B.C. judge denies status for victims' families in Pickton evidence application
![Lorelei Williams Lorelei Williams, whose cousin Tanya Holyk was murdered by serial killer Robert Pickton and aunt Belinda Williams went missing in 1978, wears a t-shirt bearing their photographs as she and her dance troupe Butterflies in Spirit wait to perform after responding to the report on the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, in Vancouver, on Monday June 3, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2023/12/11/lorelei-williams-1-6682320-1702311887853.jpg)
A Supreme Court judge has dismissed applications by relatives of Robert Pickton's victims to intervene in court proceedings over the RCMP's plans to destroy evidence from the investigation into the serial killer.
But Justice Frits Verhoeven says the families are to be notified of any RCMP applications to dispose of evidence and the court may grant them "a limited right of audience, if deemed necessary and appropriate."
Lawyer Jason Gratl, who represents the victims' relatives, says his clients are "not unhappy" with Monday's decision, and the right to be notified and heard when appropriate is "sufficient" for their purposes.
Gratl's clients are involved in nine lawsuits against the late killer and his brother, David Pickton.
The applicants had claimed the pending lawsuits gave them a direct interest in the outcome of the proceedings, in which the RCMP is applying for directions from the court about procedures for evidence destruction.
Pickton, who died in May after being attacked in a Quebec prison, was convicted in 2007 on six counts of second-degree murder but is suspected of killing many more women who went missing from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside.
Justice for Girls, an advocacy group that opposes the destruction of evidence, withdrew their own application for intervener status before the start of the proceedings.
Sue Brown, the group's director of advocacy, confirmed the move in an interview last month.
"The court, at the end of the day, cannot order the RCMP to investigate these unsolved cases, they can only order the preservation of evidence and what we really need is a commitment politically from elected officials who are capable of ordering an investigation into the unsolved cases," she said.
There has been no indication that police plan to re-open the investigation.
But, Brown said, that is their goal.
"We think we need to take this to the elected officials, whether provincially or federally, to put pressure on the RCMP and we want to see the RCMP recommit resources and properly investigate these cases," she said in the June interview.
"At a bare minimum, they should be retesting those exhibits to see if they can identify the DNA of other missing women's cases who've never been tied to the farm."
RCMP have not yet applied to the court for disposal of any items, Monday's intervener ruling said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 16, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7014061.1724668701!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Canada to restrict low-wage foreign workers, consider lower immigration targets
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is urging businesses to hire Canadians as his government announces new restrictions to limit low-wage temporary foreign workers.
Park'N Fly data breach included personal information of 1M Canadian customers, company says
A popular airport parking service is warning approximately one million Canadian customers that their personal information may have been compromised in a widespread data breach last month.
Harris and Trump squabble over muted mics at upcoming debate
The campaigns of U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump are arguing in advance of their high-stakes Sept. 10 debate over whether microphones should be muted except for the candidate whose turn it is to speak.
After losing her job, she convinced her husband to move to Mexico and open up a B&B. Here's what happened next
After years of traveling together, Brooke and Rick Gazer, both from Canada, were used to staying in interesting places.
Police warn of new banking scam
Provincial police and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre are raising awareness about new variations of banking scams.
A former Toronto Blue Jay is set to make baseball history today. Here's how
Boston Red Sox catcher Danny Jansen is enjoying his odd slice of baseball history as he prepares to become the first major league player to appear in the same game for both teams.
Ice cave collapse in Iceland kills 1 tourist and leaves 2 missing
Icelandic rescuers worked by hand Monday to cut through the remnants of a collapsed ice cave as they searched for two tourists missing for more than 24 hours since a glacier in the southeastern part of the island caved in, killing one person and severely injured another.
Charges withdrawn against Toronto cops accused of failing to properly investigate murdered woman's disappearance
Nearly seven years after the family of Tess Richey found her remains in a stairwell in Toronto, professional misconduct charges against two of the police officers initially tasked with investigating her disappearance have been withdrawn.
Things a cybersecurity expert says they would never do
How can you protect your personal information and privacy? CTVNews.ca spoke to a cybersecurity expert on how to better safeguard against the evolving landscape of cyber threats.