B.C. woman sues multi-level marketing company over 'unsafe' weight loss products
A B.C. woman has filed a lawsuit alleging weight loss products sold by a multi-level marketing company left her with chronic pain, an abnormal heart rhythm and other ill effects.
Kelowna resident Chera Harris's claim centres around more than a dozen meal replacement bars and shakes sold under Isagenix International's IsaLean line, all of which were subject to Health Canada recalls beginning in October 2020 due to "over-fortification of vitamins."
Prior to those recalls, Harris was involved in Isagenix's multi-level marketing operation for years, purchasing products and reselling them for a commission.
She also used IsaLean meal replacements personally, according to her lawsuit, which caused her to experience "a significant decrease in her overall health as a result of a chronic overdose of vitamins and minerals."
On top of the physical ailments listed in her claim, Harris said she suffered anxiety, depression and sleeplessness.
One Health Canada recall for 24 Isagenix products dated November 2020 cites "reported illnesses" associated with the items, but does not provide any further details. Harris’s lawsuit also acknowledges the company has re-released the products since the recalls with “safe levels of vitamins and minerals.”
Her claim accuses the defendants – Isagenix International LLC and Isagenix Canada ULC – of negligence in the design, manufacturing, distribution and marketing of the meal replacements.
"Resellers and consumers are entirely reliant on the defendants to ensure the quality of the defendants' products," the claim reads.
"The extent of the unsafe levels of vitamins and minerals in the products was not known and could not have been known by the plaintiff."
Isagenix has not filed a statement of defence in the case, but asked B.C. Supreme Court for a stay of proceedings, arguing that Harris's contract as a reseller requires any claims to be "settled by confidential arbitration" in Arizona, where the company is headquartered.
Justice Ward Branch refused, in a Feb. 18 decision that has been posted online, finding that Harris was free to advance her lawsuit as a consumer.
"A person may obviously be a supplier in one consumer transaction, but not in another," Branch wrote. "The plaintiff purchased the products for her own personal use, thus bringing her within the ambit of a 'consumer' under the (Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act)."
Harris is seeking unspecified damages, including for pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of her life.
In a statement to CTV News, Isagenix said it does not believe Harris's "recent alleged health challenges are the result of consuming Isagenix products."
"We believe the lawsuit is frivolous and intend to fully defend against it. Our legal team is currently reviewing the allegations and preparing an appropriate response," the company continued.
Isagenix said it conducts thousands of product tests every year and "stand(s) firmly behind" the safety and effectiveness of its products.
"In a simple procedural matter, a Canadian judge recently ruled that Ms. Harris will not be required to arbitrate her claims in the United States," the company said. "The ruling is common in the early stages of any litigation and has no bearing on the merits of the case."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Ontario's 'crypto king' Aiden Pleterski arrested
Aiden Pleterski, the self-proclaimed 'crypto king' from Whitby, Ont., was arrested in Durham Region after allegedly running a Ponzi scheme worth more than $40 million.
BREAKING Slovakian prime minister in life-threatening condition after being shot, his Facebook profile says
Slovakia's populist Prime Minister Robert Fico is in life-threatening condition after being wounded in a shooting after a political event Wednesday afternoon, according to his Facebook profile.
BREAKING Quebec court rejects McGill injunction request to remove encampment
A Quebec judge rejected McGill University's request for an injunction to remove the pro-Palestinian encampment on the university's campus in downtown Montreal.
Ottawa to acquire Quebec Bridge from CN, will spend $1 billion on span over 25 years
The federal government says it has reached a deal with Canadian National Railway Company to acquire the historic Quebec Bridge.
'Not a scarient': New COVID-19 subvariant dominant in Canada
A new COVID-19 subvariant is dominant in Canada, representing just over 30 per cent of cases in the country, but infectious disease experts say there’s no sign it’ll evolve into a summer 'scarient.'
WATCH Wildfires: Here's who's most at risk when the air quality drops
Wildfires continue to impact air quality across Western Canada with health experts and Environment Canada warning that the smoke from the blazes poses serious risks to human health.
Stormy Daniels' husband says they'll likely leave country if Trump is acquitted
The husband of adult film actress Stormy Daniels said on Tuesday that there’s a 'good chance' the couple will leave the country if former U.S. president Donald Trump is acquitted in his Manhattan criminal trial.
DEVELOPING Massive manhunt in France for prison-break gang that gunned down officers
A massive manhunt was underway in France on Wednesday for armed assailants who ambushed a prison convoy, killing two prison officers, seriously injuring three others and springing the inmate they were escorting. The prime minister vowed the gang would be caught, saying, "They will pay."
Home sales in April up 10% compared with year ago, but monthly sales slow
The Canadian Real Estate Association says the number of home sales in April rose 10.1 per cent compared with a year ago, but attributed the gain primarily to the early Easter long weekend.