Neighbour on the hook for $3,675 in damages due to 'nuisance cedar': B.C. tribunal
![Cedar tree A large cedar tree is seen in this undated stock image. (Credit: Shutterstock)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/6/30/cedar-tree-1-6946944-1719771876649.jpg)
A B.C. man who reneged on a deal to split the cost of removing a tree with his next-door neighbour is now on the hook for the whole amount, B.C.’s civil resolution has ruled.
Adam Smith was awarded $3,675 in compensation from his neighbour, Graham Smith as damages for “unjust enrichment,” the decision posted online last week says.
There was no dispute that the tree itself was on one side of the property line – but its roots breached the boundary.
“The roots of a large cedar tree located on the respondent’s property crossed the property line onto the applicant’s property and began growing into the applicant’s home. The tree roots started to buckle the applicant’s basement floor, among other things,” tribunal vice-chair Andrea Ritchie wrote.
The neighbours initially agreed to split the cost of the tree removal but the day before it was scheduled to take place, Graham Smith told his neighbour he would only pay 25 per cent. Ultimately, he paid nothing at all.
The first issue the tribunal had to decide was whether or not the tree was more likely than not to have caused the damage to Adam Smith’s property. The evidence considered included recordings of phone calls where Graham Smith agreed to pay some portion of the removal cost and admitted the tree caused the damage.
“I find the tree was a danger to the applicant’s property,” Ritchie wrote, adding that the tree caused “unreasonable interference” for the neighbour, meaning it met the test of being a nuisance and that it was Graham Smith’s responsibility to deal with it.
“I find the respondent failed to adequately deal with the nuisance cedar, despite consistently acknowledging it was a nuisance and causing damage,” Ritchie’s decision continued.
The tribunal found that Adam Smith’s decision to proceed with the tree’s removal even after his neighbour backed out of the agreement to share the cost was reasonable in the circumstances.
Ritchie explained why the law of unjust enrichment applied in this case.
“I find the respondent was enriched because they had a nuisance tree on their property removed at no expense to them. The applicant undisputedly paid to have the tree removed, which resulted in an economic loss. I also find there was no valid basis for the respondent’s enrichment,” she wrote, while also rejecting Graham Smith’s argument that he should only have to pay the 50 per cent he initially agreed to.
“I find the applicant is not bound by his earlier offer to share the expense equally because the respondent rejected that offer,” Ritchie wrote.
After adding tribunal fees and pre-judgment interest, Graham Smith was ordered to pay his neighbour a total of $4,035.77
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6929776.1718638522!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
DEVELOPING At least 60 are dead and scores are injured after a stampede at a religious event in northern India
At least 60 people were dead and scores were injured after a stampede at a religious gathering of thousands of people in northern India, officials said Tuesday.
Did WestJet cancel your flight? Here's what experts say you should do
WestJet cancelled more than 800 flights between June 27 and July 2, affecting tens of thousands of passengers. Here are the kinds of compensation experts say passengers affected by the cancellations may be entitled to, and how to go about advocating for it.
What a family lawyer says you should know before getting married
Barry Nussbaum, a Toronto-based family lawyer who has counselled countless couples, offers advice about the details you don't want to overlook before getting married.
Hurricane Beryl rips through open waters after devastating the southeast Caribbean
Hurricane Beryl roared through open waters on Tuesday as a monstrous Category 5 storm on a path that would take it near Jamaica and the Cayman Islands after earlier making landfall in the southeast Caribbean, killing at least two people.
This 12-year-old memorized the periodic table at age two. He's heading to NYU after finishing high school in just two years
Recent high school graduate Suborno Isaac Bari, 12, plans to start studying math and physics at New York University in the fall, but he’s already got his ambitious sights set on beginning a doctoral program.
Scientists wary of bird flu pandemic 'unfolding in slow motion'
Scientists tracking the spread of bird flu are increasingly concerned that gaps in surveillance may keep them several steps behind a new pandemic, according to Reuters interviews with more than a dozen leading disease experts.
Five years after historic tobacco ruling, 'nothing has changed'
Five years after a historic ruling against three major tobacco companies, no one has seen even a fraction of the money they're entitled to – and recent court filings suggest hundreds have died in the interim.
'I would call this the silent eating disorder': What experts want you to know about ARFID
Unlike eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia nervosa, Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder, or ARFID, isn’t concerned with body shape or size. People with ARFID are very limited in the foods they feel safe and comfortable eating
Biden and the Democrats raise US$264 million in 2nd quarter as they seek to calm post-debate anxieties
President Joe Biden 's reelection campaign and the Democratic National Committee reported raising US$264 million in the year's second quarter, an impressive haul that may help them calm fears within their own party about last week's shaky debate performance.