Inflatable hot tub can stay on Vancouver condo balcony, judge rules
Two Vancouver condo owners will be able to keep an inflatable hot tub on their balcony after a judge found that the item constituted patio furniture and was allowed under the strata's bylaws.
Justice Michael Tammen ruled on the case in B.C. Supreme Court last month after the strata filed for a review of an earlier decision by the province's Civil Resolution Tribunal.
According to the decision, the owners live on the 26th floor of a tower in downtown Vancouver and set up the inflatable hot tub in September of 2021 after the strata rejected their request to do so.
"After the strata council learned of the placement of the hot tub on the patio, it initiated bylaw enforcement processes pursuant to its bylaws and the Strata Property Act," Tammen wrote in his ruling.
John Emmerton and Van Ortega took the dispute to the tribunal in December of that year and a decision was handed down in August of 2022.
"I have found the applicants’ inflatable hot tub is patio furniture, I find the bylaws expressly permit the applicants to have the hot tub on the patio. In the absence of a bylaw contravention, I find the strata has no authority to require the applicants to remove the hot tub from the patio," Tribunal Member Kristin Gardner wrote in that decision.
Key to the determination that the inflatable hot tub was patio furniture was the fact that it was easily movable and could be quickly and easily drained and deflated.
The strata asked for that decision to be reviewed by a judge, arguing that it was "patently unreasonable" and should be reversed, the court decision says.
The strata said that the tribunal had made a mistake when interpreting the by-law allowing patio furniture also allowed the hot tub, saying that interpretation was inconsistent with "the plain and ordinary meaning of the term" and also that it was not explicitly mentioned on a list of permissible items alongside barbecues and flower pots.
The new evidence the strata sought to introduce in support of its case and its claim that the hot tub was not patio furniture was rejected by the court as inadmissible, "wholly irrelevant" and "of extremely marginal relevance." Even if it had been admitted, Tammen said it would not have changed the original decision, which he upheld.
"I cannot say that the central reasoning and analysis, nor the ultimate conclusion, is patently unreasonable. The tribunal member’s conclusion certainly does not border on the absurd," he wrote.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
B.C. serial killer Robert Pickton dead following prison attack
Convicted B.C. serial killer Robert Pickton, who preyed on women he lured from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside to his rural pig farm, has died.
'We will go with the majority': Liberals slammed by opposition over proposal to delay next election
The federal Liberal government learned Friday it might have to retreat on a proposal within its electoral reform legislation to delay the next vote by one week, after all opposition parties came out to say they can't support it.
Ex-husband charged with murder in death of Lumby, B.C., woman
The ex-husband of Tatjana Stefanski – the woman whose disappearance and death set the small town of Lumby, B.C., on edge last month – has been charged with her murder.
Oilers beat Stars, one win away from Stanley Cup berth
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins scored two power-play goals as Edmonton smothered the Dallas Stars 3-1 to take a 3-2 lead in the NHL's Western Conference final on Friday.
Baby dead after being delivered via emergency C-section to woman who was in police custody
A newborn is dead after being delivered via emergency C-section to a woman in police custody.
Jennifer Lopez cancels summer tour: 'I am completely heartsick and devastated'
Jennifer Lopez has cancelled her 2024 North American tour, representatives for Live Nation confirmed to The Associated Press.
This Calgary home has a giant tree in the middle, and it's for sale
There's a luxury 'tree home' for sale in Calgary.
DND moving 1,000 employees out of Ottawa office building due to safety concerns
The Department of National Defence is moving approximately 1,000 employees out of an office building in Ottawa's Lowertown neighbourhood, citing safety concerns for its employees.
Man convicted of killing Toronto cop in 1980 granted day parole
A man convicted of murdering a Toronto police officer more than four decades ago has been granted day parole for six months.