B.C. business' lawsuit against client who posted negative Google review allowed to proceed
A B.C. judge has decided to let a jury decide whether a single, negative online review of a dentistry practice was defamation, dismissing a bid to have the lawsuit tossed.
In a decision posted online last week, Justice Gordon S. Funt outlined his reasons for letting the case proceed.
The civil claim was brought by Smiley Kids Dental and Dr. Edward Chin and concerns a Google review posted in 2020.
"Dr. Chin had horrible customer service and treated our child with (zero) care. Very unimpressed,” it read.
The defendants, William Huang and Sophia Nim applied to have the case dismissed under Supreme Court Civil Rule 9-5, which allows the court to dismiss all or part of a claim that has no reasonable prospect of success.
At this stage in the process, Funt explained, the issue before him was only to decide whether the statement is "capable of being defamatory” and not whether it actually was.
"If the test is met, then the applications must be dismissed. It cannot be said that the plaintiffs’ claim is bound to fail," he wrote.
Funt explained that defamation is defined in law as published words that negatively impact one's reputation or expose someone to "hatred, contempt or ridicule."
The defendants argued that the review was not defamatory because "negative reviews for almost any business are common" and the post in question was "short, vague, subjective, and did not connote an ongoing problem," according to the decision.
The test, Funt explained, requires the court to decide how a "reasonable, right-thinking person" would interpret the words. The fact that Chin was named and that the dental practice's customer service was disparaged was enough to satisfy that criterion, he ruled.
"In my view, a reasonable, right-thinking person would not view the posting as silly, vague, vacuous, or just part of the uncouthness and boorishness frequently seen on the Internet," Funt wrote, adding that the review could lead to a negative perception of the practice among prospective clients.
The decision did not provide details on what damages are being sought. While the case could still be settled out of court, Funt's decision said "the collective wisdom of a jury is particularly well-suited to make the determination."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
‘I’ll make sure you live forever': Bill Vigars, the publicist responsible for promoting Terry Fox’s Marathon of Hope passes away
Vigars passed away peacefully in a B.C. hospital earlier this week. He was 78.
Picture-perfect engagement under Manitoba northern lights
Sometimes love is written in the stars, but for one couple, it’s written in the aurora borealis.
5 things not to say to a grieving friend
It’s almost impossible to know what to say to someone in the throes of grief. We all want to say something comforting. Very few of us know what that is.
Bomb threat sent to BC NDP campaign office on Vancouver Island
A BC NDP campaign office in Campbell River received a bomb threat Friday afternoon, according to the party.
Report says at least 55 children died or disappeared at B.C. residential school
A British Columbia First Nation says at least 55 children died or disappeared while attending a residential school near Williams Lake, more than triple the number recorded for the institution in the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation memorial register.
A vehicle dropping off a shooting victim struck 3 nurses, critically wounding 1
A vehicle fleeing a Philadelphia hospital after dropping off a gunshot victim early Saturday struck three nurses who were trying to treat the patient, injuring one critically, authorities said.
Longueuil woman charged after 10-year-old boy scalded with boiling water
A woman from Montreal's South Shore appeared in court on Friday on charges of aggravated assault after allegedly scalding a 10-year-old boy with boiling water more than one week ago.
Murder charges for two men in connection with Old Montreal fire
Two young men are facing second-degree murder charges in connection with the fatal fire in Old Montreal that killed Léonor Geraudie, 43, and her daughter Vérane Reynaud-Geraudie on Oct. 4.
Possible Listeria contamination leads to the recall of Rana brand sauce: CFIA
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) has issued a recall for Rana brand Tagliatelle Seasoned White Chicken and Mushroom sauce, citing possible Listeria contamination.