Court falls silent for two minutes in B.C. murder trial of Ibrahim Ali
Warning: This story contains disturbing details.
The B.C. Supreme Court first-degree murder trial of Ibrahim Ali fell silent for two full minutes as Crown attorney Daniel Porte neared the end of his closing arguments.
Porte was illustrating how long it would have taken Ali to strangle the 13-year-old girl he's accused of killing in a Burnaby, B.C., park six years ago, saying Ali would have had to apply “consistent and sustained” pressure.
“Ibrahim Ali strangled (the girl) for at least that long with his hands or another item around her neck,” he told the jury Thursday, citing the coroner's testimony.
“When you strangle someone for a minimum of two minutes and for most of that time, the person is unconscious, it can only be for one reason: to kill them or cause bodily harm you know is likely to kill them.”
Ali pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder in April.
Porte summarized for the jury the evidence of more than four dozen Crown witnesses who testified during the almost nine-month trial.
The body of the girl, whose name is protected by a publication ban, was found in Burnaby's Central Park in July 2017, just hours after her mother reported her missing.
Porte told the jury that the Crown had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Ali dragged the girl into a wooded area, sexually assaulted her, then killed her.
However, Ali's lawyer Kevin McCullough told the jury the charge against his client hadn't been proven.
Their decision should be about facts, not emotions, he said.
“Emotional decisions have no place in a jury room. The cold, hard facts and the treatment of the cold, hard facts through the lens of truth beyond a reasonable doubt, that is your job.”
The jury they could not find Ali guilty of murder simply because he was 27-year-old man having sex with a 13-year-old girl, McCullough said.
Evidence that Ali murdered the girl was nonexistent, he said.
He said the teen's death created a media storm and “come hell or high water there had to be a murder charge. Someone has to pay and we'd all sleep better at night.”
McCullough told the jury there were no witnesses who could connect Ali to the park or to the girl's death.
“Juror deliberations (are) not the time to come up with your own theory,” he said, adding if they found themselves doing that, then Crown had not proven its case.
Porte, the Crown attorney, referred in his closing statement to the testimony from Christine Crossman, an RCMP forensic biologist, who said Ali's DNA was found inside the body of the girl. Only the DNA of the girl and Ali was found, Porte emphasized.
“The only reasonable conclusion is the person who sexually assaulted (the girl) is also the person who killed her,” he said.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Jason Morin, who conducted the autopsy, had told the jury the girl had been strangled and had numerous injuries on her body.
Porte reminded the jury that Morin had testified that “ejaculate is fluid subject to gravity,” and that had the girl stood afterward, the semen would run out of the body and onto her underwear and shorts.
He noted the state of her body when it was found. Referencing police testimony and crime scene photographs, Porte said she was found lying on her back, with her shirt and sports bra pulled up exposing one breast, he said. He added that her shorts were partially down, exposing her genital area.
In his final address to the jury, he summarized the Crown's theory.
“You should have no difficulty concluding that Ibrahim Ali attacked (the girl) on the path, where she dropped her phone and wallet. He forced her into the woods, which were surrounded by brush, pulled her shirt partway off (and) removed her shorts,” Porte said.
“His sexual assault of her included penetration, during which he ejaculated inside of her. During the course of this sexual assault, or shortly afterward, he strangled (the girl), killing her. ”
He left her body where it was found by police, Porte said.
Motive was not relevant, Porte said, but he added there was no evidence the girl and Ali knew each other.
“Any suggestion they knew each other or had any type of communication, in the Crown's view, would be speculation,” Porte said.
Ali's lawyer Kevin McCullough told the jury last week that they would not be calling any evidence in defence of the allegations because the Crown hadn't proven its case.
Justice Lance Bernard told the jury Thursday that closing statements from the defence were likely to continue into Friday.
The judge will then give his final instructions to the jury before members begin their deliberations.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 30, 2023.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Former PM Chretien says Liberal party must move back to 'radical centre'
As the Liberal party searches for a new leader, former prime minister Jean Chretien says it's time for the party to move back to the "radical centre" to help its electoral fortunes.
Are there U.S. military bases and American troops in Canada?
The U.S. military has more than 165,000 troops deployed in over 170 countries and territories, including Canada.
Trudeau says Trump's comments on 51st state 'flattering' but a 'non-starter'
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says talk of Canada becoming the 51st state is a distraction from more pressing threats of U.S tariffs on Canada and their likely impact.
Florence Girard was 55 pounds when she starved in home-share. Her sister wants change
The sister of a British Columbia woman with Down syndrome who starved to death in a Port Coquitlam home in 2018 says she believes more people will die if systemic changes aren't made to how people with developmental disabilities are treated.
Vance says Jan. 6 participants who committed violence 'obviously' shouldn't be pardoned
Vice President-elect JD Vance says people responsible for the violence during the Capitol riot “obviously” should not be pardoned, as President-elect Donald Trump is promising to use his clemency power on behalf of many of those who tried on Jan. 6, 2021, to overturn the results of the election that Trump lost.
'Everything is on the table': Joly won't rule out cutting off energy exports to U.S. in face of Trump tariff threat
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly is not ruling out any countermeasures when it comes to dealing with U.S. president-elect Donald Trump — his threat of significant tariffs on Canadian imports, in particular.
Los Angeles tree lovers hope their vital work recovers from devastating fires
Some people across Los Angeles have worked for years to increase the number of trees that give respite from heat and air pollution.
Teen allegedly hit by vehicle while being pulled on GT Racer: OPP
Police in Orillia are investigating an incident that left a 14-year-old in the hospital after they were injured while being pulled on a GT Racer.
Royal treasures hidden since Second World War recovered from cathedral
Historical treasures hidden for decades have been uncovered in the crypts of a cathedral, with items including burial crowns and insignia belonging to Medieval European rulers.