a week at Halifax Stanfield International Airport
An aircraft inbound for Halifax reported cabin pressure issues and triggered an emergency response.
-
RCMP in New Brusnwick ask for public's help to find wanted man
RCMP in New Brunswick is asking the public for assistance finding a man wanted by police.
-
Here’s the latest on this weekend's winter storms in Canada
From snow, to high winds, to extreme cold, much of Canada is under a severe weather alert this weekend. Here's what to expect in your region.
London
-
Homicide investigation underway in Durham
The West Grey Police Service is investigating a stabbing that took place in Durham.
-
MP Peter Fragiskatos calls on Trudeau to resign
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has lost the confidence of another prominent Liberal MP.
-
Poor weather postpones OHL Games in Owen Sound and Barrie
Inclement weather and travel conditions have forced the postponement of two games in the Ontario Hockey League Saturday.
Kitchener
-
Kitchener arrested after police said he approached bylaw officers with a knife
A Kitchener man has been arrested after Waterloo Regional Police Service said he threatened bylaw officers while holding a knife.
-
Vacancy rate in Kitchener-Cambridge-Waterloo hits highest level since 1993: report
Vacancy rates in Waterloo Region are growing, but low-income earners may still have trouble finding a place to live.
-
Three school board trustees call for town hall following director of education's departure
Three Waterloo Region District School Board trustees are joining the call for a town hall after a sudden shake up within the board.
Northern Ontario
-
Suspect charged in northern Ont. road rage incident that went viral
A 37-year-old suspect has been charged in connection with a road rage incident last week in Temiskaming Shores.
-
Mark Carney reaches out to dozens of Liberal MPs ahead of potential leadership campaign
Mark Carney, the former Bank of Canada and Bank of England governor, is actively considering running in a potential Liberal party leadership race should Justin Trudeau resign, sources tell CTV News.
-
MNR renews call for help with investigation of abandoned cow moose killed in northern Ont.
Conservation officers with the Ministry of Nature Resources are again asking for the public’s help with identifying those responsible for killing a cow moose near Chapleau, Ont.
N.L.
-
Newfoundland residents seek answers, assurance as Quebec energy deal heads for debate
About 50 people gathered in a St. John's, N.L., gymnasium on a recent rainy night to seek answers about a massive energy deal with Hydro-Quebec trumpeted by the Newfoundland and Labrador government as a new chapter in the province's history.
-
Labradorians pay thousands to fly to Newfoundland. Could a Quebec energy deal help?
An airport executive in Labrador hopes a new energy deal with Quebec could help attract a competing airline company to the northern region, where flights costs have climbed at more than three times the national rate.
-
Icebreaker on hand in Labrador to guide season's last freight arrivals by ferry
A Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker is in central Labrador until Saturday to guide the Kamutik W ferry on its last freight deliveries of the season.
