Vancouver landlord must pay former tenants $21K for wrongful eviction, court says in upholding RTB ruling
![Eviction notice - generic This stock image shows a door with an eviction notice on it. (Credit: Shutterstock)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2023/10/13/eviction-notice---generic-1-6600756-1697233238425.jpg)
A Vancouver landlord has lost her appeal of a ruling that ordered her to pay former tenants $21,600 as compensation for their wrongful eviction.
The B.C. Supreme Court ruled on the case Thursday, describing the circumstances that led to the eviction and the dispute that followed.
Tejinder Sidhoo, who owns a home with two rental units in the city's West End, notified the renters – who had lived in the suite for about six years – that they were being evicted so her daughter could move in.
"The tenants moved out by April 1, 2020. However, they later learned that the daughter was not living in the rental unit and they believed she had never moved in," Justice F. Matthew Kirchner wrote in the decision, adding that the tenants filed a dispute notice with the Residential Tenancy Branch contesting their eviction.
B.C.'s Residential Tenancy Act allows for evictions in the event that a landlord plans to move a close family member into a unit, provided they give two months’ notice. If a tenant challenges the eviction, the onus is on the landlord to prove that their family member not only moved in but stayed in the suite for six months.
The RTB, in this case, found the landlord had not proven that her daughter lived in the suite for the required six months and awarded the tenants one year's worth of rent. The evidence considered included evidence from the residents of the other unit in the house that no one moved in in April of 2020 and that a "For Rent” sign went up a few months later.
Sidhoo appealed the decision, saying the RTB had failed to admit evidence that would establish an exemption from the requirement to compensate the former tenants based on extenuating circumstances.
The landlord said her daughter's move to Vancouver was delayed by two months due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and that once she did arrive she lost her job and had to move to another city three months later for work. These factors, Sidhoo argued, prevented her daughter from moving in when she was supposed to and staying for the required six months.
Sidhoo said documents showing this were not admitted as evidence in the RTB hearing, but that they should have been.
"The landlord also argues that she was not permitted to lead certain oral testimony and make arguments relating to extenuating circumstances that purportedly explain why the daughter did not occupy the rental unit," Kirchner's decision said.
Essentially, Sidhoo was arguing that because the RTB decision did not address or make a determination on the issue of extenuating circumstances it should be dismissed and a new hearing should be ordered.
The judge was not persuaded.
"I have found the landlord’s affidavit evidence lacking credibility as to what was argued or sought to be argued at the hearing. I am not persuaded that extenuating circumstances were advanced as a serious issue. Consequently, I am not persuaded the Arbitrator’s decision was patently unreasonable for failing to address that issue in the reasons," Kirchner wrote.
"However, even if extenuating circumstances had been asserted as part of the Landlord’s response, I find the result would not have been any different."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6945819.1719614720!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Tenants in 16-floor apartment building in Ottawa's west-end served eviction notices
More than 100 people in Ottawa's west-end are in the process of receiving eviction notices to vacate their 50-year-old apartment building for renovations.
WestJet cancels at least 150 flights following mechanics union strike
WestJet says it's cancelled at least 150 flights beginning Saturday after the union maintaining the airline's planes announced it went on strike hours earlier.
Health Canada recalls brand of sunscreen product due to potential fungal contamination
Double check your sunscreen products before lathering up this long weekend, as Health Canada has recalled several lots across the country.
opinion Practical tips for seniors who want to supplement their retirement income
Are you retired and looking for some ideas to help make some extra money? Personal finance contributor Christopher Liew has some tips to help you earn some income in your golden years.
The small French town where Newfoundlanders were heroes
It was a battle ripped from the pages of a storybook: Ten soldiers held off hundreds of German troops to save a small French village in the First World War.
Ontario woman loses $1,000 deposit in cottage rental scam
For many, the Canada Day long weekend is the official kick off of summer and many families will be spending time at a cottage.
As fall elections loom, are fears for the state of democracy in Canada justified?
Is Canada's democracy truly under threat? Political scientists say while Canadian politics and institutions are facing a myriad of concerns, the situation isn't dire overall.
Driver charged with DUI for New York nail salon crash that killed 4 and injured 9
A minivan slammed into a Long Island nail salon Friday, killing four people and injuring 9, a Suffolk County fire official said.
'We need new leadership': Liberal MP writes to caucus, says Justin Trudeau should resign
A sitting Liberal MP has written to the federal caucus to say he thinks Prime Minister Justin Trudeau should resign. 'For the future of our party and for the good of our country we need new leadership and a new direction,' said New Brunswick MP Wayne Long in the brief note.