B.C. woman says renovation team damaged her tanning bed, claims more than $900 in compensation
A B.C. woman won't be getting the hundreds of dollars she sought through the province's Civil Resolution Tribunal to replace a damaged tanning bed and missing stepladder.
Julia Rehill filed a claim with CRT alleging employees of Lonestar Construction Ltd. used her tanning bed as a workbench while completing renovations in her rented apartment.
The claim stemmed from "extensive" work done to Rehill's apartment between June 2022 and February 2023, at the request of her landlords. The tribunal heard Rehill moved into a temporary apartment while renovations were underway and left her tanning bed behind.
"Ms. Rehill says that Lonestar's employees used the tanning bed as a workbench and ultimately damaged it," Andrea Ritche, CRT vice-chair, said in her decision.
Ritchie wrote Rehill provided three witness statements from friends saying they saw workers using the tanning bed as a bench. But Lonestar denied damaging it and gave two witness statements from employees who were on site every day.
"Both employees deny causing any damage to the tanning bed, or otherwise touching it other than moving it out of the way when removing and replacing the flooring," Ritchie wrote.
Lonestar's owner, Benny Bruneau, shared a statement with the tribunal saying he told Rehill's landlords the apartment needed to be empty before the renovations began. When workers arrived, there was still a fridge and a mattress along with the tanning bed.
"After several conversations with the owners, Ms. Rehill removed the mattress and Lonestar’s employees helped her move the fridge, but she refused to move the tanning bed, despite Lonestar offering moving assistance," Ritchie's decision said. "Mr. Bruneau further states the tanning bed was used, yellowing, and in poor condition."
In an emailed statement sent to CTV News Vancouver, Rehill said she was told the tanning bed wasn't in the renovation team's way.
"Very little renovating happened in my apartment. There was no new flooring or walls done in the room it was in," Rehill's statement said, in part. "I was never asked to remove the bed and I saw the employees use it as a workbench and repeatedly had to tell one employee to stop sitting on it. I posted signs, they tore them down over and over again."
Along with damage to the tanning bed, Rehill claimed Lonestar removed her stepladder. But Lonestar said there wasn't a stepladder in the apartment when they began renovations and denies its workers saw or removed one. Lonestar also said there were workers from other companies in the apartment during the renovations.
In civil disputes like Rehill's, a decision is made based on the balance of probabilities, meaning Rehill had to prove her claims "more likely than not."
"Ms. Rehill does not address Lonestar’s submission that other tradespeople had access to the apartment, and why she believes it was Lonestar specifically who damaged the tanning bed and removed the stepladder," Ritchie wrote.
"Even if I did accept that Lonestar used the tanning bed as a workbench or lunch table, Ms. Rehill did not submit any photos of the alleged damage, nor any evidence of the cost to repair it such as correspondence from a technician."
Ritchie dismissed Rehill's claim for $908.48 – which included $573.49 for the tanning bed, $60 for a technician and $274.99 for a stepladder – saying that, on balance, she didn't prove her side of the dispute.
This story was updated to reflect a statement from Julia Rehill sent to CTV News Vancouver on March 7.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian former Olympic snowboarder wanted in Ontario double homicide: DOJ
A Canadian former Olympic snowboarder who is suspected of being the leader of a transnational drug trafficking group that operated in four countries is wanted for allegedly orchestrating the murder of an 'innocent' couple in Ontario in 2023, authorities say.
Ontario school board trustees under fire for $100K religious art purchase on Italy trip
Trustees with an Ontario school board are responding to criticism over a $45,000 trip to Italy, where they purchased more than $100,000 worth of religious statues.
A photographer snorkeled for hours to take this picture
Shane Gross, a Canadian marine conservation photojournalist, has won the title of Wildlife Photographer of the Year.
Tobacco giants would pay out $32.5 billion to provinces, smokers in proposed deal
Three tobacco giants are proposing to pay close to $25 billion to provinces and territories and more than $4 billion to some 100,000 Quebec smokers and their loved ones as part of a corporate restructuring process triggered by a long-running legal battle.
More Trudeau cabinet ministers not running for re-election, sources say shuffle expected soon
Federal cabinet ministers Filomena Tassi, Carla Qualtrough and Dan Vandal announced Thursday they will not run for re-election. Senior government sources tell CTV News at least one other, Marie-Claude Bibeau, doesn't plan to run again, setting the stage for Justin Trudeau to shuffle his cabinet in the coming weeks.
Robert Pickton's handwritten book seized after his death in hopes of uncovering new evidence
A handwritten book was seized from B.C. serial killer Robert Pickton's prison cell following his death earlier this year, raising hopes of uncovering new evidence in a series of unprosecuted murders.
Former members of One Direction say they're 'completely devastated' by Liam Payne's death
The former members of English boy band One Direction reacted publicly to the sudden death of their bandmate, Liam Payne, for the first time on Thursday, saying in a joint statement that they're 'completely devastated.'
Israel says it has killed top Hamas leader Yayha Sinwar in Gaza
Israeli forces in Gaza killed top Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, a chief architect of last year's attack on Israel that sparked the war, the military said Thursday. Troops appeared to have run across him unknowingly in a battle, only to discover afterwards that a body in the rubble was Israel's most wanted man.
Indian government employee charged in foiled murder-for-hire plot in New York City
The U.S. Justice Department announced criminal charges Thursday against an Indian government employee in connection with a foiled plot to kill a Sikh separatist leader living in New York City.