B.C. parents file lawsuit against Irish nanny for quitting on short notice, withdraw claim
Two parents filed a lawsuit in B.C. Supreme Court last week seeking damages from their former nanny, alleging she quit on short notice and "never said goodbye to the children."
In response to an interview request from CTV News, the father, Vancouver-based lawyer David Aaron, said his family is not going forward with the civil claim. He has not responded to a follow-up question asking why their lawsuit was withdrawn.
Employment lawyer Lia Moody said B.C. workers are rarely sued for resigning without ample notice, as there’s little financial incentive for employers to do so.
“Wrongful resignation isn’t really a thing, and that’s because the damages are so minor,” Moody said.
'Tenderly bond' with nanny
The family’s lawsuit alleged the nanny, identified as an expat from Ireland, broke a contract she signed in September, in which she agreed to care for their young children, ages two and four, until early December.
She initially provided her services – Monday to Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., at a rate of $20 an hour – before abruptly quitting on Sunday, Oct. 20, according to the claim.
While giving her resignation, the nanny cited an incident from two days prior, when she had been sent home early.
The nanny told Aaron she “thought she might be coming down with a cold” that Friday, and he responded by asking that she “excuse herself” to avoid getting the children sick, per the family’s claim.
Aaron said he communicated the request to the nanny “in a manner that was caring, courteous and professional," and the family promptly paid her after receiving an invoice that evening, which included a paid sick day.
The nanny’s decision not to return left the parents “without the ability to attend to their vocational responsibilities, with a resulting loss of opportunity to earn professional income and meet their financial commitments,” according to the lawsuit, which sought both general and punitive damages.
The parents also said their children had formed a “tenderly bond” with the nanny in the five weeks she worked for them, and that her departure left them “abandoned in relation to a child-care provider with whom they had … an expectation of ongoing care and connection.”
None of the allegations in the lawsuit were tested in court, and the nanny had not filed a response by the time it was withdrawn.
Contract terms key, lawyer says
Unlike some provinces, B.C. does not require employees to give a set amount of notice before quitting their jobs – but that doesn’t necessarily mean they have no obligations to their employers.
Some companies include a minimum notice period in their contracts, Moody warned, which would make quitting on the spot a breach of the agreed-upon terms.
“If there is no contract, there’s still going to be a common-law obligation for employees to provide reasonable notice,” the lawyer added.
But crucially, employers hoping to recoup damages in court related to a worker's resignation must prove that damages were actually suffered.
“Employees have the right to quit,” Moody said. “So unless the employer incurs a significant amount of expense to find a replacement in a short period of time, they’re just not going to be able to establish damages – and so the whole point of the lawsuit would be fruitless.”
Those damages must also be above and beyond what the employer saved by not paying the worker’s salary, Moody added.
“Nine times out of 10, the damages incurred are zero dollars,” she said.
Avoiding backlash for quitting
The employment lawyer told CTV News she’s unaware of any successful court cases for “wrongful resignation” in the province, but that workers who want to avoid the stress of a potential lawsuit can still help protect themselves by giving one or two weeks’ notice before quitting.
If that’s not possible – perhaps because the employee has already accepted another job offer and is starting soon – they can offer to help their former employer through the transition period, Moody said.
The offer could be as simple as providing a testimonial for future job applicants.
“That will help optically in any sort of defence against a damages claim,” Moody said.
The lawyer also stressed there are some situations – such as an employer harassing their employee in the workplace – that remove any obligation to provide advanced notice before leaving.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canada's inflation rate jumps back to 2%, likely curbing large rate-cut bets
Canada's annual inflation rate accelerated more than expected to 2.0 per cent in October as gas prices fell less than the previous month, data showed on Tuesday, likely diluting chances of another large rate cut in December.
Cargo plane goes off the runway at Vancouver International Airport
A jet carrying Amazon packages went off the runway at Vancouver International Airport Tuesday morning.
Toddler dies from drug toxicity in Niagara Falls, Ont.
A 40-year-old woman is facing charges in the death of a toddler who was found without vital signs in a Niagara Falls, Ont., home last year. Niagara regional police say officers found the two-year-old child after they were called to a home on Nov. 21, 2023.
Watch 'Thought it was part of special effects': Cruise ship tilts as 'Titanic' song plays
Cruise ship passengers got a scare when their vessel tilted sideways, with one man saying the theme song for the film 'Titanic' had played during the ordeal.
Ex-husband of mass rape victim Gisele Pelicot set to speak in court
Gisele Pelicot, subjected to mass rape organized by her husband over 10 years, on Tuesday condemned the cowardice of the dozens of men accused of abusing her who claim they didn't realize it was rape, adding France's patriarchal society must change.
E. coli: Carrots recalled in Canada
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency has posted a recall for both baby and whole organic carrot brands sold at multiple grocery stores due to E. coli contamination.
BREAKING Man armed with knife on U of M campus: Winnipeg police
The Winnipeg Police Service (WPS) is warning the public about a male armed with a knife at the U of M campus.
Paul Teal, actor from 'One Tree Hill,' dead at age 35
Paul Teal, a film and TV actor known best for his role in the CW's teen soap 'One Tree Hill,' has died, according to a statement from his agent Susan Tolar Walters. He was 35.
'Bomb cyclone' to bring high winds to the B.C. coast
Environment Canada is warning those living on the B.C. coast to be prepared for incoming wild weather.