'Too many gaps': Defence pokes holes in Crown's theory at Kane Carter murder trial
A defence lawyer for the man accused of shooting and killing an innocent teenager and a rival gang member in January of 2018 says the Crown failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that his client was the second gunman who fired the fatal shots.
“There’s simply too many gaps in the evidence, gaps in time, gaps in people’s memories,” said Richard Fowler.
His client, 28-year-old Kane Carter, is charged with the second-degree murders of 15-year-old Alfred Wong – an innocent passerby – and 23-year-old Kevin Whiteside, an alleged gang member.
The Crown’s theory is that on the evening of Jan. 13, 2018, Carter was the lone occupant of a burgundy Pontiac Montana van parked south of the intersection of Broadway and Ontario Street. He was there with the intent to protect his associate Matthew Navas-Rivas, who was at Indochine restaurant.
Prosecutors say Carter was working in a "middle management" role for a drug operation Navas-Rivas was running.
The Crown says as Navas-Rivas and his girlfriend left the restaurant, Whiteside opened fire at around 9:16 p.m. shooting several rounds at them. Prosecutors believe that’s when Carter, from the van, fired at Whiteside, killing both him and Wong, who was riding in the back seat of his parents' car as they drove along Broadway.
Fowler brought up how there was no evidence that Navas-Rivas knew there was a target on his back, and that phone records showed that there were no texts or calls made between him and Carter in the hours leading up to the shootings.
“If this motive for Mr. Carter to be there is to protect Mr. Navas-Rivas, Mr. Navas-Rivas must have known for some need to be protected,” said Fowler. “There’s no evidence of that at all."
A former customer turned worker for the drug-dealing operation, Jackson Riley, testified during the trial that a van of the same make and model was used for drug deliveries.
The defence has acknowledged that the drug-dealing van and the van seen at the crime scene are, indeed, the same vehicle.
Riley testified that on the night of shootings, he was out driving the van when Carter called him at around 7:45 p.m., urgently telling him to bring the vehicle back to the Seymour Street condo building where the drug operation was based.
Riley said Carter departed in the van some time just after 8 p.m.
Video then shows the van parking on Ontario Street at around 8:30 p.m.
Fowler says there would have been plenty of time for Carter to drop the van off to someone else.
“There are multiple gaps in time,” he said.
Fowler also mentioned that the three bullet casings later found in the van were linked to a shooting in September of 2017 in Vancouver, while Carter was living in Ontario at that time.
“There’s actually no evidence before you that Mr. Carter had access to the type of gun likely used in these killings,” he said.
Supreme Court Justice Catherine Wedge is expected to charge the jury on Friday morning, before deliberations will begin.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Children's doctors reporting unusual increase in walking pneumonia cases in Canada
Children's hospitals across the country are seeing an unusual increase in the number of serious and more complicated cases of walking pneumonia affecting much younger patients, according to medical experts.
Teachers in Newfoundland and Labrador say violence is on the rise, averaging 22 incidents per school day
School staff are being struck more often, students are fighting more frequently, and police are increasingly being called to school grounds, according to data compiled and released this week by the Newfoundland and Labrador Teachers' Association.
'One of the most talked about words of 2024': This is Collins Dictionary's word of the year
Collins Dictionary has declared 'brat' -- the album title that became a summer-living ideal -- its 2024 word of the year.
Canada and the U.S. share the world's longest border. Here's how the election could affect it
Spend just a few minutes at the border between Canada and the U.S. – the world's longest – and you'll see why trade is a vital lifeline.
B.C. landlord who evicted longtime tenant, hiked rent and re-listed unit ordered to pay $16K
A landlord from B.C.’s Lower Mainland who evicted a longtime tenant only to rent out the same unit months later for more money has been ordered to compensate him $16,480.
'Stand by your sons, daughters': New Brunswick woman named national Silver Cross Mother
Maureen Anderson, who lost both her sons to their overseas service in the Canadian Armed Forces, has been named this year's national Silver Cross Mother.
Canada's youngest dangerous offender, who sexually assaulted baby, seeks prison leave
A convict who became Canada 's youngest designated dangerous offender after sexually assaulting a three-month-old baby is seeking escorted leave from prison to attend Indigenous cultural ceremonies in Vancouver.
opinion Prince Harry, Meghan Markle take a different tack this time to the U.S. election
With a divided electorate about to head to the polls after a dramatic presidential campaign, the Duke and Duchess of Sussex have taken a more neutral approach in the 2024 U.S. general election compared to 2020, writes royal commentator Afua Hagan in her column for CTVNews.ca.
Heidi Klum and Janelle Monae wear elaborate E.T. costumes for their Halloween parties
Heidi Klum and Janelle Monae opted for out-of-this-world Halloween costumes this year — both choosing to dress as the stubby alien E.T. for their parties on opposite coasts.