B.C.'s highest court hands down decision in inflatable hot tub dispute
British Columbia's highest court has weighed in on a dispute over an inflatable hot tub a couple set up on their condo's patio – potentially bringing a close to the years-long conflict.
The B.C. Court of Appeal decision was handed down last week. The three-judge panel reconsidered the question answered by the Civil Resolution Tribunal and the lower court.
Specifically, whether the hot tub was "patio furniture" and therefore allowed under the condo building's bylaws.
In B.C. the common assets of a condo building are owned by a strata corporation and managed by a strata council.
John Emmerton and Van Ortega, the couple who owned the unit on the 26th floor of a downtown Vancouver highrise, set up the hot tub in 2021 and came into conflict with their strata council soon after.
In the first decision on the case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal found the inflatable spa was patio furniture because it was easily movable and could be drained and deflated.
The strata challenged that ruling, seeking a judicial review in B.C. Supreme Court. The judge upheld the tribunal's decision, finding the strata had no authority to order the couple to remove the hot tub or to fine them for breaching bylaws.
But the appeal court came to a different conclusion.
The judges found the ones rendered previously were "patently unreasonable," mainly because they interpreted the bylaw allowing patio furniture in a manner that was "far away from (its) plain and ordinary meaning."
The court considered the issue of "moveability" and found that when filled with water the hot tub – which has a capacity of 900 litres – would weigh nearly a ton.
"When filled the hot tub is not moveable. Its moveability, as found by the tribunal, depended on reducing the tub to a folded item. The tribunal found that the hot tub could be inflated and deflated in five minutes, and found, without evidence of the drainage time, that it could be drained relatively quickly," the decision said.
The actual process by which the hot tub could be drained was something the appeal court found was not given proper consideration in the previous decisions, along with the issue of the impact of a "catastrophic failure" on the patio and other common property managed by the strata.
Rather than ordering the case to be sent back to the tribunal for reconsideration, the appeal court dismissed the claim entirely.
Emmerton and Ortega did not participate in the latest proceedings, with the court noting they no longer own the condo.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING BMO online service outages reported by customers
Dozens of Bank of Montreal customers said they faced website outages early Wednesday morning, according to reports.
W5 Investigates How a clothes donation bin company passed itself off as a charity, while donated items were put up for sale
In part two of a four-part investigation into the seedy underbelly of the lucrative clothing donation bin industry, CTV W5 uses trackers tp reveal a for-profit operation masquerading as a charity.
Does the updated COVID-19 vaccine protect against the XEC variant?
The XEC strain, a hybrid of Omicron subvariants KS.1.1 and KP.3.3, was first detected in Canada in mid-August and the number of COVID-19 cases with the XEC variant has rapidly increased.
Unspecified number of Liberal MPs set to confront Trudeau, ask him to step down
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will face down his own caucus members in a hotly anticipated meeting this morning, as several of them plan to try to convince him to step aside.
'Unbelievably violent': Gisele Pelicot, French victim of mass rape, takes the stand
Gisele Pelicot, the 72-year-old victim of mass rape whose ordeal has shocked the world, told a trial in southern France on Wednesday that she was determined that making her case public should help other women and change society.
Halifax police confirm body of Walmart employee was found in walk-in oven
Police have confirmed the body of an employee who died at a Walmart in Halifax over the weekend was found in a walk-in oven.
'Prayers are needed': Father and children who suffered severe burns in Springfield, Ont. fire undergo surgery
A father and his two children who suffered severe burns in a Springfield, Ont. house fire have undergone surgery.
Bank of Canada to release interest rate decision, economic forecast today
The Bank of Canada is set to make its latest interest rate decision this morning.
American Airlines fined US$50M over mishandling of disabled passengers and wheelchairs
The U.S. government fined American Airlines $50 million for failing to provide wheelchair assistance to passengers with disabilities and damaging thousands of wheelchairs over a five-year period.