Expert doubts body-worn cameras will increase Vancouver police accountability
There's little reason to believe body-worn cameras will increase accountability or transparency among Vancouver police, according to an expert who has followed the implementation of the devices across Canada and the U.S.
Christopher Schneider, a sociology professor at Manitoba's Brandon University, has published several peer-reviewed papers on body-worn cameras, and said there is "inconsistent" evidence that the devices reduce the amount of force used by police or the number of civilian complaints against officers.
"Could body-worn cameras work? I think we could take steps in that direction," Schneider said. "The actual evidence suggests they don't work, at least in the way they're being utilized now."
While some controlled experiments have found use of force decreased when officers were wearing the devices, others counter-intuitively found use of force actually increased, Schneider said.
"We need to be honest with ourselves when we talk about body-worn cameras," the researcher added. "Largely it's being used for the benefit of the police."
ENHANCING PUBLIC TRUST
On Thursday, the Vancouver Police Department launched a pilot project to equip 85 officers in the downtown core and east side with body-worn cameras for six months.
At a news conference, Deputy Chief Howard Chow said his department has been advocating for body-worn cameras for years, and that authorities hope the program will both "enhance public trust" in law enforcement and "protect officers from false or vexatious complaints."
Chow said the department consulted with numerous stakeholders, including two B.C. police watchdogs, Indigenous groups, LGBTQ2S+ groups, and the province's privacy commissioner when deciding how to implement the devices.
Authorities ultimately chose to keep the cameras dormant until an officer activates them.
"We appreciate that some people in our community may feel uneasy about being recorded," Chow said. "We've reached a balance that protects people's rights and their privacy."
But letting officers decide when to use the devices defeats much of the reason for using them, Schneider argued.
"If the police can turn off the camera, or turn it on using their individual discretion, this in essence negates any serious conversations about police accountability," he said.
The cameras do continuously pick up 30 seconds of video when dormant, and that short video is saved once an officer activates the device – though there is no sound on that portion of the recording.
Videos will then be held for 13 months before they're automatically deleted, unless they contain evidence of a crime or if there is a pending complaint against an officer.
REPERCUSSIONS FOR MISUSE
Under the Vancouver Police Department's guidelines for the pilot project, officers "shall" activate their cameras whenever they have a "reasonable belief" they will be using force, or whenever a suspect is expected to be "violent or aggressive" – but there are currently no repercussions for officers who fail to do so.
Determining how to handle those situations is one of the aims of the pilot project, Chow said.
"It's going to be a learning process," he added.
Schneider acknowledged there are circumstances when an officer should be able to turn their camera off – when interviewing sexual assault victims, young offenders or police informants, for instance – but urged authorities to consider serious consequences for officers who abuse their discretion, up to and including termination.
In many jurisdictions, the repercussions for switching the devices off are much less serious than they would be for using excessive force, Schneider said, which he argued incentivizes misuse.
"Maybe they get docked a day's pay," he said. "They get in trouble but it's mostly inconsequential."
WHO GETS TO VIEW THE VIDEO?
Authorities have confirmed officers will be allowed to review recordings while documenting police incidents and preparing reports for Crown counsel.
Schneider said this gives police an opportunity to "get their story straight" following a contentious incident involving members of the public, and before a matter reaches trial.
"It gives police an advantage in controlling the narrative about a particular incident," he said.
Meanwhile, civilians who are recorded must file a Freedom of Information request – a process that is notoriously plagued by delays – in order to view video of their interactions with police.
"Is that really consistent with transparency?" Schneider said. "I would argue no."
In order to ensure body-worn cameras provide a public benefit, Schneider suggested the public be involved in shaping the police department's policies.
"Allow the public to define what 'accountability' means, allow the public to define what 'transparency' means, and allow the public to contribute to the development of policies and regulations and rules surrounding the use of the body-worn camera devices," the researcher said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6977430.1721929538!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'There's mom and dad's house': New video appears to show destruction of Jasper neighbourhood
Video posted to social media on Thursday morning appears to show the charred remains of a Jasper, Alta., neighbourhood.
LIVE UPDATES Multiple homes, businesses 'lost' to wildfire in Jasper National Park: Parks Canada
Officials from Parks Canada and Jasper say "multiple structures, including a number of businesses and homes, in and around the town of Jasper, have been lost" to wildfire in Jasper National Park.
Prince William's 2023 salary revealed in new report
Newly released financial reports show that William, the Prince of Wales, drew a salary of $42.1 million last fiscal year, his first since inheriting the vast and lucrative Duchy of Cornwall.
Alberta premier says a third, perhaps half, of all Jasper buildings destroyed by fire
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says early reports indicate a third and perhaps up to half of all buildings in the historic Rocky Mountain resort town of Jasper have been destroyed in a wildfire.
Canada to bring home fewest Olympic medals since 2012, according to forecaster
Fewer Canadians are expected to reach the Paris podium than in the previous two Olympic Summer Games, a global data analytics company predicts.
Jennifer Aniston criticizes JD Vance for 'childless cat ladies' remarks: 'I pray that your daughter is fortunate enough to bear children'
Jennifer Aniston is criticizing JD Vance for comments he made in his past about women without children.
'Skibidi Toilet:' If you don't know what it is, you will
'Skibidi Toilet' is already an internet sensation and now its about to get even more exposure after the YouTube series is being developed for TV and film, according to a report by Variety.
NASA says no return date yet for astronauts and Boeing capsule at space station
Already more than a month late getting back, two NASA astronauts will remain at the International Space Station until engineers finish working on problems plaguing their Boeing capsule, officials said Thursday.
French sprinter will wear a cap during Olympic opening ceremony after hijab dispute is resolved
French sprinter Sounkamba Sylla will be allowed to participate in the opening ceremony at the Paris Olympics wearing a cap to cover her hair, an agreement reached with the French Olympic Committee after Sylla said she was barred because of her hijab.