B.C. woman who sought $5K from neighbour over noise ordered to pay $50 for nuisance
A British Columbia woman who unsuccessfully sued her downstairs neighbour last fall for making too much noise has now failed in a bid to sue her upstairs neighbour for being too loud.
B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal rejected Linda Woo's claim seeking $5,000 in damages for lost productivity and medical expenses from upstairs neighbour Lorenzo Bruno. The tribunal instead ordered Woo to pay Bruno $50 in nuisance damages for her "unreasonable ceiling-tapping and cupboard-slamming" in response to the noises.
The dispute began shortly after Bruno moved into the strata building in July 2022. Since that time, Woo lodged more than 300 noise complaints with the building's strata council and police, who twice described the noises as her neighbour "just going about his life," according to the tribunal's decision last week.
Woo proceeded with a lawsuit claiming "near-daily unreasonable noise" from her upstairs neighbour, including stomping, dragging furniture, loud guests and running appliances during quiet hours.
Bruno filed a counterclaim, arguing Woo's constant complaints to the strata and police amounted to harassment for which he was entitled to compensation.
The tribunal had dismissed a similar $5,000 claim from Woo last October, when she alleged noise from her downstairs neighbour caused injury to her dignity, loss of enjoyment of her home, and mental and physical suffering.
'Simply no noise'
To support her claim against Bruno, Woo submitted audio and video recordings of the alleged noise from Bruno's condo, instructing the tribunal to listen to the recordings "with earbuds and with the volume at maximum," according to tribunal member Megan Stewart.
"Some of the recordings are completely silent, which suggests the files may have been corrupted, or there was simply no noise," Stewart wrote.
"I find that of those recordings where noise can be heard, the majority reflect only very faint or muffled single-impact noises that appear to reflect everyday living, or soft background humming."
Woo also submitted recordings of phone calls with police and officer attendance reports, however "none of the reports say there was unreasonable noise," according to the tribunal.
In one recorded call with police, Woo admitted she "poked" her ceiling and slammed her cupboard in response to alleged noise from Bruno's suite, "so that he would understand" the annoyance.
"I find this deliberate noise was likely loud enough to cause a disturbance," Stewart wrote, ordering Woo to pay Bruno $50 for the disruption.
The tribunal could not similarly corroborate Woo's claims that noises from Bruno's condo constituted a nuisance.
"Though I accept the noises Ms. Woo hears bother her, I do not agree that on an objective basis she has shown they rise to the level of negligence or nuisance," Stewart wrote.
"Living in a strata building involves some degree of give and take among neighbours when it comes to noise and other potential nuisances," she concluded, dismissing the claim.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
4 charged with manslaughter, forcible confinement in Burnaby 19-year-old's death: IHIT
More than a year after a Burnaby man was killed during a home invasion, charges have been laid against four suspects for their alleged involvement in the fatal incident.
Ottawa woman dies after battle with pancreatic cancer
An Ottawa woman who raised more than $500,000 for cancer research at the Ottawa Hospital has died after a lengthy battle with pancreatic cancer.
Northern Ontario beekeeper says she lost nearly 2 million bees this season
CTV News Northern Ontario provides and update on the story of more than 1.5 million bees be lost earlier this summer.
How a false rumour about pets in Ohio and Laura Loomer’s presence helped derail Trump’s planned attacks on Harris
Donald Trump wanted to spend this week attacking one of Democratic rival Kamala Harris' biggest political vulnerabilities. Instead, he spent most of the week falsely claiming that migrants are eating pets in a small town in Ohio and defending his embrace of a far-right agitator whose presence is causing concern among his allies.
Andrew Scheer avoids answering if Conservatives will cancel dental care program
Conservative House Leader Andrew Scheer won't say whether his party will scale back or fully scrap Canada's federal dental care program, despite new data showing nearly 650,000 Canadians have used the plan.
'We're at a high degree of spread': What you need to know about COVID-19 in Ontario
As we head into another respiratory illness season, here’s a look at where Ontario stands when it comes to COVID-19 and what you need to know.
A landslide triggered a 650-foot mega-tsunami in Greenland. Then came something inexplicable
It started with a melting glacier that set off a huge landslide, which triggered a 650-foot high mega-tsunami in Greenland last September. Then came something inexplicable: a mysterious vibration that shook the planet for nine days.
Staff member hospitalized after assault at B.C. maximum security prison
A corrections officer at B.C.'s only maximum security federal prison was taken to hospital after an assault earlier this month.
Jane's Addiction concert ends early after Perry Farrell throws punch at Dave Navarro
A scuffle between members of the groundbreaking alternative rock band Jane’s Addiction came amid 'tension and animosity' during their reunion tour, lead singer Perry Farrell’s wife said Saturday.